Hungary FinMin says debt of up to 80% of GDP is sustainable
In the op-ed, Varga summed up the similarities and differences of crisis management by the United States and the European Union in 2008-2009 and during the coronavirus pandemic. The facts, he said, indicate that the EU failed to catch up with the USA in terms of crisis management, either in respect or the speed and degree of interventions or the structure of the supportive regulatory environment.
The USA responded to the crisis faster and more efficiently than the EU both in 2008-2009 and now.
When trying to find the best way forward the question arises “how large additional spending aimed at restarting the economy can be, while making sure that it provides sufficient coverage for the measures, and it does not increase the country’s debt beyond the level that can be sustained in the long term.”
He reminded that Hungary took steps with a focus on competitiveness, while it managed to lower both the debt-to-GDP ratio and the budget deficit.
Varga noted that “the convergence of Europe (to the USA) is hampered by a fragmented fiscal policy and the mountains of debt of different size and structure, not only in the periphery countries, but also in central ones as France or Belgium.”
He said “the bureaucratic institutional system makes it difficult to react [to crises] therefore the amendment [and] fine-tuning of fiscal rules is expected to be a lengthy process.”
According to preliminary expectations, the 2022 French presidency will move to relax fiscal rules, said Varga.
The minister admitted that Hungary financed the management of the coronavirus crisis from the budget which led to a sharp rise in the shortfall, but added that
“There's a need for state intervention also to restart the economy, i.e. to support investments and the creation of jobs.”
The minister stressed that “Hungary had to choose its own path within the EU once again. That is why setting the budget deficit and the debt ratio should not be based on the EU’s fiscal rules that will potentially become more lenient.”
He states that Hungary
needs to find a very fine line where the financing need for the restart of the economy and the willingness to finance public debt from the market meet. This means that we need to aim for a debt ratio that is sustainable also in the long term.
Varga stressed that “as the Hungarian economy is small and open, assuming massive debts can be done only at the cost of increasing the country’s external vulnerability and FX exposure, as the government security absorbing capacity of the local investor community is limited.”
"Consequently, irrespective of EU regulations, in Hungary’s case we consider a debt level of up to 80% [of GDP] as sustainable.”

The content and timing of Mihály Varga’s op-ed suggests that this is a kind of a response to central bank (MNB) Governor György Matolcsy’s series of op-eds published over the last few weeks. In these he repeatedly slammed the government’s fiscal policy, particularly for what he said was an overly high and thus unsustainable budget deficit. He argues that the 5.9% of GDP shortfall pencilled in for 2022 is too high and also unjustified because restarting the economy will no longer be a necessity next year, while the bloated deficit will lead to cranking up the economy too much and fuelling inflation.
On these grounds Matolcsy warned that an overly loose fiscal policy and the already high debt level increases Hungary’s financial vulnerability, the risks of debt financing. He also envisioned a financial assault on Hungary and raised a red flag over a potential crisis. The risks of the latter, he said, could be mitigated by planning a budget deficit that is closer to 3.0% of GDP [the EU target] for 2022 which would in turn facilitate a faster reduction of the debt-to-GDP ratio from around 80%.
Varga’s op-ed is an implicit message that the government is aware of the potential risks posed by an excessive budget gap to debt financing therefore he has set a ceiling for fiscal policy [80% of GDP debt] that, on sustainability considerations, must not be breached.
Cover photo: Portfolio









