Economy
Hungary farther from IMF deal than a year ago - Simor
Save article
Share
Speaking at a press conference after the Monetary Council cut the base rate for the fourth consecutive month by 25 basis points (to 6.00%), Simor said a deal with the IMF/EU would be important for growth, financial stability and the predictability of economic policy. Answering a question he reminded that keeping the budget deficit below 3.0% of GDP is not enough to secure a financial assistance programme.
Simor read an IMF statement from earlier this month, in which the Fund said there are no formal talks with the Hungarian authorities.
"I do not have a date for the resumption of the mission to Hungary. No mission currently planned," Gerry Rice, Director of the Fund’s External Relations Department, told a press briefing on 1 November.
Simor said that in his view Hungary is farther from an IMF deal than it was a year ago when it turned to the Fund for help.
Rice also noted that in order to return to Budapest the IMF and the European Commission would first need to see the Hungarian government regarding both of them as "valuable partners", and that it would still not be enough.
"I can also say that meaningful progress on programme negotiations would require a clear indication from the authorities that they see the IMF and the EC as valuable partners in designing the reform and adjustment process, and a clear commitment from them to policies that ensure balanced fiscal adjustment and promote growth," Rice said.
Controversial situation abroad
Global market sentiment is very good, but this is not reflected in real economic fundamentals. It is yet to be seen how this controversy will diminish in the future, Simor said.
Fiscal steps to cause cost side pressure in the mid-term
The unfavourable investment dynamics and the persistently high rate of unemployment indicate that potential growth is deteriorating. Addressing the government’s latest fiscal adjustment measures Simor noted that a more detailed assessment of these will be available in the central bank’s next Report on Inflation due out in December.
In this respect he only said the cabinet’s commitment to keeping the budget deficit low is to be appreciated, but the adjustment measures (bank tax, financial transaction tax, utility tax) will be intensifying the cost side inflation pressure in the medium term and via worsening the capital attraction capacity of the banking system they also have a negative impact on potential growth.
Doves vs. Hawks - 4:3
The MPC discussed two proposals today, one to cut the base rate by 25 bps and one to keep it on hold, Simor said.
He also noted that Hungary’s inflation could exceed the central bank’s 3.0% CPI target both this year and net, basically due to one-off shocks, but some more durable factors could also be at play.
The Hungarian economy is in recession, growth may resume next year, but for that Hungary would need to see some upturn on its export markets first, Simor added.Things could change - Standard Bank
Timothy Ash, analyst at Standard Bank in London, said Simor’s remark about Hungary being farther from an IMF deal now than when it sought IMF assistance a year ago was a “fair comment" and it “underlines that there are no formal talks."
“Indeed, the relationship between the two sides has soured quite significantly over recent months.
“But the market does not seem to care as long as a) global markets remain liquid, and unwilling to penalise any EM credit by going particularly short for long; b) the govt is still sitting on a HUF2 trillion cash buffer; c) the government is still holding to a sub-3% budget deficit target d) the current account remains in balance/surplus.
“Things could change in my view, if we see a broader market risk reversal, or we see the govt make an unorthodox appointment to the NBH (e.g. Matolcsy), or we see big tickets debt issuance, and then marked fiscal loosening - which seems likely in my mind in H2 2013 as we head to the parliamentary elections in April 2014. Remember the Hungarian economy is not growing, is mired in recession, and shows no sign whatsoever of recovering - presumably Orban will want to become more populist in the run up to the April 2014 elections, and this means either fiscal pump priming, or banging the drum on nationalist issues, or finding some extra cash under the mattress (probably of foreign owned big business, if past experience is anything to go by."
Click on the link below for more analyst comments on the rate decision.
Simor read an IMF statement from earlier this month, in which the Fund said there are no formal talks with the Hungarian authorities.
"I do not have a date for the resumption of the mission to Hungary. No mission currently planned," Gerry Rice, Director of the Fund’s External Relations Department, told a press briefing on 1 November.
Simor said that in his view Hungary is farther from an IMF deal than it was a year ago when it turned to the Fund for help.
Rice also noted that in order to return to Budapest the IMF and the European Commission would first need to see the Hungarian government regarding both of them as "valuable partners", and that it would still not be enough.
"I can also say that meaningful progress on programme negotiations would require a clear indication from the authorities that they see the IMF and the EC as valuable partners in designing the reform and adjustment process, and a clear commitment from them to policies that ensure balanced fiscal adjustment and promote growth," Rice said.
Controversial situation abroad
Global market sentiment is very good, but this is not reflected in real economic fundamentals. It is yet to be seen how this controversy will diminish in the future, Simor said.
Fiscal steps to cause cost side pressure in the mid-term
The unfavourable investment dynamics and the persistently high rate of unemployment indicate that potential growth is deteriorating. Addressing the government’s latest fiscal adjustment measures Simor noted that a more detailed assessment of these will be available in the central bank’s next Report on Inflation due out in December.
In this respect he only said the cabinet’s commitment to keeping the budget deficit low is to be appreciated, but the adjustment measures (bank tax, financial transaction tax, utility tax) will be intensifying the cost side inflation pressure in the medium term and via worsening the capital attraction capacity of the banking system they also have a negative impact on potential growth.
Doves vs. Hawks - 4:3
The MPC discussed two proposals today, one to cut the base rate by 25 bps and one to keep it on hold, Simor said.
He also noted that Hungary’s inflation could exceed the central bank’s 3.0% CPI target both this year and net, basically due to one-off shocks, but some more durable factors could also be at play.
The Hungarian economy is in recession, growth may resume next year, but for that Hungary would need to see some upturn on its export markets first, Simor added.Things could change - Standard Bank
Timothy Ash, analyst at Standard Bank in London, said Simor’s remark about Hungary being farther from an IMF deal now than when it sought IMF assistance a year ago was a “fair comment" and it “underlines that there are no formal talks."
“Indeed, the relationship between the two sides has soured quite significantly over recent months.
“But the market does not seem to care as long as a) global markets remain liquid, and unwilling to penalise any EM credit by going particularly short for long; b) the govt is still sitting on a HUF2 trillion cash buffer; c) the government is still holding to a sub-3% budget deficit target d) the current account remains in balance/surplus.
“Things could change in my view, if we see a broader market risk reversal, or we see the govt make an unorthodox appointment to the NBH (e.g. Matolcsy), or we see big tickets debt issuance, and then marked fiscal loosening - which seems likely in my mind in H2 2013 as we head to the parliamentary elections in April 2014. Remember the Hungarian economy is not growing, is mired in recession, and shows no sign whatsoever of recovering - presumably Orban will want to become more populist in the run up to the April 2014 elections, and this means either fiscal pump priming, or banging the drum on nationalist issues, or finding some extra cash under the mattress (probably of foreign owned big business, if past experience is anything to go by."
Click on the link below for more analyst comments on the rate decision.









