Economy
INSTANT VIEW: Fitch move could be next for Hungary, current Moody's rating should not be taken for granted
Peter Attard Montalto, Nomura, London
"This move was largely expected though the timing is interesting. We thought they might wait till new year. They follow Moody's a few weeks back. We expect Fitch to follow suit early in the new year. Moody's may well go again given MNB Act and any additional funding issues."
"S+P sighted the increasing uncertainty, unpredictability and lack of credibility around government policy and the detrimental effects it would have on credit risk and investors. In particular the effects of government action on the "independence of institutions" (ie MNB) was sighted. We highlighted this since end of last week that MNB Act could be a credit event and also was making the agencies nervous."
"Also remember the conspiracy theory that Hungary only ever went to IMF to begin with because of S+P or Moody's giving them notice of a downgrade. I know many of you are still sceptical of this but it fits with the evidence I've seen and heard of from Ministry contacts. At very least we can agree that the general threat of downgrades prompted Orban rather than fear of a future BoP crisis (esp given recent events and action by govt). As such we can see this ploy ultimately failed."
"It is clear that S+P did not see the prospect of an IMF/EU backstop as credible enough to support an IG credit view. This is also our view. The govt is not serious about getting a backstop, it is a game with the markets. They will only become serious **AFTER** a crisis has developed and that is only the point at which they will accept conditionally. This is what investors I talk to are trying to phantom. Is the prospect of a backstop real, and how do we get there? The answer is yes, but things have to get much worse first."
"Note we do not see serious forced selling occurring now two agencies have Hungary in junk equally the impact on major index inclusion is limited. There are some asian names and some convergence funds who have ratings requirements but these are already severely underweight and so the amount of selling we expect should be of limited impact. Overall our view remains that we see increased primary market funding difficulties in H1, combined with Hungary expecting the IMF/EU to return but them refusing given MNB Act, combined with deleveraging and reserve drawdown leading to a BoP event and then eventually the IMF/EU being dealt with in a constructive manner, conditionality accepted (including a pre-commitment by repealing the MNB Act) and a programme in place."
Julius Duk¹ta, SEB, Stockholm
"HUF weakened following the rating change announcement and currently trades around 308 level against the euro. Interest rate swaps went up by 10bps and yields on local bonds are expected to rise today because trading was already closed when the rating decision came out. More negative pressure on Hungarian assets is expected today."
Bjarke Roed-Frederiksen, Nordea, Copenhagen
"S&P has noted that the IMF mission has left Hungary, with no agreement in sight. With the economy still weak it is an uphill battle to solve the debt problems. Remember it has a debt rate of 80%/GDP, which is among the highest in the Emerging Markets. Hungary is in deep trouble, S&P confirmed yesterday."
Eszter Gárgyán, Citigroup, Budapest
As markets are focusing on the IMF talks, we expect the imminent broad asset sell-off will be short lived with asset prices more likely to be driven by political news in the coming weeks. We believe S&P’s move may be followed by Fitch, and rating downgrades are likely to intensify pressure on the government to make the required amendments to the constitution. Our view is that even if talks are delayed until spring 2012, the government is likely to be pushed into a position where it has to accept conditionality following tough talks with the IMF/EU. The political costs of sharp currency weakening and a funding squeeze (see page 2) would be too high, in our view, as the private sector is heavily indebted in FX.
Lars Christensen, Danske Bank, Copenhagen
"We agree that the Hungarian government’s continued erratic behaviour and unorthodox economic policy are serious problems that have undermined investor confidence. Said in another way, Hungary’s economic fundamentals do not justify a junk rating, but the damaging policies of the Hungarian government have undermined investor confidence and this is the key reason why both Moody’s and S&P have decided to cut Hungary’s rating."
"Furthermore, it is clearly worrying that the Hungarian government apparently continues to ignore how negative the consequences of its actions are. When Moody’s downgraded Hungary in November the Ministry of Economics in a statement said it was a “financial attack" on Hungary. In a reaction to S&P’s rating action the same Ministry said: “S&P purposely ignored that there has recently been a positive change in the gauges that serve as the basis of the evaluation". We have found it hard to detect this “positive change" and have been puzzled that S&P did not cut Hungary’s rating earlier, as the Hungarian government’s policies render it difficult for international investors to be positive on the outlook for the Hungarian economy and markets. The fact that Hungary is now rated junk by two of the three major rating agencies is likely to put further pressure on Hungary’s
ability to find funding in the international capital markets. As a consequence we maintain our view that the Hungarian forint is likely to remain under pressure and stick to our recommendation to underweight Hungarian debt in EM bond portfolios."
"Today the Hungarian parliament is likely to vote on the controversial changes in the central bank law that effectively are going to take away political independence from the Hungarian central bank. If the law is passed, this might very well be the trigger for the third major rating agency, Fitch, to cut its rating of Hungary to junk status."
Gyula Tóth, UniCredit, Vienna
"The move is slightly surprising given the S&P previously indicated that it wants to wait till the conclusion of the talks. But following the break up of the informal talks last week and increasing pressure from the EU it is understandable. After this we think it is highly likely that the Fitch will follow very soon (reports in local media yesterday suggested that even a two notch downgrade is possible). As most of the Hungarian external debt is held by dedicated EM bond funds, which do not have strict rating limit around the investment grade we do not expect significant forced selling. On the other hand we expect temporary underperformance of the EUR denominated papers which will offer attractive switch opportunity (USD to EUR). Looking ahead we will keenly watch weather the intensifying EU, rating agency pressure changes the stance of the government. We also watch carefully the approval or not approval of the new central bank law and financial stability law."
"This move was largely expected though the timing is interesting. We thought they might wait till new year. They follow Moody's a few weeks back. We expect Fitch to follow suit early in the new year. Moody's may well go again given MNB Act and any additional funding issues."
"S+P sighted the increasing uncertainty, unpredictability and lack of credibility around government policy and the detrimental effects it would have on credit risk and investors. In particular the effects of government action on the "independence of institutions" (ie MNB) was sighted. We highlighted this since end of last week that MNB Act could be a credit event and also was making the agencies nervous."
"Also remember the conspiracy theory that Hungary only ever went to IMF to begin with because of S+P or Moody's giving them notice of a downgrade. I know many of you are still sceptical of this but it fits with the evidence I've seen and heard of from Ministry contacts. At very least we can agree that the general threat of downgrades prompted Orban rather than fear of a future BoP crisis (esp given recent events and action by govt). As such we can see this ploy ultimately failed."
"It is clear that S+P did not see the prospect of an IMF/EU backstop as credible enough to support an IG credit view. This is also our view. The govt is not serious about getting a backstop, it is a game with the markets. They will only become serious **AFTER** a crisis has developed and that is only the point at which they will accept conditionally. This is what investors I talk to are trying to phantom. Is the prospect of a backstop real, and how do we get there? The answer is yes, but things have to get much worse first."
"Note we do not see serious forced selling occurring now two agencies have Hungary in junk equally the impact on major index inclusion is limited. There are some asian names and some convergence funds who have ratings requirements but these are already severely underweight and so the amount of selling we expect should be of limited impact. Overall our view remains that we see increased primary market funding difficulties in H1, combined with Hungary expecting the IMF/EU to return but them refusing given MNB Act, combined with deleveraging and reserve drawdown leading to a BoP event and then eventually the IMF/EU being dealt with in a constructive manner, conditionality accepted (including a pre-commitment by repealing the MNB Act) and a programme in place."
Julius Duk¹ta, SEB, Stockholm
"HUF weakened following the rating change announcement and currently trades around 308 level against the euro. Interest rate swaps went up by 10bps and yields on local bonds are expected to rise today because trading was already closed when the rating decision came out. More negative pressure on Hungarian assets is expected today."
Bjarke Roed-Frederiksen, Nordea, Copenhagen
"S&P has noted that the IMF mission has left Hungary, with no agreement in sight. With the economy still weak it is an uphill battle to solve the debt problems. Remember it has a debt rate of 80%/GDP, which is among the highest in the Emerging Markets. Hungary is in deep trouble, S&P confirmed yesterday."
Eszter Gárgyán, Citigroup, Budapest
As markets are focusing on the IMF talks, we expect the imminent broad asset sell-off will be short lived with asset prices more likely to be driven by political news in the coming weeks. We believe S&P’s move may be followed by Fitch, and rating downgrades are likely to intensify pressure on the government to make the required amendments to the constitution. Our view is that even if talks are delayed until spring 2012, the government is likely to be pushed into a position where it has to accept conditionality following tough talks with the IMF/EU. The political costs of sharp currency weakening and a funding squeeze (see page 2) would be too high, in our view, as the private sector is heavily indebted in FX.
Lars Christensen, Danske Bank, Copenhagen
"We agree that the Hungarian government’s continued erratic behaviour and unorthodox economic policy are serious problems that have undermined investor confidence. Said in another way, Hungary’s economic fundamentals do not justify a junk rating, but the damaging policies of the Hungarian government have undermined investor confidence and this is the key reason why both Moody’s and S&P have decided to cut Hungary’s rating."
"Furthermore, it is clearly worrying that the Hungarian government apparently continues to ignore how negative the consequences of its actions are. When Moody’s downgraded Hungary in November the Ministry of Economics in a statement said it was a “financial attack" on Hungary. In a reaction to S&P’s rating action the same Ministry said: “S&P purposely ignored that there has recently been a positive change in the gauges that serve as the basis of the evaluation". We have found it hard to detect this “positive change" and have been puzzled that S&P did not cut Hungary’s rating earlier, as the Hungarian government’s policies render it difficult for international investors to be positive on the outlook for the Hungarian economy and markets. The fact that Hungary is now rated junk by two of the three major rating agencies is likely to put further pressure on Hungary’s
ability to find funding in the international capital markets. As a consequence we maintain our view that the Hungarian forint is likely to remain under pressure and stick to our recommendation to underweight Hungarian debt in EM bond portfolios."
"Today the Hungarian parliament is likely to vote on the controversial changes in the central bank law that effectively are going to take away political independence from the Hungarian central bank. If the law is passed, this might very well be the trigger for the third major rating agency, Fitch, to cut its rating of Hungary to junk status."
Gyula Tóth, UniCredit, Vienna
"The move is slightly surprising given the S&P previously indicated that it wants to wait till the conclusion of the talks. But following the break up of the informal talks last week and increasing pressure from the EU it is understandable. After this we think it is highly likely that the Fitch will follow very soon (reports in local media yesterday suggested that even a two notch downgrade is possible). As most of the Hungarian external debt is held by dedicated EM bond funds, which do not have strict rating limit around the investment grade we do not expect significant forced selling. On the other hand we expect temporary underperformance of the EUR denominated papers which will offer attractive switch opportunity (USD to EUR). Looking ahead we will keenly watch weather the intensifying EU, rating agency pressure changes the stance of the government. We also watch carefully the approval or not approval of the new central bank law and financial stability law."









