Fiscal alcoholism has not disappeared in Hungary, it has just been transformed
Funds are in fact available, but only for pet projects
This is gist of this year's fiscal policy:
taxpayers' money can be used for whatever the government wants.
But it also means that anyone expecting a consistent, credible fiscal policy from the government will be disappointed. Indeed, the budget is determined not only by the government's response to the changing environment, but also by ad hoc government measures.
The most recent evidence to that is the announcement made on Monday morning that pro-government 4iG is buying a 51% stake in the local operation of Vodafone, while the state is to acquire a 49% stake in the telco for a total of HUF 715 billion. This means that taxpayers will pay HUF 350 billion on this minority package, most likely before year-end.
It's a key technical issue that this particular budget expenditure will not affect the ESA (accrual-based) general government balance, but it does increase the cash deficit. The expensive acquisition comes after the cabinet has been madly working over the last few months to rebalance the budget. It devised spending cuts worth HUF 2 trillion for this year, and is to save hundreds of billions of forints on partly pulling out of the utility bills reduction scheme.
This begs the question: If there was a need for a mammoth fiscal adjustment because the goals were at risk, how come the state can finance this deal now? Well, it can rely on several factors:
- Firstly, the room for manoeuvre stems from the fact that the government has not cut back on the extent of the austerity measures since they were announced, but rather increased them until now (raising the windfall tax on Mol, extra VAT revenue from the market fuel price, greater VAT revenue on higher overheads). It has not even changed the rules on residential overheads, which are likely to have a dramatic impact on the financial situation of individual families.
- Secondly, in recent months, the budget has seen significant revenue surpluses due to better-than-expected economic growth and much higher inflation, meaning that the fundamentals of the budget were strong in the first half of the year. Just think of the significant overshot of VAT revenue targets.
| Main measures affecting the 2022 budget balance since the announcement of the 2x HUF 2,000 bn adjustment | |
| Measure | Expected balance impact (bn HUF) |
| Positive impact on the balance | |
| Partial abandonment of utility bills reduction scheme | 500 |
| Tightening of KATA (tax for self-employed) tax | 50-300 |
| Hike of special tax on Mol | 80 |
| VAT content of market fuel prices | positive, but magnitude cannot be estimated |
| VAT content of higher overheads | positive, but magnitude cannot be estimated |
| Additional sales type tax revenue due to higher inflation | 700 |
| Negative impact on the balance | |
| Special quantity of natural gas | -736 |
| Purchase of military equipment | -35 |
| Extra pay rise for law enforcement agencies | negative, but no data available |
| Acquisition (49% of Vodafone Hungary) | -350 |
| Source: Portfolio research | |
Fiscal alcoholism continues
Such a transaction, in such a crisis environment (energy crisis, fear of recession), has opportunity costs and consequences beyond the budget.
- One of the key messages is that the economic policy turnaround between May and mid-July, which sought to correct the fiscal alcoholism that had dominated at the beginning of the year, has stalled to say the least. The government is spending the extra tax revenues it generates during the year not to improve the fiscal balance further and cut the public debt faster, but to finance economic goals. And this behaviour calls into question the credibility of disciplined fiscal policy.
- So fiscal alcoholism continues, but in a slightly different way. Before the spring parliamentary elections, the government directly favoured the population (extra pension payments, personal income tax refund, 'firearms money' for law enforcement staff, etc.), but since then a wide section of the population has been directly disadvantaged (tightening of KATA rules, higher utility bills, i.e. austerity measures), while other targets have been given priority: Vodafone purchase (HUF 350 bn), extraordinary gas purchase (syndicated bank loan of up to EUR 1 bn for 700 million cubic metres of gas), purchase of military equipment (HUF 65 bn), new pay rises for police and soldiers (HUF 52 bn this year). This also shows that fiscal policy has been in a new turnaround since mid-July and that the government is not exactly implementing measures to cushion the effects of the crisis and reduce the risk of an adjustment spiral.
- With its recent decisions, the government is spending much more money on the economic functions of the state than on other purposes, i.e. the government values strengthening national ownership in one sector over, for example, investing in human resources (health, education) or cushioning the effects of the rising utility bills.
- The Hungarian economy and Hungarian investment vehicles are the most sensitive to the energy crisis raging in Europe, and investors (see the forint market movements of the past few days) and credit rating agencies are well aware of this. It is no coincidence that Hungary has already received its first warning from S&P. And the signs of weakening fiscal policy consistency are not positive for Hungary's debt rating.
So, all in all, we can say that the government will not only pay the HUF 350 billion when it acquires a minority stake in Vodafone Hungary, but there will also be extra costs to the budget, which also means that
THE COST OF THE STATE'S profligacy WILL BE LARGELY FINANCED BY THE PUBLIC THROUGH HIGHER UTILITY BILLS AND MUCH HIGHER TAXES (VAT AND OTHERS).
Cover photo: MTI/Péter Lakatos









