Hungary’s Prime Minister’s Office has sent around a proposal to ministries for their opinion on draft legislation we can simply call a new tobacco shop law. Officially it is a draft about the integration of tobacco product retailing and it would wedge in a new intermediary trader between tobacco factories, the wholesalers and the national tobacco stores as of 1 May 2015, news portal 444.hu reported on Friday. The bill suggests that the supplier could generate profits of HUF 5-6 billion annually with negligible operating and liquidity risks. The new unit may be operated by the state but for various reasons it is more likely to give this job in a concession to a single company. This proposal comes hot on the heels of a bill submitted by a lawmaker of the ruling Fidesz party that would impose a special tax on revenues, which has already curbed the earnings of several multinational firms, to tobacco companies next year. The latter proposal can be regarded as the not so amicable response to Washington for the travel-ban-gate.
Ministries had until Thursday to share their views with the Prime Minister’s Office about the planned amendment.
As of 1 May 2015 a supplier of tobacco retailers would be set up, with warehouses in every county.
The national tobacco shops may order from anyone, but from next May this supplier will be their only option.
The rock solid status of this supplier would be ensured also from the other side of the supply chain, as tobacco producers and wholesalers would be able to sell their products only to this supplier.
This way the new supplying company will be an intermediary, for which the pricing system would mean an endless source of risk-free profit. It would use a profit margin of 3% maximum on the products it will resell to the tobacco shops.
Considering the HUF 400 bn annual tobacco sales in Hungary this translates into a maximum annual profit of HUF 12 bn. A logistics expert, however, told 444.hu that logistics costs and the concession fee could cost this supplier up to half of this sum.
The profit could be increased, though, because the supplier will need to pay for the goods for the tobacco producer only when the tobacco stores make payment. This way it will not need to be concerned about liquidity issues and it will also be able to make interest rate gains. On a HUF 400 bn tobacco market this would translate into HUF 4 bn financial income even if the interest is merely 1%.
The state itself could decide to set up a Zrt. to fill in this position, but 444.hu argues that due to the multitude of tasks and shortage of time it is more likely that a concession will be granted to a company.
This is underpinned by a detailed description in the bill how the state could give concession to whom for this job, although there are indeed rigorous conditions and suggest the cabinet already has a pretty clear idea who will be the winner.
According to the draft no public tender would need to be invited as the relevant minister has the right to hold a restricted tender only for companies invited.
The concession may be granted only to a company that has been in tobacco trading for at least 15 years, has never had public-law liabilities of over HUF 0.5 million and has not been fined for more than HUF 20 m since 2005.
The two large U.S. tobacco manufacturers, Philip Morris and BAT drop out right there, whereas the huge winner of the first version of the tobacco shop law, Continental Zrt., stands good chances of winning, not to mention its excellent relationship with János Lázár, minister at the helm of the Prime Minister’s Office, the author of this proposal.
Hungary retaliates for travel-ban-gate?
The U.S. Embassy in Budapest has provided written information to the Hungarian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade on the background of travel bans imposed on six Hungarian government officials. The ministry said this document still does not provide any evidence to the alleged corruption charges.
PM Orbán played down the “evidence" as a “flimsy piece of paper", saying it proved nothing. The document, which was sent to the ministry without an official heading of the U.S. Embassy, signature or seal, said the nationalization of tobacco retailing was a concern at talks between the Embassy and tax authority NAV.
The document said that there was a meeting in October 2013 with the Criminal Directorate of the Tax and Customs Office (NAV) where “specific concerns about agricultural VAT fraud and tobacco nationalization were raised. Concerns were dismissed by the NAV, whose representative offered no substantive response to questions."
As regards this issue, the Embassy said it “noted concerns from numerous sources that documented a non-transparent process of awarding tobacco sale tenders, with awards tending to skew in favor of people and companies with ties to Fidesz. Additionally, post was concerned that tobacco nationalization would cause a rise in smuggled black market cigarettes. An increase in tobacco smuggling would likely correspond with increase of other types of smuggling and result in increased organized crime activity."
A new bill was submitted to the Parliament on Thursday by a member of the ruling Fidesz party that would impose a new special tax on local tobacco companies. The "temporary" measure would be an extraordinary health care contribution payable by tobacco manufacturers and wholesalers. The state budget would collect additional billions of forints.
The new levy that can be regarded as a new special sectoral tax will be progressive and the base will be the revenues, as follows: 0.2% but no less than HUF 30 m up to HUF 30 bn; 2.5% on revenues between HUF 30 bn and HUF 60 bn and 4.5% on revenues over HUF 60 bn.
The law would enter into effect on 1 February 2015 and expire on 31 December.
Local news portal vs. hu learned from sources close to the government that the whole idea to impose a special tax on tobacco companies was a reaction to the visa ban Washington imposed on six Hungarian government officials, including the head of tax authority NAV and a few of her colleagues over their alleged involvement in corruption. This assumption could be underpinned by the fact that nearly half of the new levy would have to be paid by a single U.S. interest.
The portal learned the cabinet hopes to collect HUF 13.6 bn from this ‘health care contribution’ payable by tobacco producers, HUF 6.3 bn of which would be paid by Philip Morris alone.
Political analyst Gábor Török commented on his Facebook page that if this connection proves to be true (which he personally doubts it will) the cabinet should really think it through how risky this game of chicken is. “But it is especially life-threatening and senseless if you drive a Prius head on with a truck," he added. Török actually said “kispolski" (small polski), not Prius, referring to Polski Fiat or Fiat 126(literally in English the Polish Fiat), a compact car that was manufactured or assembled in Poland and which is not famed for its robustness and safety, especially as its engine was in the trunk and the front end was the cargo space.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas