Economy
Hungary needs more conciliatory tone, personnel changes in gov't - Járai
“I did not want to criticise the government this time either. I believe the situation of the Hungarian economy is substantially better than how the credit rating agencies or press reports describe," Járai said on Tuesday morning, responding to a question whether he left the Fiscal Council for his critical view of the cabinet’s measures.
Turnaround in progress already
Going back to the IMF and planning a 4-5% of GDP fiscal adjustment in the 2012 budget means an economic policy U-turn has already started, Járai noted. He said this is not austerity, though (which is the forbidden ‘A’ word in the government’s vocabulary - Editor’s note). In his view, it was unfair from creditors to push the Hungarian economy in its current state.
Matolcsy is used up
“I believe that in order to make the economic policy clear for the investors there is a need for institutional and personnel changes. Fiscal policy would need to be strengthened and politics pushed to the background. It is the responsibility of the Prime Minister how this could be achieved organisational wise. But fiscal control, budget planning and the reduction of bureaucracy would need to be enhanced by all means," the former finance minister said.
Asked whether Economy Minister György Matolcsy could helm such a turnaround credibly Járai responded: “this is up to the Prime Minister to decide. I think Mr. Matolcsy is rather worn out in terms of fiscal policy."
“The minister can draw up a magnificent picture of the plans, but in the meantime fiscal management is kept in the back," he added.
Responding to a question he said he would not accept a government position, because “there are young people who are competent". “The whole organisation that deals in fiscal policy would need to be shored up, but not by me," he added.
Falling out with many
Járai said Hungary’s perception is so bad because “we have fallen out with a lot of serious factors." Therefore the cabinet would need to come to terms with these power entities. And one step in this direction would be if no laws get to pass that are contrary to European Union rules, he added.
“We’d need a more conciliatory, more tactful economic policy and then we could do the same only we wouldn’t have to do it so loud," said Járai, who is also President of the central bank’s (NBH) Supervisory Board.
Brussels is not right
Járai said there is no justification for the European Commission to move the Excessive Deficit Procedure (EDP) against Hungary to the next stage, which the EC just did last week. “Brussels has not found a reason either; 2012 is alright from a budget perspective; the year 2013 is questionable though. But until then there’s ample opportunity to take measures," the economist criticised the EU executive.
He said criticism over the new Central Bank Act is also unfounded. “In most countries the members of the central bank are appointed by the government." At the same time, he acknowledged that the tradition was different in Hungary, but reminded that it was changed by the former Socialist PM Ferenc Gyurcsány.
What will happen to the budget?
Responding to a question whether new fiscal adjustment(s) will be needed in the course of 2012, Járai said the government will achieve its fiscal goals. “On this course it will not be achievable; adjustments will be necessary," he added.
Attacks on the c.bank
Járai noted that several economists criticise the central bank’s policy. “These (criticisms) are justified because the central bank does not do everything in its power to support growth. But the government should not come charging because it would appear as an attack on (the central bank’s) independence," he warned.
Turnaround in progress already
Going back to the IMF and planning a 4-5% of GDP fiscal adjustment in the 2012 budget means an economic policy U-turn has already started, Járai noted. He said this is not austerity, though (which is the forbidden ‘A’ word in the government’s vocabulary - Editor’s note). In his view, it was unfair from creditors to push the Hungarian economy in its current state.
Matolcsy is used up
“I believe that in order to make the economic policy clear for the investors there is a need for institutional and personnel changes. Fiscal policy would need to be strengthened and politics pushed to the background. It is the responsibility of the Prime Minister how this could be achieved organisational wise. But fiscal control, budget planning and the reduction of bureaucracy would need to be enhanced by all means," the former finance minister said.
Asked whether Economy Minister György Matolcsy could helm such a turnaround credibly Járai responded: “this is up to the Prime Minister to decide. I think Mr. Matolcsy is rather worn out in terms of fiscal policy."
“The minister can draw up a magnificent picture of the plans, but in the meantime fiscal management is kept in the back," he added.
Responding to a question he said he would not accept a government position, because “there are young people who are competent". “The whole organisation that deals in fiscal policy would need to be shored up, but not by me," he added.
Falling out with many
Járai said Hungary’s perception is so bad because “we have fallen out with a lot of serious factors." Therefore the cabinet would need to come to terms with these power entities. And one step in this direction would be if no laws get to pass that are contrary to European Union rules, he added.
“We’d need a more conciliatory, more tactful economic policy and then we could do the same only we wouldn’t have to do it so loud," said Járai, who is also President of the central bank’s (NBH) Supervisory Board.
Brussels is not right
Járai said there is no justification for the European Commission to move the Excessive Deficit Procedure (EDP) against Hungary to the next stage, which the EC just did last week. “Brussels has not found a reason either; 2012 is alright from a budget perspective; the year 2013 is questionable though. But until then there’s ample opportunity to take measures," the economist criticised the EU executive.
He said criticism over the new Central Bank Act is also unfounded. “In most countries the members of the central bank are appointed by the government." At the same time, he acknowledged that the tradition was different in Hungary, but reminded that it was changed by the former Socialist PM Ferenc Gyurcsány.
What will happen to the budget?
Responding to a question whether new fiscal adjustment(s) will be needed in the course of 2012, Járai said the government will achieve its fiscal goals. “On this course it will not be achievable; adjustments will be necessary," he added.
Attacks on the c.bank
Járai noted that several economists criticise the central bank’s policy. “These (criticisms) are justified because the central bank does not do everything in its power to support growth. But the government should not come charging because it would appear as an attack on (the central bank’s) independence," he warned.









