As people question the reasonableness of the planned Internet tax, i.e. the extension of the telecom tax to online data traffic, it cannot be implemented in its current form, said Hungary’s Prime Minister Viktor Orbán. However, from his regular interview with public radio MR1 on Friday it was not clear whether the cabinet will give up its plan to impose this levy for good.
Economy Minister Mihály Varga announced on 21 October that the telecom tax would be extended to online data and Internet service providers would pay HUF 150 per gigabyte. The tax was first estimated to generate HUF 20 bn revenues for the state, but the draft budget submitted to Parliament on Thursday showed a HUF 25 bn target, still a negligible figure considering the uproar it triggered. After strong protest by the sector players and professional bodies a cap was proposed, but that did not prevent tens of thousands of people to flock to the streets and protest against the world’s first Internet tax - twice within a few days.
There were three key questions about the new levy. Why exactly does the cabinet want to impose this tax? What is the HUF 25 bn revenue target based on? Why did the government fail to consult with industry players?
PM Orbán has practically backed out of introducing the Internet tax, or more precisely he does not find it possible to implement it in its current form. What we should keep an eye on from now on is how the package of tax proposals will be modified. MPs were to vote on these, including the online data traffic tax on 18 November. We will need to see if the Internet tax is removed from the new package or not. Then the cabinet will be able to refer to the results of the ‘national consultation’ if the plan of the tax is raised again. However, we should not expect that before the first quarter of next year.About energy issues - 07:57
“We are okay," Orbán described Hungary’s gas situation, adding that apparently Ukraine has struck a deal with Russia on gas transmission issues.
“Replenishing our gas storage units is progressing well," he said. “We have enough gas to give gas to Serbia in case of emergency; we will fulfil our previously undertaken supply agreements," he added.
About the current conflicts - 07:52
Orbán said Hungary is not annoying anying, it merely “represents its own interests".
He suggested no hasty action, rather calm with respect to the current conflicts.
“There is a pressure [on Hungary] from abroad because of the settlement [of unfair charges] at the banks," Orbán said.
“It is also expected that as soon as a case is revealed the cabinet investigates it. It has turned out now that there is an investigation in progress on VAT fraud, and they are clarifying the role of foreign companies, i.e. on which end of the stick they are."
“Hungary must make it evident that it does not tolerate corruption," he stressed.
The undertakings - 07:50
Orbán reminded that his government had undertaken to have broadband Internet all over the country by 2018.
“We need this for the sake of a modern Hungary," he added.
“We had an agreement about this with the service providers and this is what gets jeopardised by the extension of the telecom tax," he has acknowledged.
“The most important is the future. We need to reach this goal and not just put it on paper somewhere," Orbán responded to a question whether the cabinet wants to enshrine this objective in the fundamental law.
What would the tax do? - 07:45
The development of the telecommunications market was not hampered by the telecom tax, Orbán argued in favour of the extension of this levy.
“The problem is that it does not matter what we say about the introduction of this tax," he added.
“We can call it this or that, but we ended up in a situation where imagination raising fears has developed in relation to this tax. The debate about the tax has gone askew," he added.
“People question the reasonableness of this tax. Under these circumstances you cannot implement such a tax," he said. “Consequently the tax bill needs to be modified," he added.
“The tax simply cannot be implemented for we govern together with the people," Orbán explained.
“We are not communists therefore the tax cannot be implemented in its current form," he said, referring to the cabinet’s open ears to the people’s opinion.
Asked whether the planned Internet tax will now be revoked, Orbán responded that the planned tax legislation needs to be totally withdrawn and consultations must be conducted in January.
These consultations will need to be focused on Internet regulations and what to do with the financial aspects of the Internet.
“We need to find an answer to the question where the giant extra profit made on the Internet goes and if we could keep some of it in Hungary and include it in the budget," Orbán said. He has failed to mention that Internet services alone did not generate profit over the past few years, in fact, the Internet service providers have been in the red.
The consultation should be concluded by the end of the first quarter or the first half of 2015, Orbán added.
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán speaks in the studio of public radio MR1 during one of his regular interviews on 31 October 2014.
Why insisting on the Internet tax if the budget is stable? - 07:43
Nobody talked about an Internet tax, Orbán said.
When confronted by the reporter that a levy on online data traffic is rightfully dubbed Internet tax, Orbán asked: “But why?"
“We proposed an amendment of tax technical nature," he said, adding that, in his view, the service providers will not be able to pass this levy on to customers.
He has acknowledged, though, that people have a different interpretation of this amendment of tax technical nature.
Is the budget stable then? - 07:42
We are in a beehive-like state in politics, Orbán said regarding the disputes about the budget.
Overall, the Hungarian economy is in order, he said, adding that he cannot declare the same thing about public finances.
He reminded that the country’s debt-to-GDP ratio stood at 77% at the end of 2013 and public debt will rise as long as the budget balance is not zero.
The problem is that we spend more than how much we earn, he said about the budget deficit.
One of the main objectives is to reduce debt also in absolute terms, both in USD and EUR terms, he added.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas