Hungary: a market to avoid, a big Underweight - BofA Merrill Lynch

Portfolio
Due to the latest measures leading to higher taxes and other reasons, Hungary’s already challenged equity story could come to an end, but many investors remain optimistic and do not realise that unless we get the stars aligning, in due course Hungary can demonstrate why it is probably one of the riskiest markets in the world, said research analysts at Bank of America Merrill Lynch, in a note where they describe the country as “a market to avoid - a big Underweight."

In a trip note published in parallel with this one Raffaella Tenconi, economist at BofA/ML in London, lowered her 2013 GDP estimate for Hungary to -0.3% from +0.8% previously. She believes the country cannot afford the luxury to not striking a credit deal with the IMF/EU and emphasised that the longer an agreement is delayed, the more likely it ultimately fails to deliver the confidence that is needed.

The analysts believe that even if Budapest inks a deal with the lenders, it is only likely to stabilize markets but it’s unlikely to change the growth outlook unless it also delivers confidence that Hungary is through the worst both economically and on a policy basis. In Tenconi’s view, a “weak" central bank (NBH) Governor to replace Simor would set the floor for the policy rate at 5.00% despite the severe weakness in the economy, as this would weaken market confidence and put pressure on the currency. A strong governor, with anchored fiscal policy, may be able to bring the policy rate to all-time lows of 4.00%.
The institutionalisation of higher taxation changed the picture

The past few days have brought key developments to Hungary that support BofA/ML’s Underweight of the market. First has been tax policy which has seen “efforts to institutionalize previously one off taxation" with higher taxes on energy/MOL and the bank tax being made permanent, Tenconi reminded. And second has been the removal of Gedeon Richter, a defensive standout, from the MSCI emerging markets index. Hungary is now just 0.2% of the index via three stocks.

The analysts noted that having been negative on Hungarian equities through 2011, BofA/ML turned more constructive in December 2011 and moved to Marketweight as the market was then fully focused on Hungary’s vulnerabilities, while they felt the domestic political pendulum had shifted towards an IMF deal. Since August 2012 BofA/ML has moved to a modest Underweight on the view the still-unrealized IMF deal looks almost fully in the price.

“With the institutionalization of higher taxation, MSCI changes and our fundamental view that Hungary’s valuations reflect more of the still uncertain put to the IMF than its extreme economic vulnerabilities, we now recommend a big Underweight position in Hungary," Tenconi said.

Shouldn’t be so constructive on stocks, OTP EPS estimate, TP lowered

“Beyond the simple (and we think stale) view of Hungary as a risk proxy, we find a number of investors are constructive Hungary on stock valuations," BofA/ML’s research analysts said. But they also think it is difficult to divorce Hungarian macro from most major stocks.

They mentioned, as an “obvious example", market bell-weather OTP “as Hungary’s structural growth vulnerability is driven by the overhang from consumer Swiss franc mortgage borrowing and the resulting US scale of negative equity for Hungarian mortgage holders."

Hungary’s government increased its squeeze on banks, by 1) doubling the level of new Financial Transaction Tax (FTT) from Jan 2013, to 0.2% from 0.1% and, 2) making the special banking tax permanent against a pledge to phase it out (the original plan was to do it in 2013 and then it was changed to 2014 and then dropped once and for all). Adding corporate income tax, BofA/ML estimates that Hungarian banks will now pay over 40% effective tax rate.

A few days ago BofA/ML’s analysts cut their target price for OTP to HUF 3,200 from HUF 4,000 previously on the higher tax burden (rating: Underperform). They also lowered their 13E onward EPS by 17-23%. They now take HUF37bn (gross) special banking tax paid by OTP in 2012 into infinity and also estimate HUF69bn of gross FTT, or 30% of HUF 230 bn that government targets from FTT. The bank assumes that OTP will pass-on 75% of its FTT to customers.

“So on net basis, we see HUF17bn negative impact annually from FTT for OTP. The bank is hesitant to guide on FTT impact it said that pass-on to corporates could be more difficult than to retail. Moreover, in 1Q13 the FTT burden may be higher due to delays in tariff changes. Our new EPS for OTP is 30% below consensus, implying to us that sell-side has not yet reflected all the tax changes," the analysts added in a research note on 19 Nov.

Klikk a képre!
Hungarian equity story fizzled out

“Hungary, already a challenged equity story with little more than an IMF deal to hang its hat on, has seen further deterioration in its equity story," Tenconi said, citing three main reasons for her view.

  • “The post crisis temporary tax on the banks has been made permanent. This equates to an effective tax rate being sustained at around 40%.
  • The corporate tax rate on energy companies to a headline 50% less deductions (effectively raising the tax rate on MOL by 4 percentage points).
  • The removal of Gedeon Richter from the MSCI Emerging Index - reducing the importance of Hungary overall in GEM from 0.3% to 0.2% and importantly removing what was arguably the highest quality/most defensive stock in the market from the GEM benchmark."


' title='
Hungarian households are suffering

At the end of 2011 Hungary looked an “exceptional risk proxy on overwhelming market fears" and, in BofA/ML’s view, an IMF deal was likely. This time around however they argue Hungary (and indeed the entirety of EU focused CEE, is “not a way to express a bullish view on the Draghi put). Why? We find Hungarian upside capped due to the dire growth outlook and legacy of CHF debt."

“With pressure on crucial exports to Europe and no signs of life in the consumer despite some CHF mortgage restructuring we think Hungarian equities can be viewed as no more than a trade," Tenconi said.

“With the move to make the tax on banks permanent, the raising of taxes on energy, prospective changes in leadership at the Central Bank and the negative outlook of ratings agencies more likely to lead to action, that trade looks to have run the bulk of its course." Hence the “big Underweight" recommendation, with strong downside projected in OTP.

The research analysts at BofA/ML firmly believe domestic auto sales are “the single best indicator of big ticket, interest rate sensitive consumer demand in just about any market."

They frequently discuss a chart showing current annualized run rates for auto sales across EEMEA vs. the respective country’s pre-crisis 2006-2008 average. “That chart alone made us acutely aware of Turkey’s 2010 overheating while an undemanding yet clearly positive trend kept us overweight the South African consumer for almost three years."

The chart below focuses on Central Europe with a clear downward trend apparent in Poland and the Czech Republic. In the case of Hungary, the chart clearly illustrates “the scale of the pain the Hungarian consumer is facing and ultimately the reality of what is behind even performing loans in the Hungarian banking sector."

“While there was a modest uptick in demand post the end 2011 haircut to debt from upper income Hungarians who could repay their CHF mortgages, that proved short-lived. Until stimulus is matched with confidence - Hungary looks poised to struggle economically," Tenconi said.

Klikk a képre!
Lack of growth could trigger even more aggressive steps

As mentioned above, Tenconi has just lowered her 2013 GDP estimate for Hungary to -0.3% from +0.8% previously, expecting the three rounds of budget adjustment to impact household and investment heavily.

“Until Hungary is definitively on the path to recovery with rising house prices, it is difficult to argue that Hungary will not remain an acutely vulnerable economy," Tenconi said. In her view, it was clearly just the expectation of an IMF deal that has helped the currency, “but the longer a deal is delayed and the longer corporates face an uncertain policy outlook, the less likely that confidence will recover enough to stimulate investment," BofA/ML economists said.

“Coupled with a weak EU and a very low probability that consumers will drive growth, it is easy to imagine Hungary struggling to grow through to the 2014 elections. With the nature of economic policy choices to date (even in the absence of electoral pressure) it is not difficult to imagine a combination of no growth and pending elections leading to even more aggressive policy actions to reduce the painful consumer burden," they added.

Can’t afford the luxury

“Unlike in Turkey which ultimately did not need the IMF to retain market confidence & growth - Hungary has no such luxury," the analyst noted, adding that “the longer a deal is delayed, the more likely it ultimately fails to deliver the confidence that is needed."

The analysts said a “modest kicker" could be expected if Hungary actually gets an IMF deal signed, albeit, in her view, that seems less likely with these tax moves.

“Yet even so it is only likely to stabilize markets/the currency but it’s unlikely to change the growth outlook unless it also delivers confidence that Hungary is through the worst both economically and on a policy basis," they added..

“With Hungary’s recent policy history and its lack of flexibility due to the scale of currency mismatch in the consumer sector (ie no potential for a devaluation to drive growth is a disappointing similarity with Greece). Unless we get the stars aligning, in due course Hungary can demonstrate why it is probably one of the riskiest markets in the world."

MPC “acutely aware of the risks"

After a recent trip to Budapest Tenconi noted that the majority of the Monetary Policy Council sees a “compelling case to lower interest rates given the continuing recession and no evidence of second round inflation risks at this stage."

That said, she maintains the view that the MPC is “acutely aware of the risks to financial stability from unexpected exogenous shocks and significant fluctuations in the currency." Therefore she believes the rate-setters will thus likely maintain a “clear easing stance as long as the currency and the bond market remain stable."

She added that the nomination and appointment of the next NBH Governor, who will replace András Simor, will affect the speed and magnitude of the monetary easing ahead.

The analyst expects the Government Debt Management Agency (ÁKK) to continue to avoid the Eurobond market as long as the negotiations with the IMF-EU continue, which, in her view, will last at least through spring but she does not expect will deliver successful negotiation of the program.

“However, some relief to the FX funding needs could come from the AKK decision to start issuing euro local bonds, which will be open to retail and institutional investors (residents and non-residents)."

New NBH Governor vs. rate path

After her visit to Budapest, Tenconi expects the MPC to cut by a further 50 basis points this year to 5.75%, entering a pause until April (after the new Governor is appointed), cutting to 5.00% by July 2013.

In her view a “weak" governor sets the floor for the policy rate at 5.00% despite the severe weakness in the economy, as this would weaken market confidence and put pressure on the currency.

“We believe a weak governor will lead the four current external members to turn more cautious, blocking excessive easing, consistent with their view that financial stability needs to be preserved," Tenconi said.

“On the other hand, if Orbán were to surprise the market with a “very positive" nomination, namely someone very qualified and a perceived independent economist, will send a clear message that the government will keep its distance from the central bank. This will be even more effective if the two new vice governors are also perceived as politically independent," she added.

A strong governor, with anchored fiscal policy, may then be able to bring the policy rate to all-time lows of 4.00%, “leveraging on the abundant global liquidity and weak growth outlook."

At this stage, she attaches only a small likelihood to this scenario, though she believes things may become clearer closer to the appointment period.

In the local press three recurring names have been speculated: Mihály Varga, chief IMF-EU negotiator; György Matolcsy, Economy Minister; and Antal Rogán, Fidesz parliamentary leader. Given Prime Minister Orbán’s track record of appointing reasonable members to the NBH, Tenconi thinks Varga is the most likely candidate.

See whom the market would like to see and thinks will eventually see succeed Simor at the link below (Portfolio.hu survey).With regard to the 2014 elections, BofA/ML’s central scenario is that Fidesz will win another mandate in the spring of 2014, albeit with a much smaller majority in Parliament.
 

More in Economy

benzin_3
February 27, 2026 13:45

Could the price of petrol really leap to HUF 1,000 a litre in Hungary?

The situation is more complex than it may seem at first glance

adó-munkaerőpiac-foglalkoztatás-szocho-adókedvezmény
February 27, 2026 09:46

The labour market situation is deteriorating in Hungary

Employment hits five-year low

D_MTI20260210007
February 27, 2026 09:18

Hungary's Orbán plans new steps with Fico to bring back Druzhba flow

Prime Minister speaks in regular interview

szijjártó péter
February 26, 2026 16:56

Ukraine summons Hungary's chargé d'affaires in Kyiv - MoFA

Conflict remains heated

Mol Dunai Finomító Dufi kőolajfinomító benzin naplemente
February 26, 2026 16:42

Hungary's Mol threatens Janaf, sets Friday deadline

The oil company may turn to the European Commission

LATEST NEWS
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts, spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas

Detailed search