Economy
EU fraud office finds shady deals at lighting firm linked to Orbán's son-in-law
What’s in the OLAF report?
OLAF told the WSJ this week it has completed a two-year investigation into 35 projects awarded to Elios Innovative Zrt, a company specializing in street lighting technology that was then co-owned by István Tiborcz, who married Orbán’s eldest daughter, Ráhel, in 2013. Granted between 2011 and 2015, the contracts to modernize Hungary’s street lighting were partly funded by the EU.OLAF’s investigation revealed not only serious irregularities in most of the projects, but also evidence of conflict of interest
, the office told the paper.OLAF, which has investigative powers but cannot directly prosecute, is recommending that Hungary’s public prosecutor pursue charges in the case.
The conflict of interest relates to Endre Hamar, a Hungarian businessman with stakes in various companies linked to the projects, according to a person familiar with the case. At the time the contracts were being awarded, Hamar was the owner of Sistrade, which helped municipalities prepare the tender process, giving advise on the requirements for successful bidders, according to the person. He was also, along with Tiborcz, a majority shareholder in Elios, the company winning many of those bids.
The European Commission told the WSJ it is assessing the OLAF report and will discuss the matter with Hungarian authorities and decide on possible action. Under EU rules applying to these programs, the commission holds back 5% of overall funding as a safeguard. The EU hasn’t reimbursed Hungary for all of the spending, meaning it could claw back some of the payments.
Although the report OLAF sent to the EU executive and Hungarian prosecutors is confidential, it is recommending that the EC recover more than EUR 40 million spent on the projects.
Hungarian public records show that between 2011 and 2015 Elios won 39 new contracts partly funded by the EU, of which 16 had only one bidder. The company won the lion’s share of the lighting renovation contracts in the final years of this period. Its profit after taxes rose from 201 million forints (USD 776,000) in 2012 to 972 million in 2015.
Hungarian authorities in 2015 launched an investigation into allegations of a possible urban-lighting cartel. Local media reported the investigation was dropped in 2016. Hungarian authorities didn’t reply to a request for comment on the investigation’s status.
The European Commission office for regional and urban policy, which was the main funder of the contracts, also conducted an audit into the project awards in 2015. The audit isn’t public.
PM Orbán told Parliament at the end of May 2015 that no one may benefit or be discriminated due to their relations, ethnic origin, or political views, and ordered state organisations to send away anyone who claim their relation to Orbán’s family in any of the tenders.
It was reported only a few days later that Tiborcz had sold his stake in Elios at the end of April, claiming he and his family was a continuous target due to this holding.
In the summer of 2015, his exit was put into a different light, when it turned out that OLAF was indeed looking into projects Elios Zrt. had carried out. Although investigations were indeed launched in relation to these also in Hungary, but the chief prosecutor said the probes into the lighting modernisation projects in Hévíz, Kalocsa, Mezőhegyes and Szekszárd were dropped.









