Hungary's Orbán persuaded to drop veto of Ukraine aid in good cop-bad cop game
EU leaders unanimously approved a total of €50 billion in aid for Ukraine, in what has become one of the highlights of world politics last week. The decision was far from being a joyride, as Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán had long threatened to torpedo the deal that would have flopped without unanimity.
The situation was complicated by the fact that the results of the National Consultation - in which 99% of participants opposed EU financial assistance to Ukraine until Hungary received similar support - seemed to leave Orban little room for manoeuvre. Nevertheless, the Hungarian government finally bowed to pressure and is now trying to sell this as a success at home.
The New York Times reported, citing senior diplomats and sources who attended secret meetings, serious efforts were made to persuade Orbán.
Many EU leaders tried to defuse the tension with humour, jesting they would send Orbán their hotel bills for the extra nights they had to spend in brussels.
Others, less jokingly, relayed to him that he was facing the risk of a legal suspension from European Union proceedings. And a few offered a friendly, sympathetic ear over late-night drinks as he complained about what he sees as a European bureaucracy stacked against him out of ideological animus.
This carefully coordinated, behind-the-scenes pressure had forced the Hungarian PM to fold and drop his veto on Thursday morning, just one hour into the emergency summit.
The NYT said this "role playing" by EU leaders was "a breakthrough not just for Ukraine but for EU unity as well"
European Council President Charles Michel was the bad cop, while Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, Orbán's ideological friend from the hard right, was the good cop. Michel made it clear to Orbán there was no way his demand for an annual veto right over the Ukraine fund would be granted. He also reminded him that some member states were considering going for the 'nuclear option', Article 7 proceedings in a bid to strip Hungary of its voting rights in the Council, which would be an unprecedented use of the EU's rulebook.
Meanwhile, Meloni met Orbán in the executive suite of the stately Amigo hotel — a staple for visiting dignitaries, tucked away in the centre of Brussels, trying to convince him that bowing to the will of the majority would be beneficial both for him and his country in the long run.
French President Emmanuel Macron was up next, suggesting that the EU leaders could include some language in their joint conclusions that would nod to Orbán’s complaints about being treated unfairly by the EU executive branch.
At the same time, a meeting between Charles Michel, Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, confirmed that there was nothing to gain from holding out on the Ukraine fund, and that message was relayed back to Orbán.
Before Thursday’s meeting, Orbán had been demanding an annual chance to veto the disbursement of money to Ukraine, but that was rejected. Instead, leaders agreed to a regular review of the spending to assuage concerns about diversion or corruption, EU officials said.
The deal is that the European Commission will draft an annual report on how the Ukraine fund is being used. European leaders will have a chance to debate its performance and raise any concerns about it.
The European Parliament needs to approve the fund by simple majority, a bar that should be easily cleared, and the vote could take place as early as this month. The EUR 50 bn aid is a significant step forward for Ukraine to sustain its economy in the next four years and address the challenges of the war being fought with Russia. Meanwhile, a similar scale of assistance remains under discussion in the United States, as aid is currently stuck in Congress.
Officials said on Thursday Orbán had managed only to extract a reference in the summit conclusions urging the European Commission to be “proportionate” in the way it freezes funding for member states it punishes for violations, as is the case with Hungary.
In an interview with VRT News, Hungary's Foreign Minister Péter Szijjártó said Hungary wanted guarantees that the EU funds that are owed to Hungary but are currently withheld over rule of law concerns would not end up as aid in Ukraine.
The interviewer interjected that no one had made any such proposal. The minister then explained that a member state not receiving its EU funds is right to "have a suspicion" that its money could end up at an external partner when it needs financial support. "But we got the guarantees that this is not going to happen."
So, Hungary received guarantees that something that no one had proposed was not going to happen. Right.
It was very important for us to have a kind of review mechanism every year to see how the money is being spent by the Ukrainian side. So, now the Commission will give a report every year and based on that report the Council will give guidance.
When reminded that Orbán wanted a yearly decision, but instead he got a yearly discussion, Szijjártó said it will be a yearly report and the possibility for the Council to give guidance to the European Commission, "it's fine with us."
Since both our expectations have been fulfilled in a satisfactory manner, we are okay.
Cover photo: Thierry Monasse/Getty Images









