Economy
EU unyielding on phasing out energy price regulation, Hungary no exception
The consultations are aimed at persuading each EU Member State to gradually phase out regulated energy prices, the Commission source, who spoke on condition of anonymity, Hungarian state-owned newswire MTI reported today. Energy Commissioner Günther Oettinger informed every Member State where electricity or natural gas prices are set centrally about this intention of Brussels last year.
He notified them that the EC is recommending this practice to be phased out gradually, saying regulated prices “do not carry the appropriate message" to have the desired developments executed.
The Commission argues in favour of enforcing free market prices that in the long term someone - if not the consumers than the taxpayers - will have to pay the price for this practice. It also said competition between service providers would in the end stabilise prices at an adequate level therefore the consumers would be also better off in the long run.
Instead of regulated prices Brussels would prefer targeted subsidisation of consumers at free market prices.Oettinger warned already in November 2012 that 18 Member States still regulated their end-user prices, particularly electricity. “The state introduces rules and sets prices itself. This is not our understanding of what a single European market should be about," he said.
The EC wanted to see regulated prices being phased out over the next few years, particularly those which are below market prices, he added.
An EU Directive says: “Regulated prices distort the markets as they do not reflect actual demand and limit effective competition. Furthermore, they can prevent new arrivals from entering the market. Therefore, and as confirmed by the jurisprudence of the Court of Justice, regulated prices may be adopted only when they serve the general economic interest and are proportionate, clearly defined, transparent, non-discriminatory and verifiable."
In his letter written last year Oettinger requested information on the particular situation of the countries where regulated energy prices are in effect in a bid to promote the liberalisation of the internal energy market. The data received are assessed one by one and Commission experts will start bilateral talks with the affected countries to enable a gradual phasing out of regulated prices while making sure the interests of consumers in need of protection are not hurt.
BruxInfo reported earlier this week that Klaus-Dieter Borchardt, Director of the Internal Energy Market at DG Energy, told a conference that the EC will initiate infringement proceedings too if necessary and is willing to take cases to the European Court of Justice to have regulated prices gradually phased out.
The portal, however, deducted from the remarks that the EC will leave time for discussion and not rush into infringement proceedings. Such procedures can be lengthy and take as long as one or two years before ending with an ECJ ruling.
Therefore it looks more than likely that the EC will take no legal step against Hungary on this issue before the 6 April parliamentary election and for some time even after that, BruxInfo opined.
There are currently 17 Member States where electricity and/or gas prices are regulated.
Electricity prices are regulated in Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, France, Hungary, Latvia, Malta, Poland, Slovakia and Spain. There are price regulations in place also in Denmark, Estonia, Greece, Lithuania, Portugal and Romania but these countries have already pledged to phase out this practice.
Natural gas prices are regulated in Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Denmark, Estonia, France, Hungary, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Slovakia and Spain, whereas Romania and Portugal have undertaken to phase out regulated gas prices. The EC considers the existence of permanently regulated prices in countries where the market is too small to have meaningful competition, such as Malta or Cyprus.
On 15 November 2012, the European Commission presented a Communication assessing the state of play of the internal energy market, to be completed by 2014.
The Communication encourages Member States to step up efforts, highlighting the benefits of a truly integrated European market for citizens and business. The document also identifies the need for further action in a number of areas including consumer protection, enforcing the existing rules and investing in the modernisation of energy infrastructure.
“Member States should seek to cease regulating electricity and gas prices for all consumers, including households and SMEs, taking into account universal service obligation and effective protection of vulnerable customers. Suppliers should clearly spell out the different cost elements in the final cost for their customers, to encourage well-informed decision-making.
“The Commission will continue to insist on phase-out timetables for regulated prices being part of Member States' structural reforms. The Commission will continue to promote market-based price formation in retail markets, including through infringement cases against those Member States maintaining price regulation that is not meeting the conditions laid down by EU law," the EC said in the Communication.
He notified them that the EC is recommending this practice to be phased out gradually, saying regulated prices “do not carry the appropriate message" to have the desired developments executed.
The Commission argues in favour of enforcing free market prices that in the long term someone - if not the consumers than the taxpayers - will have to pay the price for this practice. It also said competition between service providers would in the end stabilise prices at an adequate level therefore the consumers would be also better off in the long run.
Instead of regulated prices Brussels would prefer targeted subsidisation of consumers at free market prices.Oettinger warned already in November 2012 that 18 Member States still regulated their end-user prices, particularly electricity. “The state introduces rules and sets prices itself. This is not our understanding of what a single European market should be about," he said.
The EC wanted to see regulated prices being phased out over the next few years, particularly those which are below market prices, he added.
An EU Directive says: “Regulated prices distort the markets as they do not reflect actual demand and limit effective competition. Furthermore, they can prevent new arrivals from entering the market. Therefore, and as confirmed by the jurisprudence of the Court of Justice, regulated prices may be adopted only when they serve the general economic interest and are proportionate, clearly defined, transparent, non-discriminatory and verifiable."
In his letter written last year Oettinger requested information on the particular situation of the countries where regulated energy prices are in effect in a bid to promote the liberalisation of the internal energy market. The data received are assessed one by one and Commission experts will start bilateral talks with the affected countries to enable a gradual phasing out of regulated prices while making sure the interests of consumers in need of protection are not hurt.
BruxInfo reported earlier this week that Klaus-Dieter Borchardt, Director of the Internal Energy Market at DG Energy, told a conference that the EC will initiate infringement proceedings too if necessary and is willing to take cases to the European Court of Justice to have regulated prices gradually phased out.
The portal, however, deducted from the remarks that the EC will leave time for discussion and not rush into infringement proceedings. Such procedures can be lengthy and take as long as one or two years before ending with an ECJ ruling.
Therefore it looks more than likely that the EC will take no legal step against Hungary on this issue before the 6 April parliamentary election and for some time even after that, BruxInfo opined.
There are currently 17 Member States where electricity and/or gas prices are regulated.
Electricity prices are regulated in Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, France, Hungary, Latvia, Malta, Poland, Slovakia and Spain. There are price regulations in place also in Denmark, Estonia, Greece, Lithuania, Portugal and Romania but these countries have already pledged to phase out this practice.
Natural gas prices are regulated in Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Denmark, Estonia, France, Hungary, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Slovakia and Spain, whereas Romania and Portugal have undertaken to phase out regulated gas prices. The EC considers the existence of permanently regulated prices in countries where the market is too small to have meaningful competition, such as Malta or Cyprus.
On 15 November 2012, the European Commission presented a Communication assessing the state of play of the internal energy market, to be completed by 2014.
The Communication encourages Member States to step up efforts, highlighting the benefits of a truly integrated European market for citizens and business. The document also identifies the need for further action in a number of areas including consumer protection, enforcing the existing rules and investing in the modernisation of energy infrastructure.
“Member States should seek to cease regulating electricity and gas prices for all consumers, including households and SMEs, taking into account universal service obligation and effective protection of vulnerable customers. Suppliers should clearly spell out the different cost elements in the final cost for their customers, to encourage well-informed decision-making.
“The Commission will continue to insist on phase-out timetables for regulated prices being part of Member States' structural reforms. The Commission will continue to promote market-based price formation in retail markets, including through infringement cases against those Member States maintaining price regulation that is not meeting the conditions laid down by EU law," the EC said in the Communication.









