Economy
Hungary could pay the price for excessive deficit
Decision later today
In a European Commission meeting on Wednesday, the EC is going to request the Economic and Financial Affairs Council (Ecofin) to declare that Hungary has failed to meet the latter's mid-2009 recommendation to adjust Hungary's excessive government deficit, according to Bruxinfo.
This means the Commission is not only continuing the excessive deficit procedure against Hungary but progressing it to the next procedural stage. In such a case the standard conclusion is that a particular country, in this case Hungary, has "failed to take effective action" to bring its excessive deficit down.
The EC is now expected to declare that while Hungary has taken action to cut the government gap, this has been insufficient.
Two scenarios
EU souces have said the European Commission is now left with no choice other than move the excessive deficit procedure (EDP) against Hungary to the next stage. The Commission is now requesting the Ecofin to declare that Hungary has failed to implement the pledges it made in mid-2009. If the Commission's assessment is approved by a qualified majority in the Ecofin, the case is referred back to the EC which can take one of two optional policy lines.
One possible course of EC action is to propose that the Ecofin make new recommendations, the other scenario would be sanctions against Hungary in the form of freezing payments from the Cohesion Fund.
As Hungary is not a eurozone member it is not subject to the more automatic sanctions for member states exceeding fiscal targets.
No precedent for frezing funds
The harshest possible sanction is a temporary freeze of Cohesion Fund payments to Hungary. However, the European Commission has never actually resorted to such stringent measures against any member state.
Considering the stringent penalties in place against defaulting eurozone members, the EU is unlikely to take a lenient course of action against Hungary either, sources have told Bruxinfo. "It is not like the EU's patience knows no bounds when it comes to applying the sanctions which are currently the only way to penalize member states outside the eurozone. In theory, Ecofin affirmative action could be followed by a EC proposal to suspend part of Cohesion Fund payments to Hungary; in contrast, eurozone countries face immediate EC sanctions in an excessive deficit procedure. However, this is clearly a very robust political move and the Commission will definitely think twice before doing so. Therefore, this remains no more than a theoretical possibility."
Failure for Hungary
Based on government communication over the past 1.5 years, ending the excessive deficit procedure that has blotted Hungary's copybook since 2004 has been a key priority for the Orbán administration ever since it replaced the previous Socialist government. The current assessment of the country's situation is likely based on an EU prognosis for Hungary released in November, along with recent exchanges in which the government has been trying to convince the Commission that is is indeed striving for long-term deficit reduction.
Last November the Commission found that Hungary remained below the 3% deficit cap in 2011 (thanks to assets transferred from pension funds to government coffers, Hungary had a positive cash-based budget balance last year) and that the country may likewise be able to steer clear of exceeding the target in 2012. However it warned that deficit cuts are not sustainable and the budget gap may widen to more than 3% once again in 2013. Hungary has been called on to implement additional measures by EC Commissioner for Economic and Financial Affairs Olli Rehn.
However, Hungary's Economy Ministry has seen the findings of the Brussels report in a favorable light. Ministry sources said they saw a real opportunity for the excessive deficit procedure against Hungary to be discontinued as long as the 2012 spring prognosis for 2013 deficit is lower than 3%. "The European Commission forecast clearly sends a positive message to markets, investors and rating agencies, confirming the credibility of the government's economic policy," the Economy Ministry said in a release entitled "Hungary has won the first battle" last year. To use the ministry's expression, at the moment it seems unlikely that today's EU decition will "send a positive message to markets and rating agencies" and it may not exactly suggest "Hungary has won the first battle".
Based on information from government sources, Portfolio.hu learned last year that out of the three possible outcomes of the procedures, the ministry was expecting Brussels to weigh the option of terminating the EDP vs. proceeding with it (without any immediate penalties), rather than seeing it as a choice between a continued EDP vs. implementing sanctions. The ministry was allegedly hoping to convince the EU in a few weeks' time that Hungary has managed to get the deficit issue permanently and sustainably under control and that there is no threat to meeting the 2013 target.
A week ago, Economy Minister György Matolcsy was still trying to convince Rehn that the 2011 headline budget figure was in accordance with targets without one-off items. Matolcsy said he was hopeful the Commission would see the Hungary's efforts in appropriate light when deliberating EDP action.
Since this statement, the ministry has issued repeated statements confirming that Hungary met its 2011 deficit target pledge.
In an article last week, Portfolio.hu has warned that Hungary's chances for the EDP being terminated are very low. Based on fiscal trends, the country is very far from standing a realistic chance of escaping the EU procedure. At that time, we said the greatest possible success Hungary could score was for the EDP to be maintained without derogations being discontinued; that is, to escape sanctions despite the fact Hungary has been unable to meet the criteria for EDP termination since 2004. If newly leaked information is to be believed, the worst-case scenario could now happen; that is, sanctions may be possible.
In a European Commission meeting on Wednesday, the EC is going to request the Economic and Financial Affairs Council (Ecofin) to declare that Hungary has failed to meet the latter's mid-2009 recommendation to adjust Hungary's excessive government deficit, according to Bruxinfo.
This means the Commission is not only continuing the excessive deficit procedure against Hungary but progressing it to the next procedural stage. In such a case the standard conclusion is that a particular country, in this case Hungary, has "failed to take effective action" to bring its excessive deficit down.
The EC is now expected to declare that while Hungary has taken action to cut the government gap, this has been insufficient.
Two scenarios
EU souces have said the European Commission is now left with no choice other than move the excessive deficit procedure (EDP) against Hungary to the next stage. The Commission is now requesting the Ecofin to declare that Hungary has failed to implement the pledges it made in mid-2009. If the Commission's assessment is approved by a qualified majority in the Ecofin, the case is referred back to the EC which can take one of two optional policy lines.
One possible course of EC action is to propose that the Ecofin make new recommendations, the other scenario would be sanctions against Hungary in the form of freezing payments from the Cohesion Fund.
As Hungary is not a eurozone member it is not subject to the more automatic sanctions for member states exceeding fiscal targets.
No precedent for frezing funds
The harshest possible sanction is a temporary freeze of Cohesion Fund payments to Hungary. However, the European Commission has never actually resorted to such stringent measures against any member state.
Considering the stringent penalties in place against defaulting eurozone members, the EU is unlikely to take a lenient course of action against Hungary either, sources have told Bruxinfo. "It is not like the EU's patience knows no bounds when it comes to applying the sanctions which are currently the only way to penalize member states outside the eurozone. In theory, Ecofin affirmative action could be followed by a EC proposal to suspend part of Cohesion Fund payments to Hungary; in contrast, eurozone countries face immediate EC sanctions in an excessive deficit procedure. However, this is clearly a very robust political move and the Commission will definitely think twice before doing so. Therefore, this remains no more than a theoretical possibility."
Failure for Hungary
Based on government communication over the past 1.5 years, ending the excessive deficit procedure that has blotted Hungary's copybook since 2004 has been a key priority for the Orbán administration ever since it replaced the previous Socialist government. The current assessment of the country's situation is likely based on an EU prognosis for Hungary released in November, along with recent exchanges in which the government has been trying to convince the Commission that is is indeed striving for long-term deficit reduction.
Last November the Commission found that Hungary remained below the 3% deficit cap in 2011 (thanks to assets transferred from pension funds to government coffers, Hungary had a positive cash-based budget balance last year) and that the country may likewise be able to steer clear of exceeding the target in 2012. However it warned that deficit cuts are not sustainable and the budget gap may widen to more than 3% once again in 2013. Hungary has been called on to implement additional measures by EC Commissioner for Economic and Financial Affairs Olli Rehn.
However, Hungary's Economy Ministry has seen the findings of the Brussels report in a favorable light. Ministry sources said they saw a real opportunity for the excessive deficit procedure against Hungary to be discontinued as long as the 2012 spring prognosis for 2013 deficit is lower than 3%. "The European Commission forecast clearly sends a positive message to markets, investors and rating agencies, confirming the credibility of the government's economic policy," the Economy Ministry said in a release entitled "Hungary has won the first battle" last year. To use the ministry's expression, at the moment it seems unlikely that today's EU decition will "send a positive message to markets and rating agencies" and it may not exactly suggest "Hungary has won the first battle".
Based on information from government sources, Portfolio.hu learned last year that out of the three possible outcomes of the procedures, the ministry was expecting Brussels to weigh the option of terminating the EDP vs. proceeding with it (without any immediate penalties), rather than seeing it as a choice between a continued EDP vs. implementing sanctions. The ministry was allegedly hoping to convince the EU in a few weeks' time that Hungary has managed to get the deficit issue permanently and sustainably under control and that there is no threat to meeting the 2013 target.
A week ago, Economy Minister György Matolcsy was still trying to convince Rehn that the 2011 headline budget figure was in accordance with targets without one-off items. Matolcsy said he was hopeful the Commission would see the Hungary's efforts in appropriate light when deliberating EDP action.
Since this statement, the ministry has issued repeated statements confirming that Hungary met its 2011 deficit target pledge.
In an article last week, Portfolio.hu has warned that Hungary's chances for the EDP being terminated are very low. Based on fiscal trends, the country is very far from standing a realistic chance of escaping the EU procedure. At that time, we said the greatest possible success Hungary could score was for the EDP to be maintained without derogations being discontinued; that is, to escape sanctions despite the fact Hungary has been unable to meet the criteria for EDP termination since 2004. If newly leaked information is to be believed, the worst-case scenario could now happen; that is, sanctions may be possible.









