Hungary "forgets" to notify Commission of energy emergency, EC not happy
Energy emergency, seven countermeasures
Gergely Gulyás, Prime Minister Viktor Orbán's chief of staff, announced on Wednesday that the government was declaring a state of emergency relating to energy supply risks. He cited uncertainties relating to the maintenance of the Nord Stream 1 pipeline (fears that it might not be reopened from 21 July) and subsequent concerns that there will simply be not enough gas in the whole of Europe this winter.
As a response, the cabinet adopted a package of seven measures, one of which was an export ban on energy and fuel wood, without any specific explanation. The seventh point was the most important one, namely the revampment of the utility bills reduction regime, which is aimed at forcing households to save on energy by slapping massive energy bills on those that consume above average (gas and electricity). Lower energy consumption is supposed to improve both security of supply and the country's fiscal situation.
Commission vexed
The EU executive recalled that Hungary announced the intention to introduce an energy emergency plan that would apparently include measures restricting the cross-border flows of gas and other energy carriers in the Single Market. Hungary has not notified the Commission of these planned measures. The Commission is in contact with the Hungarian authorities to better understand the emergency plan and to assess its implications for the neighbouring Member States.
The Commission pointed out that the EU has in place a robust legal framework for ensuring security of supply in a spirit of solidarity among Member States.
While Member States have the responsibility to ensure security of supply, a declaration of a state of emergency and its resulting measures must be taken in the presence of a clear threat of supply interruptions and notified to the Commission
under the Security of Supply regulation, to allow for proper information and coordination with neighbouring countries.
Individual national restrictions affecting gas cross-border flows are unwarranted and can only exacerbate problems in the current gas market situation.
All EU Member States are also subject to solidarity obligations under the existing security of supply rules, meaning that they are obliged to help their neighbours in case of urgent need, by supplying energy for protected customers, the Commission said.
The timing of the Hungarian measures was particularly bad for the Commission is to present next Wednesday its report and new recommendations on preparations for natural gas supplies in the winter.
This will include a number of elements detailing when and which other member states will have to bailed out in an acute situation (e.g. Hungary would reportedly bail out Austria with gas from the south, and Poland is to bail out Germany from gas from LNG terminals). Meanwhile, Gergely Gulyás rather suggested at the press conference that Hungary is not (yet) under any obligation to help other member states.
"More generally, any measures which restrict trade in goods, including any type of energy-bearing goods, within the internal market must be limited to what is necessary and be strictly proportionate," the Commission said.
Restrictions on the exports in the internal market can only be justified based on very specific grounds such as the protection of public order and public health. Economic grounds are never a legitimate justification.
The Commission stressed that a unified and coordinated approach at EU level and the respect of the legal framework of the EU energy policy and Single Market rules are necessary to respond effectively to any reduction of gas supplies from Russia. The EU has been working intensively on preparedness for the last months and the Commission will come forward with concrete proposals to reinforce our readiness for this winter on 20 July.
Cover photo: Getty Images









