One leg of EU's oil sanctions on Russia is "total madness" - analyst
One of the topics of the lengthy interview was the EU's anti-Russian oil sanctions, one leg of which came into force on 5 December last year (no Russian crude can be imported into the EU, but Hungary, Slovakia and the Czech Republic have been exempted from them with regard to pipeline supplies).
The other leg will come into force from 5 February and means that refined products such as diesel produced from Russian crude oil in this way cannot be sold to other countries by refiners in these three countries. The aim is not to distort the fuel markets of other countries and gain a fierce competitive advantage by using products made from Ural-type Russian crude oil bought at depressed prices.
In Pletser's view, the key question on the subject is "how do you convert Slovnaft's Bratislava refinery from 100% Russian oil to marine oil? It is physically possible, there is the Adriatic pipeline. Except that the Croats are already asking seven times the price. For electricity, there are already European rules on how much you can charge per kilometre of line, but for oil there is no upper limit on the transit price."
The analyst recalled the sixth package of EU sanctions, which included the possibility for Slovnaft to buy Russian oil but not to export refined products made from it. In this context, he said:
This is total madness. It goes against the fundamental principle of the European Union, which is the free movement of goods and services across borders.
He also noted that, according to his information, "now the Czechs, Slovaks, Hungarians and Austrians are not lobbying for cheaper Adriatic, but for Slovnaft to be taken out of the package. For these countries, and even for southern Poland, it is crucial that Slovnaft can export. I expect that there will be further fine-tuning. If the oil embargo causes tension somewhere, the EU will quietly back off."
Asked how Hungary will get diesel, he said "we are prepared and can bring it from Schwechat or eventually from Trieste", but it will be expensive because the port and rail transport are both at capacity. He added:
But if Slovnaft has to cut production, it will be self-destruction for the whole region. A solution must be found here by 5 February, even if it means giving Bratislava a reprieve. That would be the easiest thing to do.
As for the second leg of the oil sanction coming into force on 5 February, Pletser says that "the European market is very much gearing up for this: everyone is stockpiling, building stocks, and setting up new supply routes". It may also be easier now because there is sufficient supply of diesel due to the global economic challenges and European diesel margins are still high, so it is worth supplying here.
Many other topics were also discussed in the interview, such as the fact that Western sanctions could significantly reduce Russia's oil production capacity in the coming years, which could also pose a risk to Russian oil imports through the Friendship pipeline. He also noted that the possibility that Western companies may not carry out the necessary maintenance this summer due to sanctions could also pose a significant risk to Hungarian gas imports through the Turkish Stream pipeline.
According to Pletser, "the next two years could still be critical" for EU gas supply, but after 2025 it could be a calmer period, as the global gas supply side is also increasing, and so "a price level below €100 could be set after 2025". For gas prices for the next two years, he said his expectation is €150/megawatt hour. "Probably this should be revised lower now due to the fact that this year's consumption figures are much better."
Cover photo: Portfolio









