Hungary’s budget shortfall could exceed 3% of gross domestic product this year and general government debt will not decline, according to the latest projection by the Fiscal Responsibility Institute Budapest (FRIB or KFIB) revealed on Tuesday. At the same time, the economy could still perform better, primarily thanks to fiscal and monetary measures. The institute has identified several risks to the budget, including the weak forint, lower budget revenue from the excise tax on tobacco products, lower-than-targeted VAT revenues and a worse GDP path.
Good growth in 2014 will be temporary
According to the FRIB’s latest technical assumption, Hungary’s long-term growth rate is extremely weak, between 0.5% and 1.0%. Whereas GDP could increase by up to 2% this year, it will go up at this rate only if the central bank (NBH) allocates is entire Funding for Growth Scheme (FGS) and at this juncture this appears to be having hiccups.
What is included?
Balázs Romhányi, managing director of the FRIB told a press conference today that since their last technical assumption (Nov13) two sets of monthly budget figures have been released, the 2014 budget bill was approved and in this technical assumption the impact of the second round of utility tariff cuts (1 Nov) have already been taken into consideration. He noted that the party’s election promises will be priced in accordingly.
The FRIB projects inflation to retreat further this year to 1.6% (from 1.7% in 2013). As a result, there could be a real pension hike of 0.8%, Romhányi added.
Consumption is expected to rise temporarily, just like investments, primarily owing to fiscal measures.
What about the deficit?
Romhányi underlined that in their estimate, Hungary’s budget shortfall could exceed 3% of GDP this year and reach even 3.5%, provided the HUF 100 bn Country Protection Fund remains unspent. The gap could remain over 3% in the following years too, he added.
Hungary’s debt-to-GDP ratio is also expected to rise, already this year and in the next ones too. Lower growth will not solve this problem in 2015-16, Romhányi said.
Here are the risks!
1. Risks related to growth
Romhányi said the first and most important risk is that there is a huge difference between the officially targeted nominal GDP and their own estimate. The FRIB estimates this year’s nominal GDP to be more than HUF 630 bn lower than what the cabinet pencilled in, mainly due to the considerably lower CPI. He added that the government-sponsored reduction of energy prices for households will continue.
Another key difference in views is that while the cabinet projects this year’s growth to be sustainable, the FRIB believes it will be only temporary and GDP could rise by 2% only if the second leg of the FGS is used entirely.
The institute also believes VAT revenues are overplanned by about HUF 170 bn.
Romhányi noted, however, that pension spending is shaping up especially well, and thanks to reclassifications the trend could have caused a positive surprise even for the government. Whereas the cabinet pencilled in HUF 3,467 bn pension spending for this year, the FRIB sees “only" HUF 3,416 bn to be spent on pensions.
A possible drop in exports could also be a risk, but its impact on the budget is limited (HUF 30 bn).
Another risk related to growth is that the central bank fails to allot the entire FGS II, although it may respond to that scenario by altering the rules, Romhányi said.
2. Measures that could mess things up
The FRIB does not expect any additional revenues from the launch of online cash registers, but if there are revenues it is an upside risk, Romhányi noted.
There is a HUF 50 bn risk run by the Klebelsberg School Manager (KLIK), he said, referring to an audit recently published by news portal index.hu.
Index referred to a review by ministerial commissioner Balázs Szabó, and said that KLIK was being mismanaged and its deficit could total 50 billion forints by the end of 2014. The opposition Socialist Party and E-PM said in a statement that KLIK is an “expensive, unnecessary and mismanaged" organisation, and added that they would scrap it altogether if they were to win power in the upcoming election. The Human Resources Ministry issued a statement in which they said the ministerial review contributed to KLIK’s efficient operations and that the minister’s trust in the leadership of the organisation was unbroken.
The FRIB also believes the HUF 120 bn revenue planned to be received from the mobile frequency licence tender could also be exaggerated.
The revenue target from online gambling tax represents an upside risk relative to the baseline scenario, the institute said.
Revenues from excise tax on tobacco products, however, are seen undershooting the target. Cigarette prices rose significantly in the second half of the year and if they remain that way the legal market will shrink further, along with budget revenues, the FRIB forecasts. Romhányi also pointed out that revenues from fine-cut tobacco will not make up for this.
3. Other risks
The European Commission is currently looking into road construction contracts, on suspicion that there were irregularities and discriminatory practices in some tenders. The possible sanctions represent another risk factor.
Another key risk is municipality debt which was reduced by the state at the end of 2013, but the local governments’ liabilities remain elevated.
A third systemic risk is seen at municipalities. In this respect Romhányi underlined that we are in an election year and the government had assumed the municipalities’ debts therefore they have no liquidity barrier. The FRIB accepted the government’s estimate for HUF 30 bn municipal debt in its calculations.
4. And the weak forint?
The FRIB’s economists have also conducted sensibility studies on the forint exchange rate and bond yields. For their base case scenario used EURHUF 297.50. If the current exchange rate level (5% or HUF 15 weaker) remains persistently throughout the year, interest expenses will rise by HUF 15 billion, the FRIB projects.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas