(Adds comment by Nomura, Citi, KBC on page2) Hungary’s central bank (NHB) lowered its key policy rate by 25 basis points to 6.00% on Tuesday, in line with the market’s call, although a hold decision was also in the air, after Standard & Poor’s cut Hungary further into junk grade last Friday.
“The improvement in global risk appetite has provided Hungary’s National Bank with the scope to loosen policy. But persistent financial vulnerabilities mean that, without an IMF deal in place, the Bank could be forced into rate hikes to defend the forint if faced with a fresh deterioration in investor sentiment.
“This lunchtime, the National Bank of Hungary (NBH) cut its benchmark interest rate by 25bps to 6.00%. The move was widely expected. The NBH had cut rates by 25bps at each of its previous three meetings, and both we and the Bloomberg consensus expected a further 25bp cut today. This means that the current easing cycle has completely unwound the 100bps of defensive rate hikes that the MPC was forced into by growing tensions in the financial markets late last year.
“Once again, it’s likely that the vote to cut rates passed with the slimmest of majorities. The MPC includes four “external" (government-appointed) MPC members who seem to be more concerned with growth than with inflation or risk perceptions (which are the main concerns of the three “internal" MPC members - who are Bank staff and include Governor Simor). At the past three rate-setting meetings, all four external members have voted to cut rates while the internal members have voted to keep rates on hold.
“With Q3 GDP data (released earlier this month) showing that the economy is sliding deeper into recession, growth concerns pushed the external MPC members to vote to cut rates again. By contrast, we think the internal members probably all voted to keep rates on hold. After all, inflation at 6.0% last month remains well above target (admittedly, it is driven in large part by tax rises and food and energy inflation). And perhaps more importantly, the economy is still highly exposed to the external financing environment (and thus swings in investor sentiment) as a result of its heavy external debt burden. This is exacerbated by the fact that an IMF deal now looks like a very distant prospect.
“In the near-term, the poor growth outlook means that the external MPC members are likely to hold sway. Hence, the current easing cycle could have further to run. Indeed, several external members have hinted that they see the “equilibrium" interest rate (i.e. the rate which is consistent with stable inflation) at around 5% or possibly even lower. But whether the MPC does actually cut rates further depends entirely on whether the financial markets let them.
“For now, the markets don’t seem to be paying much attention to events within Hungary itself. An IMF deal is looking increasingly unlikely, but at the same time market strains have eased. What’s more, the markets barely flinched in reaction to S&P’s decision to downgrade Hungary last week. Instead, easing tensions in local financial markets reflect an improvement in global risk appetite more generally.
“However, we doubt that things will stay this way for long. Our view is that the euro-crisis will escalate once again over the coming year to the point that the single currency starts to break up. The financial dislocation associated with such an event is likely to cause market sentiment to sour. Without an IMF deal in place, we think the NBH could be forced into defensive rate hikes to stem capital outflows.
“As such, while we wouldn’t be surprised to see a few more rate cuts over the coming months, ultimately, we think these will be reversed and we expect interest rates to end next year at 6.00%."
Gábor Ambrus, 4Cast, Sofia
“In line with nearly unanimous market expectations, but against our call, the Hungarian Monetary Policy Council has decided to cut the base rate by 25bp to 6.00%.
“After the meeting Governor Simor made it clear that it was another tight 4:3 vote in favour of the 25bp rate cut. The statement is dovish all around and implies further easing down the road. Interestingly, the key sentence in the statement was mistranslated.
“Unlike the statement that followed the October rate setting meeting, the original Hungarian version of the current statement contains no controversial reference to the data of the ‘next months’ as a precondition for a cut, it only conditions further easing on the persistence of the favourable financial market trends, and on the mid term 3% target being in reach.
“További kamatcsökkentésre akkor kerülhet sor, ha a kedvező pénzügyi piaci folyamatok folytatódnak és a középtávú inflációs kilátások a 3 százalékos céllal összhangban alakulnak."
This in our translation reads as:
“Further easing should be possible if the favourable financial market trends endure and if the medium term inflation outlook is in line with the 3% inflation target."
While the official translation in English says:
“The Council will consider a further reduction in interest rates if data becoming available in the coming months confirm that the improvement in financial market sentiment continues and the medium-term outlook for inflation remains consistent with the 3 per cent target."
“The official English translation contains the reference to the data of the ‘next months’, which some, including us thought last month as an indication for a potential slowdown of the pace of the easing cycle.
“In case of a difference, the Hungarian version should be considered the original. The text has been changed back to the pre-October version, without reference to several month’s worth of data -this leaves no doubt about the continuation of the easing cycle."
Zoltán Árokszállási, Erste Bank, Budapest
“Governor Simor said that the MPC discussed a 25bp cut and keeping the policy rate on hold, and the rate reduction had a slim majority. This again suggests a voting pattern of 4-3 in favor of external members as is not at all a surprise. The MPC’s statement said that the CPI target can be reached in 2014, while it also pointed out that “there remains a substantial margin of spare capacity in the economy". On the other hand, Governor Simor talked about increasing base CPI trends in recent months and told that he thinks Hungary is further away from an IMF deal than a year ago. This again shows how divided the MPC is and also cannot be considered a big surprise.
“As for the inflation outlook, a theoretically significant determinant of monetary policy, we still expect that it is not too easy to reach the CPI target even in 2014. However, the MPC will likely continue to communicate that the CPI target is within reach on the relevant policy horizon. Thus, in the upcoming months, from the point of view of price developments, the council is not expected to see a burden to further rate easing.
“As for risk assessment, the picture is not that straightforward, however. The change of leadership in the central bank may be a risk for the upcoming months. Furthermore, the MPC’s statement also says that “higher risks around the agreement with the multinational organisations and the downgrade of Hungary’s sovereign debt by S&P may lead to an increase in perceptions of the risks associated with the economy".
“This may indicate some uncertainty among the more dovish external members as well. In addition, the external sentiment may still become less favorable given the well-known risks (US fiscal cliff, Euro Area economic problems). Overall, we expect no strong improvement in risk assessment in the upcoming weeks, but no big deterioration is anticipated either at the moment.
“Overall, we stick to our earlier forecasts. The policy rate may stand at 6% at the end of 2012 and we expect one 25bp reduction in each quarter of 2013. Nonetheless, risks are tilted towards a rate cut already next month."
Timothy Ash, Standard Bank, London
“MPC is split 4:3 on non-exec and exec members...exec members have been resisting cuts in recent sessions, but outweighted by non-exec members appointed by Fidesz government.
“More cuts expected, with economy still in the doldrums, and with relative HUF strength/stability, concerns over inflation still being close to double the NBH target are not a priority for the bulk of the MPC. With liquid global financing conditions, "market risk" has receded for the bulk of the MPC. Key question mark though going forward- next 3 months - will be who will replace incumbent governor Simor when he bows out in March. The market will want an orthodox replacement. An unconventional choice could still un-nerve the market."
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas