Hungary’s budget balance showed a nearly HUF 150 billion smaller deficit in 2013 than what the government had targeted. In retrospect we could say the tax hikes last year were uncalled for, but then why did the cabinet played it so extremely safe?
Nice figure
The 2013 budget balance exceeded all expectations. The government originally aimed for a 2.7% of GDP gap and even the latest estimates by the European Commission and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) were for a 2.4% shortfall.
According to preliminary figures, Hungary’s government undershot its (original) deficit goal by 0.5% of GDP last year. The Central Statistical Office (KSH) reported on Monday that gross domestic product in 2013 totalled HUF 29,114 billion, which implies that in nominal terms the budget shortfall was HUF 145 bn smaller than expected.
This may be interpreted also in a way that the cabinet tightened the belt HUF 145 bn more than it would have been necessary. If you recall what happened in 2013 you might ponder in view of this undershoot why most of the amendments to the budget were necessary. In May, Economy Minister Mihály Varga announced a HUF 92 bn spending freeze and he tabled a HUF 130-150 bn tax hike package in June. In scope of the latter, the telephone tax was hiked, the cabinet slapped a 6% health contribution on interest income, the rate of the financial transaction tax (FTT) was raised and banks were obliged to pay a one-off HUF 75 bn compensation to make up for the missed FTT revenue target.
Because of a black hole
Looking back it seems the cabinet did not want to leave anything to chance in its efforts to have the EU’s Excessive Deficit Procedure (EDP) against Hungary abrogated. This zeal reveals a lot about the transparency of budget planning. Also, the government wanted to make sure the deficit target is attained because the municipality system is a “black hole" for it one year after another. During the year the cabinet has no information on local government balances, these numbers come to light only a few months after the fiscal year is over.
Note that municipalities have been making some jaws to drop over the recent period. The chart below attests that, comparing the actual municipal sector balance with the government’s projection for that made in the autumn of the given fiscal year (both data series are from the Hungarian stats office’s EDP Report sent to Eurostat). In each of the past three years the local government’s caused highly pleasant surprises and thus shored up the general government balance. In the current parliamentary cycle the only year when municipalities were the reason for a higher budget gap was 2010. This is another key reason why the cabinet decided to tighten the reign on municipal finances.
The HUF 150 bn undershoot of the deficit target in 2013 some HUF 60 bn were attributable to a larger-than-expected surplus of municipalities. The also nearly HUF 150 bn outperformance in 2012 was practically the result of a HUF 200 bn surprise delivered by the local government system.
Summary
In view of the latest budget data we can state that by its intra-year measures the cabinet is keeping fiscal developments in check. If we had to choose between two scenarios of (i) the deficit soars and exceeds the target or (ii) the deficit goal gets undershot, it is clear which one is preferred. A more accurate, comprehensive and all-encompassing budget planning would definitely help avoid adjustments that later prove to be unnecessary.
Of course, regardless of how scrupulous fiscal planning is when a sudden negative shock tips over all those nice numbers. In that case there is a need for adjustment measures that have a lasting balance improving effect for the years to come. So, in this sense it could easily be the case that exactly because of the tax hikes in 2013 we don’t have to worry about the 2014
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas