This could be behind policy U-turn of Hungarian gov't, cenbank
For the past year, the narrative in Hungary has been relatively simple, maybe even boring: a central bank that wanted to minimise rates to maximise growth, that was maximising profit to remit to the government over time, that wanted lower foreigner participation in HGBs and a flatter curve, a fiscal policy that was tight given monetary expansion and to ensure a ratings increase - not a whole lot else going on, the strategist reminded.
He added that that has, in the last month or so, shifted quite sharply.
First, we think there was a realisation within government that there was a need for a greater (populist) reaction to the political pressure Fidesz is under in the education and health care sectors as a result of previous wage freezes and a lack of other reforms dogging employees in particular.
More generally, Attard Montalto believes government (and the MNB) has come to the realisation that a more dramatic push is needed to secure growth targets (3.0-3.5% in the medium run) through higher credit growth to SMEs and higher export growth than is currently occurring.In this regard, he thinks “there was a realisation between government and the MNB that (broad, unorthodox) monetary policy could not simply do all the heavy lifting - as such, fiscal had to come to the party as well."
In tandem, or indeed facilitating this shift to use both main policy levers, the strategist thinks there was a realisation in government, finally, that despite a volume of protestations ratings agencies simply are not going to budget with upgrades.
“We have always been sceptical of the upgrade story for this year (or the supposed fact that Hungary is under-rated). The ratings agencies have had a lack of trust in medium-run potential growth being above 2.0% (vs the government’s hopes for 3.0-3.5%), have mistrusted the debt statistics and had doubts around the sustainability of tight fiscal policy," Attard Montalto said.
Indeed, he has often commented that tight fiscal was only being run to get an upgrade and after there would be a marked loosening.
We think the government has realised this dynamic along with recent ratings agencies comments about the risks caused by MNB unorthodoxy (policy which the government backs). As such, we think the government has abandoned the upgrade target, and this has facilitated a loosening of fiscal policy. The end goal is to boost growth and maintain popularity
, Attard Montalto added.Parallel to this, he noted, there are some U-turns on specific domestic policy issues around education and healthcare, as well as whipping up anti-refugee rhetoric and calling a referendum on that issue for the end of September or start October.
With two levers of policy now turning to ‘loose’, the curve can steepen, though herein comes some complexity with the MNB’s desires on curve level and shape.
At the same time, he thinks the focus is on a more blunt push on growth, so the MNB has shifted back from unorthodox to orthodox as the key driving force of policy.As regards the 2017 budget, Attard Montalto noted that this fiscal loosening raises the upside risks to growth next year of our 2.8% baseline forecast.
“The type of fiscal loosening being discussed, we think, could add 0.4pp onto growth for next year. We will make a decision on changing forecasts after next week’s GDP data prints."
“Medium-run consolidation, however, in the underlying primary and headline deficit looks somewhat aggressive, given we think potential growth will remain stuck around 2.0-2.5% in the long run, and so reversing course could be problematic - hence the discussions already occurring about further VAT cuts in 2018 and personal tax cuts that year, too."
As such, the strategist sees a much more gradual decline in debt ratios in the coming years, in line with the IMFs view.
“We are now back to the focus being on orthodox policy (rates); however, we think the foundations and broader framework of monetary policy have not really changed," he said.
The strategist noted that these changes have been communicated “somewhat opaquely" through investor meetings in London attended by Deputy Governor Márton Nagy.
His understanding is that monetary policy is still:
- in a low inflation environment,
- growth maximising,
- maximising the MNB profit remitted to the fiscus,
- wanting a weaker currency,
- targeting a low and flat yield curve,
- looking to target credit growth at a higher rate.
The strategist thinks FX policy has come a lot more to fore.
He noted that some parts of policy have reached a natural conclusion - for instance, the shrinkage of the balance sheet by the closure of the 2w depo window.
“Here the MNB is somewhat risk averse - it doesn’t want to massively increase its balance sheet, nor frighten the market, with interventions, yet it knows the struggles of a 5% current account surplus ‘low vulnerability’ country in shifting to a different FX level," Attard Montalto said.
[...] a soft 310 floor has existed in the backs on the MNB’s mind for some time but that greater management of front-end liquidity (FX implied, basis, BUBOR) will enable them to keep implied rates lower and, with it, implied real rates and so weaken the currency
, he said.
For the moment, Attard Montalto thinks it will remain the 3m depo rate as the epicentre of the complex postmodern policy world of the MNB. However, the possibility of caps on 3m depo access in future could mean that, whilst it remains the policy rate, the real policy tool does shift to BUBOR, he added.

“The MNB has achieved its key aims of getting banks to hold more debt than foreigner [...]. Foreign holdings levels have reduced to (peak) pre-crisis levels. The MNB seems now to want to get another step change lower in foreign ownership (and selling of HUF) to reset EURHUF up towards 320 odd levels."
The question is who will pick up this debt locally, he noted, adding that banks are already complaining they are overstuffed, and the prospect of other foreigners buying on a spike in yields is also unclear.“With cuts in the front end and the ability to support the banks through a slightly steeper curve, we think the MNB is happy here with the curve shape. Looser fiscal policy and the need for more issuance next year also seem to be weighing on the MNB’s mind as a reason to allow slightly higher yields to get this issuance to clear in the market."
So, the strategist thinks unorthodox measure can return if fine-turning is needed (more HIRS to boost lending later in the year, duration swaps to keep the curve in check). Similarly, 3m depo caps are still on the table, he believes, to get more money into the market.
We don’t read too much into perceived reduced dovishness from the MNB here, as we think they are trying to manage expectations down a little and then to ‘surprise’ people by cutting more to get a little extra currency weakness that way.
Attard Montalto stressed that, as ever, “the overriding forecast remains of slow, steady HUF weakness through MNB policy, and an MNB easing policy through whatever means possible as much as possible."The risk, of course, in the medium run is that this overly complex policy ‘blows up’ in the MNB’s face, he has warned.
“With high inflation not seen throughout the forecast horizon, that risk remains but is pushed way out. Bank liquidity shocks or a financial stability shock could also be hard to deal with in this framework. But, for now, there is space for complexity and ‘cleverness,’ for an MNB that wants to be providing direction and micromanaging ‘ahead’ of the market rather than following it."









