Hungary’s gross public debt amounted to 80.3% at the end of 2011, the central bank’s financial accounts data showed on Friday. At the end of Q3, the debt-to-GDP ratio stood at 82.6% following a leap. As it was expected the figure came lower, but - also verifying estimates - it remained a tad above 80%.
At the end of 2010 Hungary’s general government consolidated gross debt at nominal value amounted to 81.3% of GDP at the end of 2010, so the indicator dropped moderately last year. The main reason for that is that the state spent half of the assets transferred from private pension fund to state coffers on debt reduction.
In the Széll Kálmán Plan (a package of structural reform measures) and the Convergence Programme the cabinet penciled in 75.5% of GDP debt for the end of 2011. The forint’s drastic depreciation, which greatly increased the forint value of FX debt, was the cause this goal was not achieved.
The high Q3 debt figure (82.6% of GDP) was partly attributable to the fact that it already included loans taken out early in the year in order to have funds for redemptions in Q4. This repayment, which did not have to be pre-financed, obviously contributed to lowering the Q4 debt. It also helped that the Government Debt Management Agency (ÁKK) was struggling selling debt at auctions. This, however, did not cause other problems thanks to the liquid financial situation. These factors could offset the fact that the forint was weaker versus the euro on 31 December than on 30 September.
The course of changes in public debt has changed somewhat since the Q1 report, as the level of GDP was taken lower by methodology changes. As a result, Hungary’s debt-to-GDP ratio was not on a 16-year high at the end of September, but - according to the fresh GDP data - the debt record was reached at 85.2% in Q2 2010.
Due to the barrage of one-off factors it is difficult to determine the trend of general government debt. Basically, as we see it the budget’s structural position last year would not have necessarily led to a decline in the debt-to-GDP ratio. Disregarding the forint depreciation we should have seen a trend close to stagnation or one that is slightly rising. This is underpinned by the fact that excluding the amount of the capital transfer (i.e. private pension fund assets), general government net lending was equivalent to -4.5% of GDP in 2011.
Hungary’s state debt could start to decline convincingly from this year if the government successfully executes its adjustment plans and manages to seal the much-needed bailout deal with the IMF/EC. In that case the debt indicator may not be threatened by interest expenditures and the exchange rate as last year.22 February Update
Certain data on the general government sector, and in particular on central government, published in the press release on preliminary financial accounts data for general government and households on 17 February 2012, have been corrected, the central bank said in a statement on 22 Feb.
According to corrected data, general government net lending amounted to 4.3% of GDP in 2011, instead of 5.0%as published originally. This correction has been made necessary by the fact that other financial liabilities of central government related to the special VAT refunds in 2011 Q4 were incorrectly calculated. The correction does not affect the amount of general government consolidated gross debt at nominal value.
Details
According to preliminary data, general government net lending amounted to HUF 1,217 billion or 4.3% of Hungary’s GDP in the four quarters to 2011 Q4. Excluding the effect of the capital transfer from households to general government due to opt-outs from private pension funds, general government net lending amounted to HUF -1,460 billion or -5.2% of GDP in the year to 2011 Q4.
General government net lending (HUF -602 billion) was equal to -7.7% of quarterly GDP in 2011 Q4.
At the end of 2011, general government consolidated gross debt at nominal value (or Maastricht debt) was HUF 22,649 billion, equivalent to 80.3% of GDP.
Net repayments (transaction) reduced the debt by HUF 1,047 billion and the depreciation of the forint (revaluation) increased it by HUF 765 billion.
At the end of 2011, a 1 forint change in the exchange rate caused a 0.14 percentage point change in the gross debt-to-GDP ratio.
Net liabilities of general government amounted to HUF 14,583 billion or 51.7% cent of GDP at the end of 2011 Q4.
In 2011 Q4, net borrowing of central government amounted to HUF 1030* billion. On the assets side, central government deposits with the central bank, lending within general government and holdings of mutual fund shares fell significantly.
On the liabilities side, the declines in holdings of government bonds and foreign borrowing were dominant.
The assumption by central government of county government debt had a significant impact on net lending of local government authorities (HUF 103 billion). On the assets side of the local authority balance sheet, deposits with credit institutions fell sharply. On the liabilities side, there was a significant decline in bond liabilities.
Net lending of social security funds (HUF 325 billion) mainly reflected the cancellation of debt owed to central government.
According to preliminary financial accounts data, household net lending (HUF -1,261 billion) was equivalent to -4.5% of GDP in the four quarters to 2011 Q4. Excluding the effect of the capital transfer from households to general government due to opt-outs from private pension funds, household net lending amounted to HUF 1,417 billion or 5.0% of GDP in the year to 2011 Q4.
In 2011 Q4, household net lending (HUF 604 billion) amounted to 7.7% of quarterly GDP. Excluding the effect of the capital transfer related to early repayments of foreign currency mortgages, household net lending amounted to HUF 430 billion or 5.5% of quarterly GDP.
Early repayments of foreign currency mortgages had a significant impact on the structure of household sector financial assets and liabilities. (see box below)
On the assets side, household holdings of foreign currency, foreign currency deposits and shares and other equity declined sharply, with life insurance reserves falling only slightly. By contrast, forint cash and forint deposits increased significantly.
On the liabilities side, foreign currency loans due to transactions, mainly reflecting early repayments, fell sharply. By contrast, forint loans increased considerably, also mainly as a result of early repayments.
Methodological notes to the Q4 2011 financial accounts data
1 Statistical recording of early repayments of foreign currency mortgage loans
Under the relevant regulation, financial corporations are required to use fixed, significantly below-market exchange rates for early repayments by households. The resulting increase in wealth is treated as a capital transfer to households in the statistics. In the statistical accounts, this capital transfer is granted 70-30% by financial corporations and general government, given that general government will refund 30 per cent of the loss arising from early repayments to financial corporations.
Capital transfers are recorded at the time households repay their debt; those related to repayments made before the end of the year were recorded in 2011 Q4. Capital transfers related to early repayments made in 2012 will be recorded in 2012 Q1. Given that general government refunds 30 per cent of losses on a cash basis only in 2012, the sector has other liabilities to financial corporations in the financial accounts at the end of 2011.
Calculated at market exchange rates, households repaid HUF 642 billion of their foreign currency mortgage loans, taking advantage of the early repayment option, and they received a HUF 174 billion capital transfer from financial corporations and general government.
2 Uncertainties related to 2011 Q4 data for the household sector
2011 Q4 household financial accounts data are only partially able to reflect the effects of economic events. Households are likely to have reduced their financial assets or increased liabilities in order to make early repayments which can be captured only to a limited extent in the statistics. In addition, based on bank account turnover households are likely to have increased their foreign investments at the end of the year, which can be captured only partially by the statistics.
Households are estimated to have reduced their foreign currency holdings by HUF 120 billion, i.e. they converted the foreign currency equivalent of that amount to forints. In addition, deposits held abroad, claims on voluntary pension funds and households’ other assets are estimates. The estimates may change in later publications or may be replaced by actual data as they become available.
3 Capital injection to Hungarian Development Bank (MFB)
Central government granted a HUF 120 billion capital injection to Hungarian Development Bank in 2011 Q4, in part to cover the losses incurred in earlier periods and in part to stimulate development banking activity. The whole amount of this capital injection is treated as a capital transfer in the statistics, and a result it is recorded as a decline in financial assets held by central government. The statistical treatment of the capital injection may change later, if adequate information is obtained that the capital injection granted to support development banking activity earns a return which is comparable to market returns.
4 Change to the recording of extraordinary VAT refunds
In accordance with the judgement of the European Court of Justice, Parliament has changed VAT refund rules. As a result, other liabilities of central government in the financial accounts are estimated to have increased by HUF 289 billion and its net borrowing requirement to have increased by the same amount in 2011 Q3, given that the amount was recorded in the statistics as a capital transfer from the state to non-financial corporations.
The estimate for the amount of capital transfer was revised based on data becoming available since then. According to current information, the value of capital transfer was HUF 198 billion in 2011 Q3, and as a result central government other liabilities increased by the same amount. In the statistical treatment of the transfer, changing the estimate for Q3 does not have an effect on general government net lending in 2012, only on the ratio between Q3 and Q4 net lending.
5 Injection to the Magyar Nemzeti Bank’s revaluation reserves
According to a decision by Eurostat, injections to the Magyar Nemzeti Bank’s revaluation reserves need not be recorded as central government expenditure. As a result, central government net lending in the financial accounts increased by HUF 29 billion in 2011 Q1 relative to the previous data release.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas