Economy
Hungary discloses OLAF report on Metro 4 fraud
“The report of the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) clearly proves the accountability of Hungary’s socialist governments and Budapest’s pre-2010 municipal leaders in the metro 4 corruption scandal", Csepreghy told a press conference on Friday.
“The country is expected to have to repay some 59 billion forints (EUR 190M) to the European Union’s account as a result of the largest case of corruption since Hungary joined the EU", he added.
More than 100 contracts were signed in the course of the implementation of this project, out of which 20 were considered as large works contracts.
OLAF’s investigation established the following serious management irregularities and errors and possible fraud and other offences which took place from the beginning of the project and which affected the whole project throughout its implementation:
OLAF said “a significant number of public procurement procedures were affected by irregularities, some at the stage of the tender publication, others during the tender evaluation procedure."
The total amount of contracts affected by different type of irregularities is over EUR 1.05 bn (HUF 282.82 bn), which is about 60% of the total project amount of EUR 1.75 bn or HUF 452.6 bn.
The total estimated financial impact of the irregularities is EUR 644.78 mn (HUF 166.94 bn).
OLAF has found that the estimated financial impact on the EU co-financed “KÖZOP Operative Program" is EUR 295.95 mn (HUF 76.65 bn).
The total financial impact on the Cohesion Fund (77% of the eligible amount, which corresponds to 85% of the total subvention) is estimated to EUR 227.88 mn (over HUF 59 billion).
OLAF found irregularities at 57 contracts, but 96% of the damages may be tied to five of these.
“The country is expected to have to repay some 59 billion forints (EUR 190M) to the European Union’s account as a result of the largest case of corruption since Hungary joined the EU", he added.
Conclusions
OLAF said the Budapest Metro Line No. 4 is “the most expensive EU funded project implemented in Hungary for the period 2007-2013. Total final costs of the project was HUF 452.55 billion (about 1.7 bn euros), of which Cohesion Funds financed EUR 696.49 million. Two loans by the European Investment Bank (EIB) - EUR 472 mn for the state and EUR 58.5 mn for the Municipality of Budapest - also contributed to the project’s financing.More than 100 contracts were signed in the course of the implementation of this project, out of which 20 were considered as large works contracts.
OLAF’s investigation established the following serious management irregularities and errors and possible fraud and other offences which took place from the beginning of the project and which affected the whole project throughout its implementation:
- DBR Metro Projects Directorate did not have the necessary professional capacity and the staff needed to implement correctly its coordination and management tasks.
- Some members of DBR Metro Projects Directorate or their hierarchical superiors were in the conflict of interests situation with one of the contractors.
- The owners of Eurometro Kft. (Project Management and FIDIC Engineer) were in the conflict of interest situation with several contractors.
- The choice of the “FIDIC Yellow Book standards" was not adapted to the incapacity of the Project Directorate to fulfil the function of co-ordinator.
- The insufficient financial and technical preparation of the project and the decision of choosing the “FIDIC Yellow Book standards" resulted in serious delays and considerable increase of the project costs. The total amount of claims introduced by different works contractors (accepted or under litigation) due to the delays was HUF 67.59 billion (cc. EUR 261 mn).
OLAF said “a significant number of public procurement procedures were affected by irregularities, some at the stage of the tender publication, others during the tender evaluation procedure."
The total amount of contracts affected by different type of irregularities is over EUR 1.05 bn (HUF 282.82 bn), which is about 60% of the total project amount of EUR 1.75 bn or HUF 452.6 bn.
The total estimated financial impact of the irregularities is EUR 644.78 mn (HUF 166.94 bn).
OLAF has found that the estimated financial impact on the EU co-financed “KÖZOP Operative Program" is EUR 295.95 mn (HUF 76.65 bn).
The total financial impact on the Cohesion Fund (77% of the eligible amount, which corresponds to 85% of the total subvention) is estimated to EUR 227.88 mn (over HUF 59 billion).
OLAF found irregularities at 57 contracts, but 96% of the damages may be tied to five of these.
- Siemens: power supply and train control systems for HUF 31.7 bn. OLAF suspects that the company gained insider information during the tender evaluation stage, through which it gained unjustified competitive advantage therefore the entire EU funding would need to be repaid. The 100% correction would mean the repayment of HUF 21.6 bn worth of EU funds.
- Alstom: supply of metro cars, for HUF 22.9 bn. Due to insider information and unjustified competitive advantage the full sum would be reclaimed. There was also suspicion of a HUF 2 bn graft.
- BAMCO-consortium (Vinci CGP, Strabag, Hídépítő Zrt.): tunnel building for HUF 62 bn. Unlawful tender winning (the company submitting the cheapest offer was excluded from the tender). HUF 8 bn worth of EU subsidy to be reclaimed.
- Swietelsky Ltd. : interior works of metro stations for HUF 40 bn. Due to irregularities in the tendering process HUF 7.6 bn worth of EU subsidies are to be reclaimed. The 25% correction comes on the back of unproven suspicion of bribery (HUF 2 bn).
- Strabag-Hídépítő Zrt.: structure of Baross square station for HUF 3.7 bn. Due to irregularities in public procurement procedures HUF 2.5 bn would be reclaimed (25% correction).









