Hungary President Schmitt fights on "for justice", prepares to write new PhD thesis
Portfolio
Save article Share
By András Müller Pál Schmitt, President of Hungary, has announced on Friday that he is not willing to step down, after the Senate of the Semmelweis University stripped him of his doctorate degree on Thursday. The radical decision came after much controversy and row that was sparked in January when a local news portal claimed that Schmitt had plagiarised almost his entire thesis from several sources. The President continues to reject the alleged plagiarism, although a fact finding committee at the university uncovered numerous formal deficiencies and stated that Schmitt transposed from the works of others, while it also put the blame on the examiners of the thesis for their failure to find the wrongdoing.
After the panel revealed its findings, Schmitt expressed satisfaction about the results and in an interview with ATV he said he "did not think for a minute" that he would resign over the alleged plagiarism. He explained that it was his "other qualities" not his doctorate why he was elected as President.
In an interview with public television on Friday evening, the President said he feels hurt that his doctorate was repealed while he was abroad at an important conference. He has not only made clear that he wouldn’t resign, but pledged to write another thesis and regain his degree - or more precisely, obtain a new one.
They should have told me so. Now it’s too late.
“As President of the Republic I am happy that the laws apply equally to everyone, there is no double standard. The faith of the people in laws and institutions need to be strengthened. I, as President of the Republic, lead an institution, and it is important that people trust this, feel its power that I represent the country according to the stipulations of the basic law," Schmitt told MTV in an interview that was recorded in the afternoon in Parliament and aired shortly before 20:00 CET.
I’m sure people have huge faith in the institution led by the President. After all, he signed every piece of legislation the Fidesz-led government put through Parliament, including those that are now the bone of content for the European Union now. This was no surprise, however, as he had declared upon his induction in 2010 that he would not be a hindrance to the cabinet’s agenda.
Brussels is now contesting some of those laws, including the amendment of the Central Bank Act, new rules on the judiciary and the data protection ombudsman. The dispute over these laws have kept Hungary from even starting formal talks on an IMF/EU credit facility, although Prime Minister Orbán announced last November to seek financial help from the lenders.“They have assigned the opponent and the consultant, who, so to say, guided my pen. I did not receive other instruction (from them) than encouragement."
Right, so the opponent and the consultant guided Schmitt’s pen, so to speak, by giving him nothing but encouragement.Schmitt said the opponent’s preliminary review of the thesis was positive and “even in the last instant they could have said, whoa, you shouldn’t have written it this way, you should have used more quotation marks or use more footnotes to say where the quotations come from. But as then, 20 years ago, we wrote theses on typewriters, it was customary to use a bibliography, a list of sources from whom we quoted only at the end."
Right, so if I copy this whole article almost verbatim from, let’s say CNN, and claim it’s my intellectual product and no one claims copyright, then it’s okay. And if they find out a year from now what a mischievous little journalist I was, I can defend myself by saying that, sorry guys, you should have caught me red handed. Now it’s too late, terribly sorry, but you can go and...“A matter of honour"
“This is a matter of honour," Schmitt said. “I did not mean to claim no one’s intellectual product as my own."
The President explained that he had “listed the sources, followed the instructions" and he “had not been the one who created the doctorate requirements of the TF “College of Physical Education"
He stressed he was a “simple student" and that when the job was done he “leaned back content (thinking) it was an honest, manly job."
“This was an honest work 5, 10 and even 15 years later too."
“My conscience is clear. I wrote this thesis in the most honest way, according to my best knowledge. I did not wish to portray Georgiev’s intellectual product as my own. His name was also on top (in the bibliography) since I quoted from him the most," Schmitt explained why and how he did not plagiarise.
A council of the National Physical Education and Sports Office (OTSH) published a ‘how to write sport scientific publications’ guide in 1992. It shines through from its introduction that the target audience included researches with plans to write dissertations. The guide suggests a number of logical solutions to construct a bibliography, e.g. an order in which the quoted works follow each other in the thesis or alphabetical order of the sources. Listing the sources according to their importance is not among the suggested options.High value thesis for the society
Schmitt also claimed that his thesis “contained useful and new information for the society".
According to Index.hu’s knowledge, there was a single volume of Schmitt’s incriminated thesis that was available for anyone. This was located in the library of the Semmelweis University until the fact finding committee took it out for examination in January. However, it could not be rented, it was available only on spot. It was prohibited to photocopy the document or even take pictures of it that show legible content. This must have made a wide-scale usage of it slightly difficult. In light of this, the thesis must have scored rather low on ‘social usefulness scale’ had there been any.
But wait, the best is yet to come!Schmitt admitted that he put Georgiev’s name on top of the bibliography because he copied, sorry, quoted him the most in the thesis. But then he added: “But his knowledge was already public knowledge. He researched ledgers, the result records of Olympic Games, sources that were general knowledge for everyone."
What? You cannot be serious, Mr. President! Bulgarian sport researcher Nikolai Georgiev, who died in 2005, worked on his study for years, but what he created was a mere compilation of information that was available for anyone? This is quite a unique approach, I’d say. By the way, Georgiev is the author of over 40 books on the history of the Olympic Games. “In 1987, Georgiev filed a study, written in French and entitled the “Analyse du programme olympique (des Jeux de l’Olympiade)" with the Olympic Museum’s library. It was a two-volume work, 465 pages in length, several hundred of which were taken up by tables and diagrams. Later Georgiev updated his study to include program information for the 1996 olympic games and the study was published in 1995 under the title “Analyse du programme des Jeux Olympiques 1896-1996." Quote taken from here.And Schmitt goes on: “I’m not saying that I’d created new value, but everything I put together was useful for the society, I insist on that." (See opinion above.)
“It hurt."
Schmitt said he was hurt that the decision to repeal his degree was taken while he was out of the country on an important mission.
“It did not feel nice that [when the decision was made] I was representing the country in Seoul; I had a negotiation there with key economic figures, speaking at a conference on nuclear safety. I had a discussion with the Korean President on economic and co-operation matters. Meanwhile, these [people] here [...] in an accelerated process [...], while I was not even asked [...]. I would have expected the Senate to at least wait for me. Why the rush? They should have waited one more day [...] I would have told them [...] how I view this whole thing."
While the Senate ineed decided without consulting Schmitt, the head of the fact finding committee did, and it was the findings and recommendation of this panel that the Senate considered.Schmitt added that he does not mind that the Senate withdrew his degree. “[...] good for them. I would have given it back myself if I had had to."
He also stressed that he “never bragged" with his doctorate and he “never had material or moral advantage" from it.
Schmitt fights back
“But I’ll prove that I still have perseverance, a former Olympic champion, and I’ll prove at the age of 70 that I can write a PhD thesis that is up to the current and very tough criteria. I will still obtain my doctorate degree!"
He said his thesis will be on the relation between environmental protection and sports. Schmitt said he has been Chairman of the Sport and Environment Commission of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) for over 15 years and he had gathered ample experience in this field to write a thesis.
Schmitt will have to take a course of 36 months. Then a PhD comprehensive examination awaits him, plus he'll have to first write and then defend his thesis.Fair Play Award due
Asked by the reporter whether he contemplates legal action [against who my dear? - editor’s note], Schmitt responded he wouldn’t, because it would not be fair.
“You cannot sue the President of the Republic, so I won’t sue either. I won’t sue but I’ll argue."
He said he would stand up for what he thinks just, “primarily because I have to defend the TF." (TF is the abbreviation for the College of Physical Education which operated between 1945 and 1989, but which today is called Faculty of Physical Education and Sport Sciences of Semmelweis University.)
He said he does not want his then supervisors to get hurt “because they had also acted in good faith. We had made a thesis 20 years ago and I was awarded a “summa cum laude" mark", Schmitt added. (“Summa cum laude" is the highest possible category of evaluation for a doctoral dissertation. One of the examiners, Ferenc Takács even praised the work, writing that “we would like to bring attention in particular to the fact that this topic has not been discussed neither in the domestic nor in the international academic literature with this level of detail."
Although the subject is not only serious, but gravely disappointing, reeks of unbelievable cynicism and bad for public morale, there's also a funny side to it. For more details and some funny "Schmitt memes" click on the link below.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas