Hungary’s National Economy Ministry expects additional revenues from the introduction of online cash registers already by the end of the year and it is not concerned about shrinking legal cigarette sales either, the ministry’s latest responses to Portfolio.hu showed. It is worth taking a look at the ministry’s current targets with its earlier promises. The lesson we could learn from this comparison is the importance of creating and publishing impact studies.
Symbolic measures
One of the fundamental features of a good fiscal regime is that impact studies are put behind specific economic policy measures to see what effect these steps will have on the budget. This means transparency for the economic agents, helping them prepare for the related risks. The Hungarian government’s measures planned for 2013 were in many cases symbolic, but none of them were accompanied by detailed and public impact studies. These steps included:
- the implementation of a new electronic toll collection (ETC) system, with an upwardly revised revenue target - the introduction of the financial transaction tax (FTT) as of 1 January - the online connection of cash registers to the tax authority (NAV) - the implementation of the utility infrastructure tax - the hike to the special levy on energy service providers - the revamping of the tobacco retail system (government-approved tobacco stores that drastically changed smoking habits).
Some of these measures met expectations on the revenue side, such as the ETC, while others caused great disappointment (think about the chaos over the FTT legislation). In other cases it got proven by now that the cabinet overplanned revenues (online cash registers) and in another area the targeted impact was achieved, but there is no solid base for comparison (cigarette consumption).
In this article we give you an idea on how the cabinet assesses the palpable impacts and implications of the latter two measures, the obligatory use of online cash registers for businesses and the planned change to smoking habits.
Overly upbeat
We have just learned from tax authority NAV that as of Wednesday (20 Nov) a total of 220 cash registers have been connected online to the National Tax and Customs Authority. At first glimpse, this is a scarily small number, especially in light of the fact that the cabinet hoped to generate HUF 95 billion worth of funds for the budget from this measure. The Economy Ministry stressed upon our inquiry that this is merely a snapshot of the current situation and we should not draw far-reaching conclusions yet.
It has also underlined that the first batch of new online cash registers have already been received and their connection is being underway.
Asked whether the ministry - in view of the above - still expects to boost budget revenues in the remainder of the year, deputy state secretary Péter Banai, who is in charge of budget issues at the ministry, responded that in light of the sales figures they expect at least HUF 20 bn of additional revenues (which is a much more cautious estimate than the original HUF 95 bn and then the revised HUF 45-50 bn projections). He said the speed of the switchover depends on external players. Banai expressed hope that - in view of international cases - this measure will bring success, adding that the sales numbers already reflect the stricter control which is yet to follow.
Where a compass would have come in handy
The amendment of the rules on tobacco retailing and the hike to the sellers’ profits margins and the rate of the excise tax on tobacco products also had a spectacular impact. According to the NAV’s excise tax statistics, which was published the other day, showed that legal cigarette sales grew in annual terms in September for the first time in many months, although the cumulated figure still shows a huge yr/yr decline.
In this respect Banai noted that the decline in cigarette sales is in line with the change in smoking habits, which was the government’s intention in the first place. “The impact of the measures so far has been incorporated in the budget prognoses both for this year and next. Excise tax revenues from tobacco products are estimated some HUF 12 bn lower for next year than for 2013," he added. This indicates that the ministry is not overly worried about the black economy gaining ground over the legal cigarette market.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas