Paks II nuclear power plant expansion in the crossfire of sanctions

Portfolio
On Tuesday, the Paks II project took an interesting turn: the CEO of Rosatom spoke about the start of construction of Paks II in 2024, while the head of Siemens Energy also vowed to fulfil their contract. At the same time, a group of activist investors within the German company is vehemently opposed to cooperation with the Russian nuclear company. Meanwhile, it remains to be seen whether the Berlin government can issue export licences for Siemens' control systems because of the sanctions, a situation that has even made the European Commission wary.
Paks II. godor helyszin

It's been a busy week for the Paks nuclear power plant expansion, with two promises on Tuesday that the project is not under threat. On the one hand, Rosatom CEO Alexey Likhachev has indicated that the Russian side is ready to speed up the construction of Paks II and expects the first concrete to be poured next year.

The other statement was made by Siemens Energy CEO Christian Bruch, who told the company's shareholders' meeting that since they had signed a contract with Rosatom before the war in Ukraine for the German company to supply the control system for the power plant, they wanted to fulfil it. "We basically feel bound by the existing contracts," Bruch said, according to Handelsblatt reports.

At Thursday's Government Info, however, Minister leading the PM's Office Gergely Gulyás was more pessimistic, saying that the government has a scenario for every case where Western companies would pull out.

The German control system company is under pressure from both within and outside, which could make it impossible for it to participate in the development of the Paks nuclear power plant.

German activist investors are already on the move

But on Tuesday, there was also a counter-pressure: at the shareholders' meeting, the CEO of Siemens Energy had to address the Paks II case because several investors criticised the company for the fact that it had withdrawn from Russia because of the conflict in Ukraine, but had done business with the state-owned nuclear energy company. That there would be a dispute was expected in advance, with Friends of the Earth Europe, an umbrella organisation of activist investors, and the Russian environmental NGO Ecodefense also signalling their opposition to working with the Russian company. In addition, they criticised the German company not only for its statements of principle condemning environmental protection and Russian aggression, but also argued that the Paks deal violates sanctions in several respects.

As the organisations explained in their statement, the company, together with its consortium partner Framatome, supplies so-called "instrumentation and control (I&C) systems" for Russian nuclear reactors. On 2 December 2021, when they believe there were already signs of an invasion of Ukraine, the Franco-German consortium signed a new contract with the Russians. The fact that Rosatom is directly under the administration of Russian President Vladimir Putin and is responsible for the development and production of Russian nuclear weapons is also seen as problematic. This makes Rosatom one of the most effective tools for the Kremlin's geopolitical ambitions.

According to the organisations that criticised the agreement, it specifically mentions the area of I&C systems, which is the responsibility of Siemens Energy. These systems are technically very complex and form the control centre of the reactor. Siemens Energy's Teleperm XS system has already been used in the newer generation of Rosatom reactors, Novovoronezh II and Leningrad II, which operate with VVER-1200 units, but will be supplied for the newer units, like Paks II.

According to Patricia Lorenz, nuclear activist at Friends of the Earth Europe, this would only "further increase the energy dependence of Hungary, an EU member, on Russia". And at the shareholders' meeting she called for a U-turn from Siemens Energy to avoid increasing this exposure.

The organisations also made the case to the German energy company that there are several people in the management of Rosatom who have already been sanctioned by the European Union or are considered key allies of President Vladimir Putin. They mentioned Sergey Kiriyenko, the chairman of the nuclear company's supervisory board, who is also deputy head of the Russian presidential administration and therefore a confidant of the head of state. According to the activist investors, investigative articles have reported that Kiriyenko played a key role in the deal between Rosatom and Siemens Energy.

The other person subject to criminal measures is Sergei Borisovich Korolev, another member of the supervisory board of the Russian state nuclear industrial company. He was formerly deputy head of the Russian secret service, the FSB, which is also seen by activists as a disqualifying factor.

There is something that Péter Szijjártó has already complained about

It is important to emphasise that none of the above-mentioned issues is a legal obstacle to the German energy company maintaining its contract with Rosatom. In fact, as Siemens Energy argues, it is the Hungarian government's express wish that the control system for the power plant be delivered, because the company is

the only manufacturer in the world with references that allow it to be certified to European standards.

However, it is precisely because of this that the Paks II project may face a serious obstacle: the control technology co-produced with Framatome is so complex that it may already be

subject to the EU's dual-use export ban.

Siemens Energy itself confirmed to the newspaper, "There is currently no delivery, as the German Federal Office of Economics and Export Control (BAFA) has not yet decided on the application for an export licence". The BAFA is under the authority of the Green Party politician Robert Habeck, Vice Chancellor of Germany, Minister for Economic Affairs and Climate Action, who is both critical of nuclear energy and committed to tougher EU action against Russia.

On the Hungarian side, Foreign Minister Péter Szijjártó attacked Habeck two weeks ago, saying that the blockade was "unacceptable, because the compilation of the national energy mix is a national competence, and the issue of our energy security is a national matter. And it is unacceptable for another European government, in the absence of any European legislation, to block, for who knows what political or ideological reasons, the developments needed to ensure the security of energy supply of another country."

The Hungarian minister said that he had also indicated to the European Commission that "they should not come up with any proposal" that would in any way restrict nuclear energy cooperation between Hungary and Russia.

Portfolio contacted the BAFA, but the licensing authority referred us to the German Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Action, so we asked when a decision on the export license is expected, and whether they will examine compliance with the sanction restrictions or what other aspects will be taken into account. The ministry, however, told us only that "the [German] federal government does not comment on possible individual cases due to the protection of companies' corporate and trade secrets."

The European Commission could also get involved

At the same time, EU sources have told Portfolio that BAFA is also investigating whether the control system is really only suitable for civilian use or whether it could help the Russian military in war, or even in the development of nuclear weapons.

The situation is complicated and even Brussels is not sure of the answer. All EU member states, including Hungary, adopted a ban on the export of dual-use goods in March last year.

These are technological tools - including software - that can be used for both civil and military purposes. Separately included are export items that could be used for the design, development, production or application of nuclear, chemical or biological weapons or their means of delivery. They are included even if they were to be used for civilian purposes.

However, the EU regulation itself leaves some room for manoeuvre, with exemptions for exports for cooperation between governments, or for exports for the operation, maintenance and safety of civil nuclear capacity, among other things. In theory, national authorities could thus also authorise the export of nuclear technology if it is for the establishment, operation, maintenance, fuel supply, fuel reprocessing and safety of existing capabilities for the civil use of nuclear energy, the design, construction and commissioning of nuclear facilities necessary for the completion of civil nuclear installations.

In principle, these are in favour of Paks II and Siemens Energy, as is the fact that an exception can be made for nuclear power plant construction products for contracts concluded before 26 February 2022, whereas this was already agreed with Rosatom by the Franco-German side in December the year before last.

However, the batch list itself - Annex VII of the EU Regulation - contains quite strict restrictions on exactly which items are prohibited for export. And there are plenty of items that in principle exclude the export of control technology to Russia. Here, it is up to the national authorities to approve the procedure, which depends on the technology and assess the risks.

In simple terms, BAFA is now assessing what the system and its components are good for and what they are not good for, and what the risk is if Rosatom obtains it.

Overall, the fact that the French authorities have granted an export licence for the technology produced by Framatome and that a version of this technology from the previous generation is already in use at the Novovoronezh power plants also improves the chances of Paks II. Ergo, Russia would not really gain any new knowledge, the only question is what it would gain if the Russian military seized the technology meant for the Hungarian nuclear power plant.

But the political climate does not look good for the Hungarian power plant plans: while Robert Habeck's party, the German Greens, oppose the expansion of nuclear energy in Europe, members of the European Parliament have also periodically called for a ban on Rosatom. In addition, several member states, including Poland, Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia, would impose sanctions on nuclear technology and ban cooperation with Russia. However, there does not yet seem to be any realistic prospect of a ban: in the European Council, Hungary would certainly veto such a measure, while France and other Eastern European countries are also wary of such a move.

Speaking at the previously quoted Government Info on Thursday, Gergely Gulyás said that the sanctions in their current form do not make it easier, but they do not create any obstacles that would prevent the project from going ahead. The minister reiterated that no sanctions would be supported that would make the expansion impossible.

Cover photo: Portfolio

 

More in Economy

benzin_3
February 27, 2026 13:45

Could the price of petrol really leap to HUF 1,000 a litre in Hungary?

The situation is more complex than it may seem at first glance

adó-munkaerőpiac-foglalkoztatás-szocho-adókedvezmény
February 27, 2026 09:46

The labour market situation is deteriorating in Hungary

Employment hits five-year low

D_MTI20260210007
February 27, 2026 09:18

Hungary's Orbán plans new steps with Fico to bring back Druzhba flow

Prime Minister speaks in regular interview

szijjártó péter
February 26, 2026 16:56

Ukraine summons Hungary's chargé d'affaires in Kyiv - MoFA

Conflict remains heated

Mol Dunai Finomító Dufi kőolajfinomító benzin naplemente
February 26, 2026 16:42

Hungary's Mol threatens Janaf, sets Friday deadline

The oil company may turn to the European Commission

LATEST NEWS
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts, spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas

Detailed search