Mihály Varga, state secretary at the Prime Minister’s Office, said on Tuesday he could imagine the IMF/EC granting Hungary a 15-20 billion euro credit line with a three to four-year term. In an interview with local news portal origo.hu he said he expects the aid talks to be concluded swiftly. Varga said the fiscal adjustment need in 2012 is HUF 100-200 billion, but he does not expect the Hungarian economy to slip into recession next year. The former finance minister also said the cabinet will need to reach an agreement not only with the International Monetary Fund but also with the Hungarian Banking Association (on the early repayment scheme).
Varga said 2012 will be the beginning of consolidation and that the major overhauls will be completed by the end of June. Answering a question he said the governments believes a moderate growth next year is more likely than recession: “today it is much more realistic what the Prime Minister said in an interview on Sunday, namely that a growth of around 0.5% could be projected for 2012."
Regarding the ever worse GDP outlook of the government he noted: “We would make a mistake if we stubbornly stuck to the 1.5% growth (forecast), which ceased to have a realistic basis by now. I believe this is a virtue rather than a failure."
Prime Minister Viktor Orbán said in an interview with public television on Sunday that country’s GDP will grow by 0.5% at most next year.
The 1.5% GDP growth, on which the 2012 budget was based on used an EUR/HUF assumption of 268, which means the worse-than-expected macroeconomic conditions will eat into the ample budget reserves, Varga said. He noted that “it would be good to retain most of the reserves for 2012; these should not be sacrificed just because growth will be smaller".
Due to the worse macro framework the cabinet will need “substantial amendments either on the revenue or the spending side" when it overhauls the budget, he added.
When asked about the specific size of adjustment he said analysts’ estimates on a HUF 100-200 bn adjustment need “are not far from the (government’s) calculations".
Regarding the direction of the new measures Varga said he does not believe much could be done on the spending side. “[...] after the decisions we have made over the past few months there is very little to fall back on on the spending side, so I see very few points where something could be done there."
Due to the growth dampening impact of tax hikes and their unfavourable effect on employment Varga believes a mix of revenue and spending side measures will need to be implemented.
Asked about a possible extension of the bank tax and the introduction of further special levies Varga responded: “it would not be fortunate, considering that these would only erode our growth outlook further."
Instead, he sees further revenue boosting opportunities in the area of excise taxes and tax benefits.
Moody's acted late
Varga said there is “speculation against" the European economy, of which Hungary is also a part, adding that credit rating agencies occasionally take unjustified measures that later get proved wrong (e.g. the case of Lehman Brothers). With regard to Hungary’s downgrade to non-investment grade he said “I believe Moody’s was late, just like the rating agencies in general."
In his view, Moody’s has not taken into consideration “what structural changes were implemented in Hungary in 2011".
Varga said Hungary’s financing requirement could be no more than EUR 5-6 billion stressing that the country can still finance itself and “does not need external credit".
Financing OK until March, Hungary needs a deal
Varga said the country’s financing is “definitely alright until March", but Hungary is “more vulnerable in the current situation: its debt level is high; an economic restructuring is in progress, while the European economies are under siege."
Subsequently, in the following weeks and months the cabinet will need to reach some kind of agreement with the IMF (and the European Commission) on a safety net, the Banking Association on improving the lending capacity of the banking sector and the central bank (NBH) on improving the harmony between fiscal and monetary policies.
As for the latter point, he said “the central bank and - to a smaller extent - the government too need to show courtesy towards each other, trying to reach a compromise which makes monetary policy interested in assisting the government’s growth plans."
Will not be hard to reach an agreement
The IMF mission chief for Hungary, Christoph Rosenberg, is visiting Budapest, jointly with the European Commission, between December 13 and 16, for talks with the authorities and updates on the recent budgetary developments.
While the informal visit is not part of the official negotiations on possible precautionary financial assistance from the IMF and the EC, it will help prepare such discussions, which will start next year.
Varga declined to share his views about the possible assistance the IMF/EC could offer, but noted that the cabinet “intends to draw (on the facility) only in case of emergency", and that “in view of the instalments of our public debt I could imagine a EUR 15-20 bn deal for a three or four-year period."
Originally, government officials stressed that the financial assistance can be nothing else but an “insurance-type precautionary" credit line. Later government communication and market views indicated that it is most likely that a Precautionary or a regular Stand-By Arrangement, will be taken out. Analysts at Citi cited government officials saying that the aid package could be a lot bigger than a few billion euros, even EUR 10-15 bn.
Varga said there are no large differences between the government and the IMF in their view on the situation of the local economy and fiscal measures.
He said there is “a minor rift" in their opinion on the bank tax and the 2012 budget deficit, but “the most important measures of the Hungarian government follow the direction of the economic policy pursued by the IMF. Therefore I do not believe it will be overly hard to reach an agreement with them." Varga said a deal could be reached “by the end of January".
Click on the link below for analysts' views about Varga's statements and PM Orbán's remarks on budget overhaul.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas