Economy
Templeton takes Hungary to court over dividend tax
Franklin Templeton Investment Fund, a company registered in Luxembourg and owned by the fund management company that holds one tenth of Hungarian debt, argues that the state had no right to demand dividend tax from it in 2004 and 2005. At that time Templeton was buying also Hungarian stocks, which were yielding a profit. The state collected a 20% dividend tax from Templeton.
Non-residents pay up!
The regulation in Hungary at that time was that if a Hungarian company invests in another resident firm and takes out the profit (dividend) it is not obliged to pay dividend tax. But if a non-resident company invests in the shares of a Hungarian company, it has an obligation to pay the levy, unless it has held onto its investment for at least two years and controlled at least 20% of the company.
However, large fund management companies, most likely Templeton too, have a different investment horizon and they keep shares only for a brief period of time, weeks or months at most, but seldom for years. Additionally, they don’t like to pack large chunks from a single stock therefore they usually do not reach the 20% threshold.
Origo.hu tried but failed to obtain information as to how much dividend tax Templeton paid. The local office of Templeton, the National Economy Ministry and tax authority NAV all refused to disclose that data. But the portal suspects it can be quite a handful of money if Templeton considered it to be worth going up against the state in court.
Favourble odds for Templeton
http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.js f?text=&docid=122688&pageIndex=0&doclang=en&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=2358248
This spring, Templeton asked the court to examine if the exemption from tax on dividends granted by the Hungarian legislation to a recipient of dividends resident in Hungary is compatible with the provisions of the EU Treaties on the principle of freedom of establishment, the principle of equal treatment and the principle of free movement of capital, given that “a non-resident recipient of dividends is exempt from tax on dividends only if it meets certain legal requirements, namely that its holding (in the case of shares, the proportion of its registered shares) in the company capital of the resident company at the time of distribution (allocation) of dividends amounted permanently to at least 20% for at least two consecutive years, taking account of the fact that, in the event that the permanent holding of 20% is maintained for less than two consecutive years, the company distributing the dividends is not obliged to withhold the tax on the dividends and the company which receives the dividends or, in the event of non-monetary allocations, the company which distributes them are not obliged to pay that tax on submission of their tax return if another person or the party distributing the dividends has guaranteed the payment of the tax.
Origo.hu said Templeton’s chances of winning are good, because the ECJ has brought several favourable decisions in more or less similar cases over the dividend tax, when there was discrimination by a member state between non-resident and resident taxpayers. Local attorney, Dániel Kelemen at PwC Legal (Réti, Antall & Partners Law Firm), wrote in legal magazine Európai Jog (European Law) that he was of this view too. Encouraged by the ECJ’s ruling several companies registered abroad with investments in Hungary have decided to follow the footsteps of Templeton and ask for a refund of the dividend tax they paid in 2004-2005.
The Hungarian courts mostly ruled in favour of the businesses, but the tax authority requested a review and the case went up to the Curia. Instead of delivering a ruling, however, the Curia has forwarded the case to the ECJ, while, Kelemen said, the ECJ’s previous decisions make it clear how will the case end. This is how the Templeton case probably ended up in Luxembourg.
A lot of people stand behind Templeton
The reason why the focus is on Templeton now is because this case may be the first where the ECJ delivers a ruling. The case was not discussed yet therefore experts believe a decision is unlikely to be handed down this year.
If the court rules in favour of Templeton it might cost a pretty penny for the state and repay not only the collected dividend tax of a few tens or hundreds of billions of forints. Based on previous ECJ decisions on similar cases, the applicants may also claim interest, which - considering that the levy was paid 6-7 years ago - could exceed the size of the tax itself.
Non-residents pay up!
The regulation in Hungary at that time was that if a Hungarian company invests in another resident firm and takes out the profit (dividend) it is not obliged to pay dividend tax. But if a non-resident company invests in the shares of a Hungarian company, it has an obligation to pay the levy, unless it has held onto its investment for at least two years and controlled at least 20% of the company.
However, large fund management companies, most likely Templeton too, have a different investment horizon and they keep shares only for a brief period of time, weeks or months at most, but seldom for years. Additionally, they don’t like to pack large chunks from a single stock therefore they usually do not reach the 20% threshold.
Origo.hu tried but failed to obtain information as to how much dividend tax Templeton paid. The local office of Templeton, the National Economy Ministry and tax authority NAV all refused to disclose that data. But the portal suspects it can be quite a handful of money if Templeton considered it to be worth going up against the state in court.
Favourble odds for Templeton
http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.js f?text=&docid=122688&pageIndex=0&doclang=en&mode=lst&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=2358248
This spring, Templeton asked the court to examine if the exemption from tax on dividends granted by the Hungarian legislation to a recipient of dividends resident in Hungary is compatible with the provisions of the EU Treaties on the principle of freedom of establishment, the principle of equal treatment and the principle of free movement of capital, given that “a non-resident recipient of dividends is exempt from tax on dividends only if it meets certain legal requirements, namely that its holding (in the case of shares, the proportion of its registered shares) in the company capital of the resident company at the time of distribution (allocation) of dividends amounted permanently to at least 20% for at least two consecutive years, taking account of the fact that, in the event that the permanent holding of 20% is maintained for less than two consecutive years, the company distributing the dividends is not obliged to withhold the tax on the dividends and the company which receives the dividends or, in the event of non-monetary allocations, the company which distributes them are not obliged to pay that tax on submission of their tax return if another person or the party distributing the dividends has guaranteed the payment of the tax.
Origo.hu said Templeton’s chances of winning are good, because the ECJ has brought several favourable decisions in more or less similar cases over the dividend tax, when there was discrimination by a member state between non-resident and resident taxpayers. Local attorney, Dániel Kelemen at PwC Legal (Réti, Antall & Partners Law Firm), wrote in legal magazine Európai Jog (European Law) that he was of this view too. Encouraged by the ECJ’s ruling several companies registered abroad with investments in Hungary have decided to follow the footsteps of Templeton and ask for a refund of the dividend tax they paid in 2004-2005.
The Hungarian courts mostly ruled in favour of the businesses, but the tax authority requested a review and the case went up to the Curia. Instead of delivering a ruling, however, the Curia has forwarded the case to the ECJ, while, Kelemen said, the ECJ’s previous decisions make it clear how will the case end. This is how the Templeton case probably ended up in Luxembourg.
A lot of people stand behind Templeton
The reason why the focus is on Templeton now is because this case may be the first where the ECJ delivers a ruling. The case was not discussed yet therefore experts believe a decision is unlikely to be handed down this year.
If the court rules in favour of Templeton it might cost a pretty penny for the state and repay not only the collected dividend tax of a few tens or hundreds of billions of forints. Based on previous ECJ decisions on similar cases, the applicants may also claim interest, which - considering that the levy was paid 6-7 years ago - could exceed the size of the tax itself.









