Hungary’s Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has heralded the introduction of a new tax. He added, though, that there is no final decision on the advertisement tax yet and he did not even go into details about it. The idea of such a levy was raised twice in the 2000s, so it is worth taking a look at what was in the making back then.
The same scenario with a 7-month gap
PM Orbán sent yet another message to the European Commission late on Wednesday. He told a press conference in Brussels that he is confident the first one of the three fiscal correction measures recently announced should be enough to keep the deficit below the EU’s 3% threshold and thus be allowed to exit the excessive deficit procedure. But he added that he personally is in favour of taking the other two steps too.
The first one is a spending freeze to the tune of 0.3% of GDP (some HUF 90 bn). The second is the suspension of state investment projects (e.g. stadium constructions) and the third is the raising of taxes on the financial and energy sectors.
Orbán said he is in favour of covering certain one-off expenditures from one-off revenues at the expense of state assets and hike the financial transaction levy, the bank tax and the energy tax and also impose a new advertisement tax. He added that by the time he returns home the bill on the latter should be ready and on his desk.
This is not the first time a new tax on the corporate sector is mentioned by the PM. The last time he told public radio MR1 last Friday that he would not refuse raising the bank tax or the FTT should Brussels require it.
The timing of Orbán’s above remark in Brussels was most likely deliberate, as this way the PM could send a message to the European Commission, saying that if the EU executive fails to consider the first two balance-improving measures announced on 10 May sufficient (to revise its deficit estimate downward from 3.3% for 2014) then the next step will be raising taxes. The EC, however, has criticised the levies a number of times. In an occasional paper on macroeconomic imbalances in Hungary published last month the Commission said revenues from sectoral taxes have gradually increased from 0.5% to 2.5% of GDP from 2009 to 2013). This comes in addition to the revenues of around 1% of GDP from the standard corporate income taxes and 1.5% of GDP from the local business tax.
The EC stressed that that (sur)taxes on corporations may have negative incentive effects, especially when inputs to production are not exempted. In particular, they may impact on economic growth via several channels, notably through their potential distortionary impact on investment and productivity.
It also claimed that from the point of view of a catching-up country, it is also important that high taxes on corporations may also discourage inbound foreign direct investment. Furthermore the EC is concerned that the introduction of specific sectoral taxes also tends to artificially reallocate capital inputs between sectors, creating economic inefficiencies and reminded that the investment ratio has declined to its historical low level (17%) and investment is most subdued in sectors particularly hit by surtaxes.
Orbán is apparently trying to put pressure on the Commission as its College will convene on 29 May to release the assessment of the latest Hungarian measures and that is when the specific country reports will be published, along with a recommendation whether the EDP should or should not be abrogated.
According to original plans the third step of the package announced by Economy Minister Mihály Varga on 10 May will be taken only if the spending freeze and new financing for one-off state investments fail to persuade the EC about the achievability of the budget deficit target.
Hungary’s Prime Minister Viktor Orbán (l) holds a press conference after an extraordinary summit of the heads of EU member states in Brussels on 22 May 2013. On his left is Bertalan Havasi, press chief for the PM.
Orbán’s current remark bears an eerie resemblance to what he said in October 2012.
At a press conference in Brussels he unveiled the cabinet’s plan to collect additional billions of forints in 2013 by raising the bank tax, the utility infrastructure tax and the levy on energy companies. After the announcement of two fiscal adjustment packages in the autumn by Economy Minister György Matolcsy this served to persuade the Commission to let Hungary out of the EDP. On 18 November last year Matolcsy unveiled the details of his third austerity package in six weeks.
This one included a hike to the corporate income tax on energy companies, centralized the utility infrastructure tax and set the bank tax in stone for an indefinite period of time.
Hungary’s Prime Minister Viktor Orbán and Péter Szijjártó, state secretary for foreign policy and economy at the Prime Minister's Office, hold a press conference on the second day of an EU summit in Brussels on 19 October 2012.
Who can it hurt?
The idea of a tax on advertisements had come up more than once in the past. In the autumn of 2000 members of the governing party in Parliament’s budget committee proposed the implementation of a 6% ad tax. Their idea was to take 6% of the advertising revenues of written and electronic press as of 1 January 2001. The committee finally voted against the proposal.
The same idea came up again in December 2008, when unions suggested a 3% tax on advertisement revenues at a meeting of the National Interest Reconciliation Council due to banks’ aggressive advertisement campaigns. This time the state was to collect the additional billions of forints from the companies advertising and online media that run the adverts.
(Based on the estimate size of the advertising market a 3% tax would now yield HUF 5 bn revenues for the state and a 6% tax would bring cc. HUF 10 bn to state coffers.)
If the government sets the rate of the new levy as a ratio of annual advertising revenues, it will be similar to a proposal put forward in March on a new meteorological services fee (a surtax on media).
Under that proposal the "service fee" would have been 0.5% of the annual advertising revenues of any media - irrespective of whether they broadcast weather forecasts/reports or not.
According to the latest reports, Parliament may approve the new meteorological law already in the first half of the year.
This is the umpteenth special tax
The advertising tax will presumably hit the players of the advertising market the hardest - the clients and those selling advertising platforms, including electronic media, radio and television broadcasters). From this point of view this would be yet another sectoral tax. In the table below we have tried to list the taxes the current cabinet has imposed since 2010 in a bid to “renew" the tax regime. The list may not be complete, though.
Further reduction of energy tariffs - for businesses too!
About one of the main topics of the summit Orbán said they had discussed in detail how negatively high energy prices affect economic competitiveness. “Energy prices need to be reduced," Orbán said, adding that his cabinet will continue the policy of lowering energy tariffs both for households and businesses.
“By regulatory means we will reduce the price of energy used by businesses also," the PM said. He noted that a uniform liberalised market is not yet in existence and it will not be either in the short term in Europe, although this could lead to a real decrease in prices via actual competition. Such system may be brought to life in the medium term but until then, he stressed, there is a need for regulatory means.
Hungary is also about to make developments in the area of nuclear power. He said it would be important for the EU not to create a ranking between the different energy sources, but to ensure via neutral regulation the “equality" of nuclear power.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas