Economy
Hungary's Orbán takes no criticism, Századvég is a money laundry - Mellár
Orbán cannot put up with criticism
“I’ve spoken with Orbán on several occasions and it has become clear for me that he is not the kind of leader who can be given advice, with whom you can converse sensibly. When in the company of three or four people I dared declare that excuse me, but you’re wrong on this one, then the knife froze in mid-air, Miska* Varga was pulling my hand not to say such thing, at it was clear immediately that Orbán has absolutely no tolerance for criticism. By now no normal economic expert has stayed with the prime minister," Mellár told newspaper Népszabadság in an interview published today.
The economist was a founder and research director of Századvég Economic Research Zrt., which he left in 2011.
*Miska is a nickname for Mihály
A think tank which is a money laundry
The economist also talked abut the time he spent at think tank Századvég: “I left because I realised that the whole workshop was just a money laundry. Ministries were giving us orders to do this study and that and as research director I replied we cannot do it because it’s not our cup of tea. Don’t worry, they said, you have to do this, scrape something together, they’ll pay for it anyhow. And then I realised I was needed only to sign papers. The ministry transfers the money, I sign it, and the prime minister’s advisors get the big bucks while they do no meaningful work. They were receiving money from us because they could not pay them as advisors. Since then everyone I had brought to Századvég have left because they saw that no actual professional job had to be done there."
Századvég to file lawsuit against Mellár
Századvég Gazdaságkutató Zrt. responded to Mellár’s accusations on Friday afternoon, saying that “we are firmly rejecting these lies [Mellár said in the interview]" and is filing a lawsuit against Tamás Mellár.
Századvég has always been doing its job in compliance with current regulations and its contractual liabilities, it said.
The think tank noted that Mellár worked at Századvég between 12 May 2010 and 31 March 2011, and that he left on mutual consent at the initiative of the employer. In this period the research institute “had no assignment from any of the ministries."
The Internet tax is a mistake
Implementing a levy on online data traffic is a mistake, Mellár said. (Since then PM Orbán said that the Internet tax will not be implemented in its current form.)People already pay for using the Internet and this usage has tax content. “This is not alcohol or cigarette, you don’t have to protect the health of the consumers from the web," Mellár said.
“Thanks to the net we get information faster and this is huge help in research, education, the industry, agriculture and commerce. If you make this service more expensive you slow down economic efficiency and growth."
The HUF 20-30 bn the government hopes to collect this way is negligible compared to the size of the budget, Mellár added. People in the government’s circles are “losers" if they cannot realize that those economies are the most competitive ones where the infocommunications sector is the driving force.
No politician involved in corruption would step down in Hungary
Mellár said it is unimaginable in Hungary that a politician involved in corruption would step down. “The Hungarian society is weak to put pressure on politicians. Here it can happen that András Horváth, a [former] tax inspector, sheds light on a suspected thousand billion forint VAT fraud and [tax authority] NAV’s response is that everything is in order. In a normal country the entire management of the NAV would have been suspended and an international team of experts would have been brought in to investigate the validity of the report. Instead an investigation was opened against András Horváth," Mellár said.Loyal party voters are irrational
Mellár was also asked why Horváth’s case, the scandal around the national tobacco store licences and other suspected corruption cases all failed to reduce the voter base of the governing Fidesz party. He responded that “the behaviour of voters loyal to a party is irrational. [...] people affiliated with a party make emotional calls therefore if their leader ordered shots to be fired at them they would still vote for him. It is because there are no social discourses that would uncover the leaders’ faults, mistakes and crimes and there is no solidarity that would not let us tolerate the crushing of the weak."
He mentioned that Hungarians did not raise their voice when 88 billion forints were taken away from universities between 2011 and 2013.
“They had taken it from where they should have given to for our future. The people did not care. They said it’s not their business. My relatives also tell me when I’m fighting because of these: Why do you care? Don’t pay attention, shut up, why does it bother you?"
“I’ve spoken with Orbán on several occasions and it has become clear for me that he is not the kind of leader who can be given advice, with whom you can converse sensibly. When in the company of three or four people I dared declare that excuse me, but you’re wrong on this one, then the knife froze in mid-air, Miska* Varga was pulling my hand not to say such thing, at it was clear immediately that Orbán has absolutely no tolerance for criticism. By now no normal economic expert has stayed with the prime minister," Mellár told newspaper Népszabadság in an interview published today.
The economist was a founder and research director of Századvég Economic Research Zrt., which he left in 2011.
*Miska is a nickname for Mihály
A think tank which is a money laundry
The economist also talked abut the time he spent at think tank Századvég: “I left because I realised that the whole workshop was just a money laundry. Ministries were giving us orders to do this study and that and as research director I replied we cannot do it because it’s not our cup of tea. Don’t worry, they said, you have to do this, scrape something together, they’ll pay for it anyhow. And then I realised I was needed only to sign papers. The ministry transfers the money, I sign it, and the prime minister’s advisors get the big bucks while they do no meaningful work. They were receiving money from us because they could not pay them as advisors. Since then everyone I had brought to Századvég have left because they saw that no actual professional job had to be done there."
Századvég to file lawsuit against Mellár
Századvég Gazdaságkutató Zrt. responded to Mellár’s accusations on Friday afternoon, saying that “we are firmly rejecting these lies [Mellár said in the interview]" and is filing a lawsuit against Tamás Mellár.
Századvég has always been doing its job in compliance with current regulations and its contractual liabilities, it said.
The think tank noted that Mellár worked at Századvég between 12 May 2010 and 31 March 2011, and that he left on mutual consent at the initiative of the employer. In this period the research institute “had no assignment from any of the ministries."
The Internet tax is a mistake
Implementing a levy on online data traffic is a mistake, Mellár said. (Since then PM Orbán said that the Internet tax will not be implemented in its current form.)People already pay for using the Internet and this usage has tax content. “This is not alcohol or cigarette, you don’t have to protect the health of the consumers from the web," Mellár said.
“Thanks to the net we get information faster and this is huge help in research, education, the industry, agriculture and commerce. If you make this service more expensive you slow down economic efficiency and growth."
The HUF 20-30 bn the government hopes to collect this way is negligible compared to the size of the budget, Mellár added. People in the government’s circles are “losers" if they cannot realize that those economies are the most competitive ones where the infocommunications sector is the driving force.
No politician involved in corruption would step down in Hungary
Mellár said it is unimaginable in Hungary that a politician involved in corruption would step down. “The Hungarian society is weak to put pressure on politicians. Here it can happen that András Horváth, a [former] tax inspector, sheds light on a suspected thousand billion forint VAT fraud and [tax authority] NAV’s response is that everything is in order. In a normal country the entire management of the NAV would have been suspended and an international team of experts would have been brought in to investigate the validity of the report. Instead an investigation was opened against András Horváth," Mellár said.Loyal party voters are irrational
Mellár was also asked why Horváth’s case, the scandal around the national tobacco store licences and other suspected corruption cases all failed to reduce the voter base of the governing Fidesz party. He responded that “the behaviour of voters loyal to a party is irrational. [...] people affiliated with a party make emotional calls therefore if their leader ordered shots to be fired at them they would still vote for him. It is because there are no social discourses that would uncover the leaders’ faults, mistakes and crimes and there is no solidarity that would not let us tolerate the crushing of the weak."
He mentioned that Hungarians did not raise their voice when 88 billion forints were taken away from universities between 2011 and 2013.
“They had taken it from where they should have given to for our future. The people did not care. They said it’s not their business. My relatives also tell me when I’m fighting because of these: Why do you care? Don’t pay attention, shut up, why does it bother you?"









