Economy
Hungary's EcoMin Varga set to deliver vicious blow to local retailers
The content of the bill submitted to Parliament by minister Varga today match the information about new legislation leaked by local news portal hvg.hu ten days ago.
Clearing up some details
First of all the bill complements the law on commerce by clarifying the different categories of stores:
The bill bans the establishment or operation of discount stores, large supermarkets and hypermarkets in world heritage cites of residential metropolitan areas.
In practice this means that larger retail establishments will be banned in these areas, with the explicit goal to “prevent Hungarian values acknowledged by the whole world, to conserve the landscape and protect the environment," the bill explains.
It also stipulates that establishments currently exempted (i.e. those that operate in “prohibited areas") may operate there until 1 January 2018. If they do not close by then on their own, authorities will have them closed with immediate effect.
Dominant position, whether you like it or not
The bill also states that dominant position exists if the (consolidated) net revenue (of the previous year) of a business and affiliated companies from their joint sales of fast-moving consumer goods exceeds 100 billion forints. This “needs to be applied with regard to the existence of abuses of dominant positions after 1 January 2016."
Profit standards
The bill sets new rules for FMCG companies. It states that “that commercial business which: a) generates more than half of its net revenues from the sale of FMCGs
b) has net sales revenues of any two consecutive business years of at least HUF 50 million each;
c) has zero or negative balance sheet earnings in both years defined under section b)
may not conduct retail activity of FMCGs after the approval of the earnings report of the second business year as defined in section b)" ".
As to every rule there are exceptions here, as well.
the above rule is not applicable in the first four business years from the establishment of the commercial business.
This section of the law would enter into effect on 1 January 2018.Explanation for the profit rule
“In the entirely free competition the already strengthened, capital-strong chains have been expanding constantly and an increasing number of small stores have been closing down. In the meantime, unemployment is on the rise because in the discount stores and hypermarkets smaller labour input is needed for higher productivity, considering the lower quality of services," the proposal argues.
“A food retailer operated in a family business competes with discounts offering cheap products from all over Europe and hypermarkets transporting customers on [their own] shuttle buses," it continues.
In its statement of reasons, the bill openly admits its selective nature.
"If we want to offer protection to domestic small and medium-sized enterprises efficiently but in harmony with EU regulations, we need to create different rules for the different types of stores."
The government also argues that companies with significant sales are not significant employers. “An expansion in employment may be achieved via small and medium-sized enterprises; their survival and strengthening may bring a sustainable increase in employment," it explains.
It further argues in favour of the profit rules that “capital-strong retail chains can afford themselves to incur losses over several years in order to push prices lower, crippling Hungarian businesses."
“This can have unforeseeable consequences in the long term," it warned.
“It is unrealistic to operate a business that keeps generating losses. Persistently loss-making operating is indirectly an abuse of dominance since rivals will fall out and the business with massive capitalisation “buys the market"," the proposal explains.
Clearing up some details
First of all the bill complements the law on commerce by clarifying the different categories of stores:
- Hypermarket: an establishment engaged in retail activities or retail and wholesale activities on the same time and place on gross area of over 5,000 square metres; an establishment selling fast-moving consumer goods;
- large-scale supermarket: an establishment engaged in retail activities or retail and wholesale activities on the same time and place on gross area of 2,500-5,000 square metres; an establishment selling fast-moving consumer goods;
- supermarket: an establishment engaged in retail activities or retail and wholesale activities on the same time and place on gross area of 400-2,500 square metres; an establishment selling fast-moving consumer goods;
- discount store: an establishment engaged in retail activities or retail and wholesale activities on the same time and place on gross area of over 400 square metres; an establishment selling fast-moving consumer goods, which does not have counters offering fresh meat, meat products and dairy products.
The bill bans the establishment or operation of discount stores, large supermarkets and hypermarkets in world heritage cites of residential metropolitan areas.
In practice this means that larger retail establishments will be banned in these areas, with the explicit goal to “prevent Hungarian values acknowledged by the whole world, to conserve the landscape and protect the environment," the bill explains.
It also stipulates that establishments currently exempted (i.e. those that operate in “prohibited areas") may operate there until 1 January 2018. If they do not close by then on their own, authorities will have them closed with immediate effect.
Dominant position, whether you like it or not
The bill also states that dominant position exists if the (consolidated) net revenue (of the previous year) of a business and affiliated companies from their joint sales of fast-moving consumer goods exceeds 100 billion forints. This “needs to be applied with regard to the existence of abuses of dominant positions after 1 January 2016."
Profit standards
The bill sets new rules for FMCG companies. It states that “that commercial business which:
b) has net sales revenues of any two consecutive business years of at least HUF 50 million each;
c) has zero or negative balance sheet earnings in both years defined under section b)
may not conduct retail activity of FMCGs after the approval of the earnings report of the second business year as defined in section b)" ".
As to every rule there are exceptions here, as well.
the above rule is not applicable in the first four business years from the establishment of the commercial business.
This section of the law would enter into effect on 1 January 2018.Explanation for the profit rule
“In the entirely free competition the already strengthened, capital-strong chains have been expanding constantly and an increasing number of small stores have been closing down. In the meantime, unemployment is on the rise because in the discount stores and hypermarkets smaller labour input is needed for higher productivity, considering the lower quality of services," the proposal argues.
“A food retailer operated in a family business competes with discounts offering cheap products from all over Europe and hypermarkets transporting customers on [their own] shuttle buses," it continues.
In its statement of reasons, the bill openly admits its selective nature.
"If we want to offer protection to domestic small and medium-sized enterprises efficiently but in harmony with EU regulations, we need to create different rules for the different types of stores."
The government also argues that companies with significant sales are not significant employers. “An expansion in employment may be achieved via small and medium-sized enterprises; their survival and strengthening may bring a sustainable increase in employment," it explains.
It further argues in favour of the profit rules that “capital-strong retail chains can afford themselves to incur losses over several years in order to push prices lower, crippling Hungarian businesses."
“This can have unforeseeable consequences in the long term," it warned.
“It is unrealistic to operate a business that keeps generating losses. Persistently loss-making operating is indirectly an abuse of dominance since rivals will fall out and the business with massive capitalisation “buys the market"," the proposal explains.









