Business
U.S. corporate coalition to help Hungary eliminate labour shortage
Portfolio: At this year’s Brain Bar, you announced the creation of a new collaboration under the umbrella of the American Chamber of Commerce called U.S. Financial Institutions in Hungary. What is the purpose of this group?
Róbert Ésik (President, HIPA): HIPA welcomes the establishment of the “U.S Financial Institutions in Hungary" group, and we are happy to see that the U.S. investment community is gaining momentum in Hungary; although we are obviously not members of this organization, as we are not a financial institution. This group is important to us, because if these companies are successful in Budapest, it shows that the Hungarian talent pool is something you can build on and it might inspire more financial services companies to allocate their activities here. HIPA is an avid supporter of U.S. companies creating high value-added jobs in our country.
Portfolio: Why did you, as international financial institutions elect to establish your offices in Budapest?
Melanie Seymour (Managing Director, BlackRock Budapest): We came to Hungary because we were looking for an office that can take us into the next 30 years. It was really all about talent. What we were looking for is the creation of more and more opportunities for Hungarians, so that we can not only tap into the local resource pool but also help them remain in the country.

Melanie Seymour (BlackRock, left), Kevin Murray (Citi, right)
Kevin Murray (CEO, CEE-region, Citigroup): We opened our Budapest office in 1985 - at that time we saw Hungary as one of the more advanced countries: the country more receptive to allowing foreign ownership and the country with a dynamically developing financial market. In 2005, we opened our service center here, a key reason apart from cost, was the availability of talented people; people who are creative and forward thinking. We now employ around 2000 people in the service center, in addition to the 250-300 people who work on the banking side.
Norbert Fogarasi (CEO, Morgan Stanley Budapest): In 2006, Morgan Stanley opened its first office in Hungary with a complex operation; a mathematical modelling center. We decided to open a center in Hungary due to the openness of the local academic community. While there were other important factors - time zone, location, cost,- in the end, talent was absolutely the most important for us. We work together with other companies under the umbrella of U.S. Financial Institutions in Hungary, which is organized by the American Chamber of Commerce, to show that we can broaden the pool of available talent, whether this means attracting talent from abroad, returning Hungarians or collaborating closely with universities. I think the impact people can make from offices located in Budapest can be significant and the centers of excellence we have developed provide very unique career opportunities - this is why we have chosen to work together under the U.S. Financial Institutions umbrella, of which all four - institutions with a similar cultural mindset - are members.

From left to right: Norbert Fogarasi (Morgan Stanley), Melanie Seymour (BlackRock), Kevin Murray (Citi)
Ákos Janza (Managing Director, Operational Management, Head of Budapest Office, MSCI): When Our CEO and COO embarked on the spinoff of MSCI in 2007 from Morgan Stanley, they have chosen Budapest to be the focal point of IT infrastructure separation. Initially, we established an office here staffed by three people, who managed the transformation in the IT infrastructure side, then, in 2009, when I joined, we opened our quantitative financial arm as well. In 2009, there were about 63 people here, now we employ 450 people. We work on advanced financial analytics and modeling, software development and various corporate financial solutions. How do you combat the challenges posed by the tightening labor conditions in Hungary caused by growing wages and workforce scarcity?
Ákos Janza (MSCI): Let’s be honest, we combat each other for the best available talent out on the market. Labor shortage is one of the biggest problems we are facing and one of the most efficient tools for acquiring talent is luring them away from your competitors. Whilst we all going to continue to attract talent from each other, we collectively decided to work together to enlarge the pool. Our collaboration aims to raise the awareness of what unique propositions US financial institutions have in Hungary and that its worth to join our industry.

Ákos Janza (MSCI)
Norbert Fogarasi (Morgan Stanley): Over the 13 years Morgan Stanley has had a presence in Budapest, a big source of talent has been the universities - helping us to grow to over 2200 staff - and we are keen to do a lot more together. We want to ensure there are more programs for undergraduates to provide them with different career opportunities. However, I also think we need to look at creative ways to enlarge the talent pool: we can attract people from abroad, sometimes from outside the EU but also returning Hungarians. Morgan Stanley runs an internship program to aid the return of people into the workforce, who - for varying reasons - have left for a long period of time. I also think we need to take a look at retraining people with different qualifications who are interested in working with us. It can be advantageous to tap into these parts of the labor supply; university students for example may decide on a different career path after two or three years in employment. Finally, diversity is vital, and we had a conference last week with the American Chamber of Commerce at which we discussed attracting more women into finance. Did the reorganization of Citi affect the company’s methods to attract new talent?
Kevin Murray (Citi): Citi has taken a strategic decision to focus on its corporate and commercial banking businesses and sell its retail banking business in Hungary. It was a strategic decision, not necessarily one based on profitability of a single Branch’s business. The reorganization of Citi affected internal processes, among others the way how we attract new talents. When I arrived to Hungary, I experienced that the closure of our retail arm made people assume the entire bank closed. The fact is, that hundreds of people came to work at our service center since it opened in 2005, far more people who worked in the retail business. As a way of addressing this falls assumption we started to work on how we can increase our visibility in the country. To acquire talent, we deal with universities, such as the Óbuda University, where we teach classes in cybersecurity. We also teach financial courses at Corvinus, our partnership started about 15 years ago. Where we are also in the advisory board. We are also in some programs which involve young women in tech: we join the Girl in IT program where we go to grammar schools and talk to them about STEM-education and try to convince them that women in tech is the place to be. This April we joined for the fifth time in a row the initiative of the Association of Hungarian Women in Science to host a professional day for school girls aged between 12-18, who are interested in science and engineering. The purpose of this event was to help young ladies considering to choose a profession in technology or engineering related fields.

From left to right: Melanie Seymour (BlackRock), Kevin Murray (Citi), Ákos Janza (MSCI)
Is BlackRock facing any unique workforce-related challenges as a relatively new entrant in the Hungarian market? Melanie Seymour (BlackRock): Prior to my arrival in 2017, I experienced that normally a business card with “BlackRock managing director" on it opens doors, however, not many people here knew what BlackRock was, despite it being the largest asset manager in the world. The lack of preconceived ideas gave us the chance to be different. At the same time, we had a lot of support from the people at this table; we were able to learn from what they have already built up. So we have a lot of people that are similar, but different: from day one, we have been helping universities make their students to be more applicable in the workforce - we give them real projects instead of lectures or internships. We quickly realized that the local talent pool is relatively small, so we started looking for people with specific skillsets. I have the belief that if you have someone with the right mindset, behavior and the will to learn, the rest can be taught. 40% of our Budapest staff, around 520 people altogether, have no financial services experience. This of course, can be a challenge too; you have to have a very detailed training course to bring people up to speed. We also run a program to bring back Hungarians from abroad, we found that most of them left due to not being able to find the same career opportunities as in London or New York. This is not only our initiative any more, it runs across multiple companies in multiple industries. We are also looking at ways to reintegrate people into the workforce. I think the diversity in age is something that companies in general need to be better at handling, as people no longer retire, we will be getting three or four generations working at the same office.
How does HIPA support these American institutions in tackling the challenges of the Hungarian labor market?
Róbert Ésik (HIPA): Our primary role is to position Hungary as an ideal location for investments and for doing business. In addition to this, we provide management consultancy services to investors and prospective investors. This is how we got in contact with BlackRock, when they were conducting a site selection process in the region and have been supporting them with information and advice. As part of our consultancy services we try to identify the pain points of our clients and try to respond to those needs, whether that means providing information, discussions or partnering with educational institutions, or organizing events. On top of this, we are involved in policy advocacy: we aim to provide political decision makers with information on how to improve the business climate and the competitiveness in Hungary. We spend most of our time conducting discussions with foreign enterprises and investors and relay their observations and recommendations to people responsible for amending the regulatory environment or taxes. The U.S. Financial Institutions in Hungary initiative shows that if someone wants to pursue an international career here in finance, he or she has the chance to do so locally. In addition to that, these career opportunities can attract talent back to Hungary: we recently had successful career networking events in cooperation with our embassies and consulates in Frankfurt, London and New York together with Morgan Stanley, Citi and BlackRock. International students also like to come to Hungary: their ration has increased to 10%, which is double the figure we had 5-6 years ago. We would like to show them that they can build a career here and inspire the best talents to stay.

Róbert Ésik (HIPA)
Do you see automation as a transformative force in the Hungarian labor market on the long term? How can companies prepare for its effects? Róbert Ésik (HIPA): Automation is coming up both in the manufacturing and the services sector. I see this as an opportunity, since it enables extensive growth to continue. Our focus should be intensive growth though: the line workers of today should be able to become technicians or engineers tomorrow. This way, you can achieve a higher level of productivity with the same amount of people. If there is an increase in productivity, employees will be more than happy to pay higher salaries as well. On the services side, activities, such as the procure-to-pay divisions - people who scan and digitalize invoices manually - may transform, if they do not disappear entirely. These activities can be replaced by more sophisticated ones, such as financial management reporting.
How can automation change the daily lives of employees at financial institutions?
Norbert Fogarasi (Morgan Stanley): There have been numerous breakthroughs in the academic field of AI-research, but we are yet to see the best of these technologies in application. We are already seeing signs, like chatbots getting smarter, translators getting more and more accurate. Accordingly, at Morgan Stanley, we are leveraging AI in areas such as research, fraud prevention and client engagement. One of our most successful AI applications is being used in the wealth management business. The software called Next Best Action is supporting our financial advisors. It uses predictive analytics and machine learning to identify insights, market events and the impact on clients’ portfolios, helping advisers share the most relevant insights with their clients. The point of this technology is to help human advisors be more effective, we are not of the opinion that robots will replace human financial advisors, with whom clients will always want to interact.
Ákos Janza (MSCI): We are running more than 150 automation initiatives currently. Actually, 85-90% of what we do is automation: if you think about it, software development is automation. At MSCI, we think of automation as the removal of toil, as in the manual work being done over and over again. We have seen such transformation before: as computers arrived, a lot of jobs were created that we haven’t seen before. For example, statisticians became data scientists, who also concern themselves with software development. Both companies and the state need to manage this transformation, else it will be disruptive. Automation is pushing out some of the existing jobs: if I open my phone application, I can already access a voice-activated system, that keeps track of my activities or interests - for this, you would originally require an assistant. As for Artificial Intelligence, I believe in systems that streamline and speed up things, we are focusing on technologies, such as pattern recognition and being able to process billions of transactions in minutes. A lot of companies are also sitting on huge databases, which can be turned into value with the help of artificial intelligence.
Melanie Seymour (BlackRock): Technology is advancing in a pace we have never seen before: there will be jobs in ten years that we can’t even imagine. For example, ten years ago, no one could imagine learning cybersecurity at a university. As organizations, we have to prepare people to be agile in such a rapidly changing environment. It is not enough to be an expert in a certain field, you have to be able to adapt fast. As companies, you also have to think 5-10 years ahead and you need to bring in people who have the same ability. This brings a new approach into recruitment as well.
Kevin Murray (Citi): Digital Technology continues to be a key enabler of industry change. Citi runs innovation labs in Singapore, Israel, New York, London and Dublin. Dublin and Singapore focus on transaction services, others focus on markets and security services, banking and things of this nature. There is a lot going on in banking too, with the advent of bots: you can get an answer to a really complex question before you realize you are talking to a bot. Thanks to the opportunities given by the technical development, we are also looking to speed up transactions, and add efficiency. Our clients, including larger Hungarian corporations want to do things more quickly and less expensively and automate more mundane tasks, bringing AI wherever it is possible. Compliance is going to be a big user of AI as well, the case workers have to be involved in some of the more complex issues, but it is going to take more and more of a role as we develop in that particular field.
With regards how this can change the life at Citi, I would say automation combined with tailored development strategy is an opportunity for our workforce. In our SSC , in recent years we have moved more and more away from transactional tasks to more in the direction of high value-added, more complex work. Having around half of our roles filled internally, we have been able to perform this change together with our employees in a very organic and stable way, this way we have been able to both offer a meaningful career path to our employees and retain the valuable experience within the organization.

From left to right: Norbert Fogarasi (Morgan Stanley), Melanie Seymour (BlackRock), Kevin Murray (Citi), Ákos Janza (MSCI)
Portfolio: As financial institutions, what do you see as the main challenges when it comes to cybersecurity? How do you prepare for the constantly evolving threats in the cyberspace? Kevin Murray (Citi): Citi operates various centers dedicated to cybersecurity globally. The more we focus on data, the more we need to rely on advanced techniques and commit time and money to protect that data. Earlier, many companies thought of cybersecurity as a byproduct, now it’s regarded as a set of standalone skills and we are looking to enhance that talent.
Ákos Janza (MSCI): Cybersecurity is not only about looking out for people who do malicious things, but proactively we need to keep our infrastructure up to date with the latest patches and that needs an immense amount of people and work.
Norbert Fogarasi (Morgan Stanley): Cyberattacks have become one of the top operational threats for financial institutions. We are beyond the point of simply looking at periphery defense: we are focusing on the inner layers of defense. Essentially, you must assume at some point your systems could be breached and therefore be prepared with industry leading systems and processes to quickly address and prevent intrusions. One of the first things we teach to new people coming to work at our company is cybersecurity. Providing thorough and up-to-date security training to our colleagues is of paramount importance for us since they are our first line of defense.

Norbert Fogarasi (Morgan Stanley)
Melanie Seymour (BlackRock): I think anyone who controls a big set of data is open to threat. I agree with the others: cybersecurity has become cultural. You understand why you have restricted access, why certain servers are set up the way they are or develop the ability to deal with the phishing threats that come in every three seconds. This is not just inside a big retail bank, we all have too much data out there not to be worried. Everybody is alert every day, it is not just a responsibility of everyone to control their data. Kevin Murray (Citi): It’s not just the high-tech angle you have to think about when it comes to data protection, it’s about not leaving sensitive documents on your desk or carelessly clicking attachments. It’s an entire corporate culture you have to develop.
Ákos Janza (MSCI): We even have to pay attention to whom we befriend on Facebook. At one point, Henry Fernandez, our CEO wanted to become my friend on social media. I didn’t initially believe it was him, but he confirmed his identity. “IT security trained you well" - he noted at that point. We are constantly getting money transfer requests from dubious sources, sometimes people even call our desks, pretending to be our employees and ask for money to be issued. Everyone is being scammed every day and it’s going to get worse.

From left to right: Róbert Ésik (HIPA), Dániel Huszák (Portfolio), Norbert (Fogarasi Morgan Stanley), Melanie Seymour (BlackRock), Kevin Murray (Citi), Janza Ákos (MSCI)
Photos by Róbert László Bacsi / Pictorial Collective










