Could Hungary find itself in trouble due to skirmishes with Brussels?
NGEU funds to be available for Hungary eventually
Hungary is one of only four countries (along with Bulgaria, the Netherlands and Poland) that have not yet had their Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) plans approved by the European Commission, Fitch said in an Emerging Markets research note on Thursday.
The rating agency sees a substantial risk that Hungary will not receive the standard first tranche of Next Generation EU (NGEU) funds in 2021, but expects that Hungary ultimately will be able to access its entire EUR 7.2 billion grant allocation.
Why the delay?
The approval of the RRF plan, which was originally expected by the end of September, is necessary for Hungary to receive the first transfer of NGEU grants, which is to be used for pre-financing project in the plan.
The delays are mainly due to Hungary’s rifts with the Commission over rule of law and, more recently, anti-discrimination obligations. Since July, Hungary has been the target of a Commission infringement action to rescind a ‘child protection’ law that is seen as anti-LGBTQ.
Referendum plans not to be ditched
Fitch sees this impasse continuing in the near term. The government has refused to rescind the legislation in question and is set to hold a referendum on the issue in early 2022, while the European Council would need to agree by end-November if payments are to be released by the end-2021.
If this window is missed, Hungary can, still receive funds although not for pre-financing investment.
In this case, funds will be released once milestones agreed under the RRF plan are reached. The authorities have prepared for the absence of pre-financing by raising EUR 4.7 billion in Eurobonds in September.
Plans for the referendum are unlikely to be abandoned as it appears to be a key part of Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s campaign for parliamentary elections (due in April 2022).
That said, if the Fidesz-led oalition retains power, Fitch’s base case envisages a compromise for Hungary to gain access to NGEU funds, Fitch said.
Ultimatley the EU and its money remains popular in Hungary (and Poland) even though a pooling of areas of sovereignty within the EU causes frictions, and disputes can appeal to political bases.
An opposition-led victory would likely engender better relations with the EU, raising the probability of an even faster resolution.
While it is not the base case scenario of Fitch, the rating agency said a complete loss of NGEU funds would have a significant adverse impact on Hungary’s growth prospects, public finances and balance of payments.
Moody's also addresses dispute with EU
Steffen Dyck, Vice President and Senior Credit Officer at Moody's Investors Service, told an online summit organised by the rating agency on Thursday morning that a prolonged 'freeze' of EU funds would be credit negative for Hungary (and Poland). This remark is interesting for Moody's upgraded Hungary's ratings a just couple of weeks ago.
The base case of Moody's is that the European Commission will eventually reach an agreement with Budapest and Warsaw on the RRF and the transfer fo 2021-2027 EU funds, said Dyck.
If the disbursement of the funds were suspended for an extended period, it would be credit negative for both countries. In Hungary's case this means that if EU funds were not received well after next year's election, it would already be a negative scenario
, he replied to a question.
This remark is surprising given that Moody's upgraded Hungary's ratings to Baa2 from Baa3 on 24 September. It was only three weeks ago when it projected that an agreement on the RRF would be eventually reached and tht the impact of temporary delay on growth and government finances would be marginal.
Cover photo: Shutterstock









