Hungary needs half a million new workers, partly via economic migration - Development Minister
EU enforces its will on member states by withholding funds - Parragh
The head of the Hungarian Chamber of Commerce and Industry that crises of a different nature are becoming more frequent. He mentioned the financial crisis of 2008, the COVID-19 crisis, geopolitical competition, internal tensions in the EU, the war between Russia and Ukraine. The series of challenges is hardly over, he said.
The European Union wants to impose its will on member states by withholding EU funds,
said László Parragh, adding that a balance must be found between corporate responsibility and state presence.
The President pointed out that the Chamber had been drawing attention to the inflationary threat for five years.
Today, we are getting calls from companies saying that they bought the raw material at EUR/HUF 430 and they have to sell the finished product at EUR/HUF 370, he said, pointing out one of the consequences of the volatility of the exchange rate.
Parragh criticises the central bank
Parragh then asked: were the MNB's reactions the right ones?
A country the size of Hungary can pursue unorthodox economic policies successfully, but can unorthodox monetary policies be successful in the long term?, he asked another question. He mentioned that foreigners could sell the their FX bond bond holdings at any time, which is a risk.
The MNB has for a long time denied that there is an inflationary risk, Parragh rapped MNB Governor György Matolcsy who has slammed the government for its economic policy mistakes on Wednesday.
The real risk is not when we would catch up with Austria, but when Romania will overtake Hungary, said Parragh.
It is possible to step on the accelerator and apply the brakes at the same time, but only if it is the same person that does it, he said.
At present, the monetary restraint on economic growth is what economic agents are experiencing,
he said.
Subsequently, there is an imbalance between internal and external demand. He then listed:
- the consumption structure will get reshuffled,
- retail trade is shrinking at national and EU level,
- the construction sector is also declining.
We are happy to see investments from South-East Asian companies coming to Hungary, but culturally Asians are different. If you talk to a German and tell him what the rules are, he will follow them, and the Asians "just understand", he explained.
We have to permanently change the labour supply, and the most important tool to do this is training, which is the way to provide the economy with a competitive workforce. The primary means of doing this is no longer vocational training, but adult education, the chamber president explained.
Last autumn, there was a panic about the energy price shocks, but it was followed by an adjustment, said Parragh.
The agreements with the EU work less and less, he said, referring to the suspension of EU funds. He said it is a form of blackmail.
Disbursing EU funds should not be a tool for political pressure,
he stressed.
Parragh appears to be generously forgetting the reason why the EU blocked cohesion and coronavirus recovery funds for Hungary. The main reasons were rampant and systemic corruption, fraud with EU funds in public procurement, trampling on EU values, the curbing of academic freedom (the effective ousting of CEU, rendering universities under the management of public interest trusts with pro-government figures sitting and even heading the boards of trustees), the lack of media pluralism, and we have not even mentioned the treatment of NGOs and LGBTQ communities (e.g. the Child Protection Act).
Parragh also raised the issue that while the EU funds due to Hungary are not forthcoming, financial assistance to Ukraine is underway and it is questionable who will be able to participate in the reconstruction of Ukraine. "Raise your hand if you participated in the reconstruction of Iraq," he said, drawing an analogy to the chances of Hungarian entrepreneurs participating in the reconstruction of Ukraine.
How could one possibly compare aid given to a war-torn country and aid not given to an EU Member State that has serious rule of law issues? Well, there's your answer.
In 2022, without the effects of the war, Hungary's GDP growth could have reached 5.2%, according to the chamber's estimates.
We are behind the government on the battery factories, Parragh said. In his parliamentary address yesterday, central bank (MNB) Governor György Matolcsy criticised this industrial policy.
The market is finding it difficult to tackle the challenges on its own,
said Parragh, adding that it is therefore necessary to
- reorganise the economy,
- come up with an industrial policy that addresses the energy challenge.
He also presented the main figures of the Széchenyi Card Programme: last year 1,800 billion forints were disbursed under this scheme, and 54,000 loans were signed. The role of the Chamber is to be strengthened, he concluded.
Employment figures should increase, partly through economic migration - Economy Minister
Márton Nagy, Minister of Economic Development, gave a presentation on Hungarian economic cohesion and its conditions.
"I could also talk about the central bank, but let's leave that aside," he began, before presenting the government's economic development strategy.
"Hungary can reach 90% of the EU's development level by 2030, I would not give up on that. Our current ranking is 20th, by 2030 we could be No.15," he predicted, adding that being better than 15th is unrealistic.
What has not changed is that investment is the basis for economic growth. We can push the investment rate to 30%, Nagy continued. In addition, we need to use the results of extensive, quantitative growth to shift to intensive, qualitative growth, he listed:
- higher labour productivity;
- smart, green investments;
- digitalisation and robotisation;
- high domestic value added;
- digitalisation.
The prerequisites for growth are: enough energy and enough labour, the minister continued, adding that by 2030 the country will need 68 TWh of energy, up from 43 TWh in 2022.
In the meantime, the number of people in employment should increase by 500,000, he said, pointing to one of the key targets. There is economic migration, partly to deal with this, and partly from inactive people becoming active.
Two-thirds of investment is financed internally and one-third externally, with foreign working capital increasingly dominant.
The opening to the East has been achieved in terms of foreign working capital, Nagy added.
Foreign-owned companies in Hungary are realising a return of around 100% on their invested capital each year, while Hungarian companies abroad typically realise a return of 6.5%, Márton Nagy said, adding that there is still room for growth in FDI inflows.
According to the minister, domestic-owned companies are stronger in terms of value added than foreign-owned firms. The share of turnover of Hungarian firms in the retail trade and transport-logistics-storage sector has decreased, Márton Nagy said. He hinted that the government is ready to actively intervene to strengthen Hungarian actors and Hungarian ownership.
Hungary's integration into international value chains must be strengthened through domestically owned companies, said Márton Nagy, specifically mentioning that Hungarian-owned companies must strengthen their position at the TIER-1 supplier level. In TIER-2, Hungarian firms have grown up to be dominant compared to foreign ones.
Outward investment could also gain momentum, he predicted. He said that budget subsidies could increasingly support private investment (FDI).
"We are back again to lending and central bank policy. But be careful with this, because I promised not to talk about central bank policy," he reiterated, deliberately not responding to National Bank Of Hungary (MNB) Governor György Matolcsy's criticisms yesterday, for example. Last year, bank credit penetration was at a very low level, which is why we cannot catch up with European economies, Márton Nagy said.
Mihály Varga: Surging energy prices 'stole' from education, health care
Minister of Finance Mihály Varga Mihály gave a presentation titled 'Stability and Growth', saying that we have entered an era of dangers: a 3% global economic downturn in 2020, gas prices of 350 euros, double-digit inflation.
In such a situation, economic policy is consolidating, reducing the budget deficit. He stressed that the budget shortfall will fall from 7.5% of GDP to less than 3%. In 2024, it will be 2.5%, the minister said in his presentation.
There will be further consolidation in the budget this year, with a deficit of 3.9% this year and 2.5% next year, but we have not yet taken the necessary measures, he said.
Varga said the economic outlook is gradually improving. The external financing need will be around 0% in the second half of this year, inflation will fall significantly and could be around 3% by summer 2024. Next year, the unemployment rate could be below 3.5% and GDP growth above 4%.
After assessing the economic outlook, Mihály Varga turned to energy dependence. The main driver of inflation was the rise in gas prices, he said, adding that the Hungarian economy was particularly exposed to the Russia-Ukraine war and the sanctions imposed on Russia.
The rise in energy prices was financed by the budget, so there was no money for education, health and other purposes, he admitted.
He described demographic trends as an important challenge. The reserves in domestic employment are increasingly being exhausted, Mihály Varga said.
Another challenge is the steady rise in the share of the older generation, with 2.2 million people aged 65 and over by 2030. This is why the government is not reducing support for families. As a result, Varga pointed out that, unlike in other European countries, the nominal annual number of births increased from 90,000 in 2010 to 94,000 in 2020. However, the minister did not mention that the opposite trend in the number of live births was observed in 2021 and 2022.
The fight against the black economy will continue, with the result that VAT gap will be reduced to 5.1% by 2020.
The introduction of a global minimum tax will be a serious dilemma if it becomes a mandatory step, he said.
On taxation, the plans are: e-Tax for businesses by 2024, single point of transmission of employment data for businesses by 2025, he said. This will lead to a significant reduction in tax administration, Varga predicted.









