As the Governor of Hungary’s central bank (NBH) revealed on 24 April, one member of the Monetary Council voted to raise the 7.00% base rate by 25 basis points (Deputy Governor Júlia Király) and one other (external member János Cinkotai) supported a 25-bp rate cut at last month’s policy meeting, the minutes of that meeting showed on Wednesday. The MPC also discussed extensively the recently announced government measures and their likely impacts.
The Monetary Council judged that the Hungarian economy was essentially stagnating, with growth only likely to resume in 2013. The level of output would remain below its potential over the period ahead. The consumer price index was expected to rise significantly this year, reflecting the effects of increases in VAT and excise duties last year and this year as well as the depreciation of forint exchange rate in the second half of 2011 and the rise in oil prices in early 2012.
The latest Government measures, announced as part of the Structural Reform Programme, were likely to result in an increase in inflation in 2013, while causing aggregate demand to contract, which in turn might reduce the risk of second-round effects on inflation.
IMF deal important
The Council continued to consider it important that an agreement between the Government and the EU and IMF be reached as soon as possible. Such an agreement would have a favourable impact on the outlook for growth and inflation and increase the room for manoeuvre in monetary policy, in addition to reducing the risks associated with financing the government debt.
More detailed assessment of reform programme only in May
Council members agreed that the economic data released since the previous interest rate decision had not materially altered the baseline projection presented in the March issue of the Quarterly Report on Inflation. However, several members noted that the consumer price index for March appeared to confirm the assumption in the Report that the pass-through of the VAT increase to prices was faster and greater than previously thought.
There was agreement among members that an overall assessment of the macroeconomic effects of the Structural Reform Programme, announced on the day before the meeting, could only be performed during the next projection round.
However, one member noted that, based on the government forecast updated in connection of the announcement of the Programme, inflation was likely to increase in 2013 as an effect of the measures.
Another member commented that the austerity measures could lead to an increase in inflation and a slowdown in growth across Europe and could therefore reduce the responsiveness of monetary policy to inflation in euro-area member countries.
Risk perception vital
Council members agreed that in the current situation factors affecting perceptions of risks were of key importance. Several members noted that the outcome of negotiations with the EU and IMF might change foreign investors’ perceptions of the risks facing the Hungarian economy in the short term. The meeting between the Hungarian Prime Minister and the President of the European Commission on the day of the Council’s interest rate-setting meeting might stabilise and even improve perceptions about Hungary, if an announcement released following the discussion showed that progress had been made and negotiations on a credit line could start shortly. However, if the meeting did not produce a breakthrough, financial market tensions could result in a rapidly deteriorating path.
In the Council’s judgement, the measures of the Programme would also affect perceptions of the risks associated with Hungarian assets in the longer term, as market participants assessed information related to the Programme.
Several members argued that the Programme was a step towards achieving sustainable fiscal and debt paths, which would help bring closer the conclusion of the excessive deficit procedure against Hungary and contribute to an improvement in perceptions about the economy.
It was also argued that the Programme would only have a clearly positive impact on perceptions if the market judged that it contained sustainable measures and did not result in a significant deterioration in the economy’s growth potential. On the whole, it was currently difficult to assess the likely impact of the measures on perceptions about the economy.
Financing risks might increase
In terms of risk perceptions, some members cautioned that a greater amount of forint-denominated government securities had to be issued this year, due to the decision to postpone issuances in foreign currency, which might increase financing risks over time.
It was also argued that the difficulties with financing were also reflected in movements in CDS premia and foreign currency bond yields recently, which indicated that perceptions about the Hungarian economy may have deteriorated relative to other economies. Several members cautioned that global risk appetite had also fallen recently, due to negative assessment of the debt position of euro-area periphery countries.
IMF deal or no deal to influence monetary policy manoeuvring room
In discussing the monetary policy options, the majority of members agreed that the data released over the past month and developments in perceptions of risks did not warrant a revision of the baseline projection in the March Report, and therefore maintaining the central bank base rate was still justified. Several members thought that a successful outcome of the negotiations with the EU and IMF was clearly in the interests of the Hungarian economy, and therefore there was no doubt that positive news would be released about the negotiations. This would clearly influence the room for manoeuvre in monetary policy.
However, several members noted that, based on a quick assessment, the measures included in the Structural Reform Programme might increase inflation risks in 2013. One member assessed that the position of the financial intermediary system was still fragile, the outflow of funds continued at a rapid pace, there were perceptible tensions in the swap market and lending conditions were deteriorating. In this situation, an increase in the base rate to signal the stance of policy would contribute to a reduction in inflation risks, a fall in yields at the longer end of the curve and an easing in financing strains.
Other members did not support an immediate increase in the base rate; however, they agreed that if the risk premium and inflation risks continued to rise, then this might necessitate monetary policy responses in the future.
One member firmly rejected the option of raising interest rates and argued in favour of reducing rates, as an interest rate increase would send the economy into recession, which would add to inflation through spiralling effects rather than reducing it.
After the discussion, the Chairman invited members to vote on the proposals put to the Council. Five members voted to maintain the base rate at 7.00%, one member voted to raise it by 25 basis points and one member voted to lower it by 25 basis points.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas