Hungarian lawmakers are scheduled to vote today on a proposal about the so-called settlement government bond, which could not only result in substantial funds for the Government Debt Management Agency (ÁKK), but also carry criminal-national security and economic risks.
A bill submitted at the end of October seeks to amend the law on the entry and stay of third-country citizens in order to create the legal framework for investor residency. Under the proposal, if citizen of a non-EU member state provides evidence to the purchase of at least 250,000 euros (cc. HUF 70 m) worth of five-year, so-called Settlement Government Bond then this will be taken into consideration with an exceptional weight in the examination of settlement permit applications.
Since then the bill has been fine-tuned on many points. One of these is that the bond buyers will not be automatically granted settlement permit, only a residence permit (which may be given for no more than five years and can be renewed). No sooner than six months after that the subjects may apply for a national settlement permit giving them the right for an unlimited stay in Hungary, local daily Népszabadság reported on Monday.
Here are the risks
The paper said the amendment proposal Ministry of the Interior off guard. The bill carries several criminal and national security risks, since it is virtually impossible to trace the source of the money used by foreign citizens to buy Hungarian bonds, i.e. settlement permits. The ministry’s concerns were later dispersed by the government that the existing conditions to obtaining a settlement permit, such as having no criminal record, will remain intact, the paper added. It is still unclear, though whether the government is willing to give permanent settlement permits and/or also Hungarian citizenship for HUF 70 billion.
Great interest, could be of great help for the budget
According to government sources, the idea of the bond was conceived primarily over a strong interest by wealthy Chinese investors, but Portfolio.hu learned that a lot of Vietnamese investors are also seeking settlement opportunities in the European Union. Recent press reports were about 14,000-16,000 potential bond buyers, but it seems the actual interest could be a lot bigger than that.
We need to note that Spain has also recently launched a similar initiative (where residency permits are up for EUR 160,000 worth of real estate purchase) and similar systems are in effect in other countries as well.
Assuming that 10,000 people will buy this new bond and no more than the legal minimum of EUR 250,000 each, Hungary’s ÁKK will have at its disposal (in the coming months and quarters for a five-year period) a total of EUR 2.5 billion worth of FX funds. This could be a massive - and more importantly medium term - item to use for debt financing. Next year the debt management agency will need to refinance EUR 8-8.5 bn worth of (FX) debt (maturing bonds and due IMF loan tranches). The possibly substantial funds that may be gained by selling Settlement Government Bonds could reduce the need to tap international capital markets for foreign currency funds (bond issuance) and will further reduce the need of the government to secure a financial assistance programme with the IMF/EU.
Besides the criminal/national security risks, the purchase of the special bond (by Asians) could carry economic risks too. A source knowledgeable of the Chinese economy pointed out to Népszabadság that investors lured here by the state to help Hungary’s debt financing may take out loans from their domestic banks at much better conditions and with businesses set up in Hungary with these funds may easily “beat" local small and medium-sized enterprises. This, the paper said, could deliver a similar shock to the SME sector that it had gone through around the change of regime.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas