The Hungarian government will seriously consider an individual proposal submitted by Fidesz MP László L. Simon on the implementation of a new advertising tax on media companies. Revenues collected from the levy will be fully spent on children, more specifically on the development of schools and the modernisation and expansion of educational institutions, said János Lázár, state secretary at the helm of the Prime Minister’s Office, on Wednesday.
The cabinet regards the fair sharing of public burdens as an important principle. This means “everyone in Hungary is obliged to pay taxes proportionate to their burden-bearing capacity and economic results," state-owned newswire MTI cited Lázár as saying. That is why the banking, energy, trading, telecommunications sectors and the insurance segment pay more, he added.
Read more about the planned advertising tax at the links below:
The cabinet argues that multinational media companies with substantial advertising revenues will have to make a larger contribution to public burden sharing. “There was not enough political courage for this in the past 20 years, but now the government is taking seriously and considering László L. Simon’s proposal," said Lázár, adding at a press conference that the cabinet will discuss the summer schedule next Wednesday (11 June) along with the bill on the advertising tax.
He said there is “nothing odd" about the joining of forces and collective objection by otherwise rivalling media companies. That is why he takes it naturally that criticism was made by the government-friendly right-wing press too.
He said he does not believe, moreover he thinks it is exaggerated thought that the rate of the tax has anything to do with democracy and the freedom of the press. “Only because you have to pay taxes democracy will not cease to exist in Hungary," he said.
Lázár said that the plan of the advertising tax is sensitive and embarrassing from a political point of view “since there could be a special clash between politicians and the media, a conflict of interests and values" which is obviously awkward for the politicians, as a lot of times the success of their work depends on their media coverage. “What I see is that certain media are trying to exploit this and are trying to exert pressure on the government."
As regards the “special aspects" related to the advertising tax Lázár mentioned the response by RTL Hungary. The broadcaster claimed the cabinet wants to ruin the company via the disguise of this levy, which Lázár rejected in the name of the government.
“[...] RTL is threatening the country’; it is blackmailing the viewers and the politicians. It would be best if it practiced this at home, in Germany, rather than in Hungary." In his view RTL as a large international media company must bear a much bigger share of public burdens than before.
We have a pretty strong suspicion that it will not be these remarks that will help the cabinet attract working capital into Hungary. Seeing that multinational companies in Hungary are sent packing by government officials, the players of other sectors can start pondering when their operating field will be identified as an area worth involving into public burden sharing a little bit more via some special tax.As regards counter arguments that budget revenues generated by the advertising tax will be extremely moderate, Lázár said “there is indeed no fiscal pressure", while reminding that the bill was submitted not by the government, but an individual MP, which could be explained by the principal of public burden sharing and the reduction of the risk of “advertisement infection".
Even if you are not aware that the idea of an advertising tax was mulled at government level last year you cannot possibly take this argument of an “individual proposal" seriously. Although the cabinet’s mantra remains public burden sharing, it has yet to come up with an acceptable argument how a 40% tax rate on revenues can be labelled as a “proportionate" or a “fair" burden. In the legal, competitive economic sector there is hardly any market that could remain viable with such a burden. Hence, the message of the tax is “you cannot make so large profits because Hungarian tax policy will not put up with it." Again, this will hardly persuade foreign investors to bring production capacities to Hungary.Lázár said that as a member of parliament his opinion is that there are too many advertisements that are detrimental for children and that he finds it odd that “you cannot watch a movie in peace because it is sprayed with ad blocks." Therefore “creating boundaries" for advertising is not the devil’s work, he added.
Over the past decades, economic policy in Hungary has been spectacularly ignoring one of the key tax theory aspects: how changes to a tax will affect the behaviour of economic players, what reactions taxpayers will have in this new environment? The above statement is a splendid example of that ignorance. A media business will hardly be deterred from “excessive" advertising by a new and brutal levy since advertising is an integral part of its core activity. Overtaxing is not a synonym of placing between bounds. If the government really had a beef with ad blocks during films it would be able to cut the number or eliminate these ads altogether at the drop of a hat, simply via regulatory means.
Meanwhile, harsh taxation could in fact lead to even more ads on TV since a commercial television would want to make up for its shrinking revenues if it has a chance. Of course, this is not the only possible outcome, but we are yet to see an impact study showing us how this absurd burden could impact the advertising and media market. Tax avoidance is obviously the primary motivation when we’re talking about a 40% tax on revenues.As regards possibly changing the rate(s) of the tax Lázár said this is up to the parliamentary group of the Fidesz party. “Introduction may be postponed but it cannot be swept off the table for good," he said. He added that Antal Rogán, head of the caucus, had informed him that the Fidesz parliamentary group had already discussed this proposal and found it suitable for debate, but they would obviously come back to it.
Regarding the timing of the proposal and the claim by advertising organisations that they had not been consulted on the matter, the state secretary said it is the person submitting the proposal who should be asked about these issues.
It seems that when it comes to how sensible, well-founded and well-prepared the proposal is then it should be treated as an individual modification proposal, but still the caucus found it suitable for debate. So much for the consultation with professional bodies.Asked about Simon’s idea that community websites, such as Facebook, should also be taxed, Lázár said it would be a difficult legislative task, with which several EU member states are struggling. “We will also proceed in this case according to European Union treaties."
János Lázár, head of the Prime Minister’s Office before his hearing by the national security committee on 4 June 2014.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas