Shocking data show why the Hungarian budget is in trouble
We reported a fortnight ago that the Hungarian budget's May performance was laudable at first sight. The Finance Ministry's detailed general government data, however, paint a dreadful picture of the state of the budget.
We've been warning in articles for weeks that the government could be in trouble not only with the 2024 budget, but it may also be forced to implement fiscal adjustment measures this year and/or raise its current 3.9% of GDP deficit target.
EXPENDITURES
The ministry's detailed budget report for May show the following key data on the spending side:
- General government expenditure was 23% higher in May than in the same month of 2022.
- Expenditure on special and normative subsidies amounted to HUF 1 373.7 billion by the end of May, which is HUF 1 158.2 billion higher in the same period of last year. In May alone, said spending came in HUF 70 bn higher than in the base period. The massive difference in the Jan-May figures is relating to the government's overheads protection scheme, which entailed transfers of HUF 894.6 billion this year, against no payment in the first five months of 2022. The funds went to the compensation of district heating companies, the universal service of electricity and natural gas and stockpiling.
- Interest expenditure reached HUF 225 billion, up 68% yr/yr.
- Expenditure on public assets was also higher in May this year, at HUF 194 billion, up from HUF 57 billion a year earlier. A detailed graph attached to the report shows that for some reason the government has spent more than HUF 100 billion on company-related expenditure (including recapitalisation of existing companies).
- Higher pensions also boosted the expenditure side significantly: the amount of pensions paid out was 26% higher.
So it is clear that the fundamental risks of overspending on the expenditure side that we have seen so far have not disappeared (this applies to interest expenditure, spending on public assets and pensions).
REVENUES
Upon a closer look at the revenue side we can draw the conclusion that
the receipt of the first instalments of special taxes, as well as additional one-off revenue items, saved the May budget balance and effectively concealed the adverse base effects.
- General government revenue exceeded HUF 3 trillion in May, which corresponds to a 26.5% yr/yr increase.
- Within this, central budget revenues grew by 37.6%.
- This owes mainly to the 61% increase in payments by business organisations in May this year, which amounted to HUF 639 billion. Within this, corporate tax receipts increased by 40% to HUF 374 billion.
- Financial enterprises paid the budget HUF 23 billion, which compares with less than HUF 1 bn a year earlier.
- Payments by the energy sector reached HUF 88 bn, up from HUF 31 bn in May 2022.
- Retail tax receipts more than tripled to over HUF 28 bn from HUF 9 bn.
- Drug producers' tax payments to the tune of HUF 38 bn contributed greatly to the stabilisation of the budget in May.
- At first glance, consumption taxes have performed well, with an increase of 8% to HUF 519 billion, but their structure shows worrying trends.
However, revenues from the value-added tax fell to HUF 283 billion from HUF 342 billion.
- Special tax payments also contributed to the increase in sales-type tax revenues. Telecoms tax came in at HUF 39 billion, up from HUF 5 billion last year, while transaction tax came in at HUF 26 billion in May this year, up from HUF 19 billion.
- Insurance tax revenue has exploded to HUF 61 billion, up from HUF 10.6 billion in May last year.
- Only the contributions paid by the population and the various contributions (Health Insurance Fund and Pension Fund) give a reassuring picture, with an increase of 16.1%.
- Payments related to state assets also helped the May balance: compared to HUF 27 billion last year, HUF 138 billion was received in this category in the fifth month of this year. The detailed graph attached shows that in May this year the state received HUF 108 billion in dividends and HUF 64 billion from the sale of quotas.
- Payments to the savings fund were also much higher in May this year: HUF 119 billion vs HUF 17 billion.
To illustrate the underlying budgetary processes, it is also worth highlighting the first five months of VAT receipts. By the end of May, VAT receipts amounted to HUF 2,652 billion, which is 33.2% of the annual target. This compares with 37.7% of the annual target at this time last year.
Based on this, it can be calculated that, in simple terms,
this year's VAT receipts are HUF 360 billion behind due to the consumption crisis in the first five months.
It will be interesting to see how the government will/wants to deal with this year's fiscal challenges. Can we expect corrective measures and when, and will these be spending cuts, postponed investment projects, or tax hikes (consumption-type or special taxes)?
It is clear that this process has already begun with the 2024 budget, as the government has amended the family housing subsidy scheme (CSOK), obviously with a view to saving money. Given the above developments, it seems extremely likely that raising the 3.9% of GDP deficit target for 2023 is inevitable.
Cover photo: Getty Images









