Hungary OTP-MKB merger can make Orbán's dream come true - Morgan Stanley

Portfolio
Hungary’s new-old government will still want to increase local ownership in the banking sector, analysts at Morgan Stanely said on Friday. In a research note on the Hungarian banking sector, they also said a hypothetical merger of OTP and MKB could add 7-11% to OTP’s pre-provision profit profit, but but would not contribute positively to net income without a return to pre-crisis risk costs and a significant reduction in the bank levy.
The views of Morgan Stanley analysts can be summed up as follows:

The new Hungarian government will continue promoting higher domestic ownership of the banking sector. At the same time, they think this may not be as radical as some expect and may only be mildly earnings accretive for OTP, if it participates.

The Balance of Payments structure indicates that the forint would clearly benefit from a slowdown in the pace of banking outflows. However, a shift from foreign to domestic ownership of the Hungarian banks is unlikely on its own to have a significant effect on either the pace of deleveraging or foreign indebtedness.

The analysts believe PM Orbán’s goal to have at least 50% of the banking sector in Hungarian hands is not far from being achieved. “[...] one of PM Orbán’s stated aims is to bring domestic ownership of the Hungarian banks closer to 50%. Counting OTP as Hungarian, our analysis suggests domestic ownership is already around 40% and, withBayernLB obliged to sell MKB by 2015 (6%), this could be largely achieved without major structural changes."

However, near-term hurdles are significant The analysts see a number of “significant potential issues for both sellers and buyers of Hungarian banking assets, which may reduce the scope and pace of sector consolidation." Among these is treatment of the bank levy and the pending government fix on FX mortgages as well as the funding of these legacy FX portfolios.

“With synergies, a hypothetical OTP/MKB merger could add 7-11% to OTP’s pre-provision profit." Recent unconfirmed press reports suggest OTP and MKB are in advanced talks. MKB is loss-making (before the levy and FTT) mainly due to high LLPs. “Assuming typical cost and revenue synergies, we estimate that MKB could potentially add 7-11% to OTP’s PPP by 2016e, but would not contribute positively to net income without a return to pre-crisis risk costs and a significant reduction in the bank levy."

' title='
Implications of Increased domestic bank ownership

As expected, centre-right Fidesz won the April 6 elections by a landslide. The official results will be out on April 12, but Fidesz looks to have received 44.5% of the vote, leading the opposition Unity centre-left coalition (26%) by a large margin.

“Regardless of whether Fidesz achieves a qualified (two-third) majority or not, one thing is clear: PM Viktor Orbán won a resounding victory and will feel that the policies he pursued over the last four years have worked," commented Pasquale Diana, analyst at Morgan Stanley in London.

He looked in some detail at what we can expect in the next four years in and concluded that he sees
  • “odds in favour of a constructive solution on the issue of FX mortgages
  • some modest chances of fiscal loosening, but with a strong desire to keep the deficit sub-3% of GDP prevailing to avoid further EC scrutiny
  • Fidesz will continue to put pressure on regulated energy prices, and seek a larger role for the state to play in the energy sector, which could hamper investment
  • no case for Fidesz to indicate a preference for a weaker HUF.


Diana reminded that Fidesz’s philosophy seems to be that domestic banks would have the interests of the economy at heart, more so than foreign banks.

“Clearly foreign banks have been perceived as a target during the Fidesz administration, and the challenging environment they found themselves in is the key reason why deleveraging has hit Hungary more than other countries in Emerging Europe," he said.

' title='
It looks as though deleveraging in Hungary slowed down in 2013, but remains a significant macro headwind, the analyst noted, highlighting that BoP data show that banks repaid ‘only’ EUR 2.8 bn of debt-related funding, compared to EUR 4-5 bn in the preceding four years since 2009.

“A scenario in which domestic ownership of the banking system increases at the expense of foreign ownership as a result of exit of foreign players or M&A transactions has in and of itself no immediate obvious macro implications without knowing all the details," Diana said.

Morgan Stanley’s equity analysts argue that it is difficult to imagine a local bank being able to simply assume all of the FX funding in the market. “It is more likely that the seller (say, a Western European bank) would provide funding for FX assets for a temporary period to the local bank who is buying their subsidiary. If that were the case, an interbank (parent-subsidiary) loan would become a cross-border loan between two banks (one foreign, one Hungarian). In this scenario, rollover risk has not been reduced, Diana said.

“In a different scenario, the local bank would seek to translate its FX assets (loans) into local currency," he added. (MS analysts avoided the obvious issue of whether this is even feasible for a single bank to do, in the absence of a more general ruling on redenomination of FX loans into HUF.)

“In the above theoretical case, the local bank (buyer) would also try to swap FX funding for HUF funding, to avoid an FX mismatch. In so doing, it may find itself having to go into the market to seek FX to close out its foreign currency swap lines. Depending on the size of the transaction, this could have a big impact on the forint and the NBH may want to provide the FX out of its reserve stock. It is worth noting that reserve adequacy ratio is much higher now than in the past, when the above would have been much harder to contemplate. Recall also that the total stock of FX mortgages is around EUR 12 bn, compared to FX reserves of EUR 34 bn," Diana added.

' title='
Gov’t agenda takes care of itself

One of PM Orbán’s stated aims is to bring domestic ownership of the Hungarian banks closer to 50%. Counting OTP as Hungarian, Morgan Stanley’s analysis suggests “domestic ownership is already around 40% and, with BayernLB obliged by the EC to sell MKB by 2015 (6%), cc. 50% ownership could be largely achieved without major structural changes or, indeed, government intervention, as some investors fear," Daniel Cowan at MS said.

“With foreign banks unlikely to be increasing their presence in Hungary, in our view, OTP and perhaps only two or three other domestic banks have sufficient scale to afford substantial acquisitions," he added.

' title='
OTP has said it wants to play a role in any consolidation, although the extent of its participation is unclear at this time, the analyst noted. Beyond this, we should not expect significant changes in market structure in the near term, he added.

“We think expectations, fuelled by recent comments from the central bank governor, that foreign banks will soon sell up, may prove premature as we see substantial hurdles to broader sector consolidation."

Whereas all key foreign-owned banks stated they are not considering exiting Hungary, Cowan thinks that “disposals are only a matter of time, but will require significantly better exit valuations than those we think are currently available, if only to avoid substantial capital losses. For this to happen, profitability must improve and/or the number of potential buyers must rise."

' title='
Cowan also said the integration of the savings cooperatives creates 6th-largest bank by assets but it is unclear how effectively the new entity will compete.

Orbán said in mid-October 2010 that the market share of the savings cooperatives should double or triple over the next decade (from 6% of system assets currently).

By consolidating the savings banks, the government has effectively created the system’s sixth-largest lender by assets. Under July 2013 legislation, the government took control of the country’s savings cooperatives with the aim of recapitalisation and closer integration. Ownership was consolidated under Takarékbank, the cooperatives’ umbrella bank, owned 35% by the Hungarian Development Bank (MFB) and 19% by the Post Office (Magyar Posta).

“The new Takarékbank would appear to have considerable potential with a large branch network, strong retail deposit base and significant market position in SME lending. There does not currently appear to be any data on the new combination of Takarékbank and the cooperatives," Cowan said.

“It is not clear that the individual, often local, cooperative banks can be integrated sufficiently to provide genuine cost and distribution efficiency gains. We think it is likely to take considerable time before the new entity can compete effectively with private-sector commercial lenders," he added.

' title='
 

More in Economy

benzin_3
February 27, 2026 13:45

Could the price of petrol really leap to HUF 1,000 a litre in Hungary?

The situation is more complex than it may seem at first glance

adó-munkaerőpiac-foglalkoztatás-szocho-adókedvezmény
February 27, 2026 09:46

The labour market situation is deteriorating in Hungary

Employment hits five-year low

D_MTI20260210007
February 27, 2026 09:18

Hungary's Orbán plans new steps with Fico to bring back Druzhba flow

Prime Minister speaks in regular interview

szijjártó péter
February 26, 2026 16:56

Ukraine summons Hungary's chargé d'affaires in Kyiv - MoFA

Conflict remains heated

Mol Dunai Finomító Dufi kőolajfinomító benzin naplemente
February 26, 2026 16:42

Hungary's Mol threatens Janaf, sets Friday deadline

The oil company may turn to the European Commission

LATEST NEWS
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts, spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas

Detailed search