Hungarian statistical office makes major revision after accuracy of poverty data is called into question

Portfolio
The Hungarian Central Statistical Office (KSH) has completed the revision of European Union statistics on income and living conditions (EU-SILC) for the period between 2018 and 2023, after several researchers have called into question the accuracy of Hungarian figures. As a result of the revision, the main indicator of poverty, the rate of people at risk of poverty or social exclusion, did not change significantly at national level in any of the years, the stats office said on Monday. At the same time, the risk of poverty has shifted slightly among certain population groups.
lakas

"The Hungarian Central Statistical Office (HCSO) completed the planned revision to the EU-SILC data collection, for the period between 2018 and 2023. As a result of the revision, the main indicator of poverty, the rate of people at risk of poverty or social exclusion, did not change significantly at national level in any of the years. The revision confirmed the reliability of EU-SILC data and methodology, and also pointed out that pre-revision data had already provided an appropriate basis for monitoring poverty," the KSH said in a statement on Monday.

The KSH carried out a major revision to data coming from the EU-SILC data collection – examining the living conditions and income position of households – and referring to the period between 2018 and 2023. The Office made the revision as planned in advance and independently of the relevant news published in the press,

it said.

In the frame of the revision, the KSH, using population data from the 2022 Census, re-weighted EU-SILC data. Over the revision, the statistical office also considered remarks having come from users in the last years. As a result:

  • the method of imputation of income data was fine-tuned in order to make the distribution more accurate;
  • by making the grossing-up algorithm more accurate, there is no more inconsistency between net and gross incomes;
  • by optimising the imputation procedure, excessive volatility in the poverty risk gap of the different groups is over as well.

As a result of the revision, the main indicator of poverty, the rate of people at risk of poverty or social exclusion, did not change in effect at national level in any of the years.. However, the risk of poverty of certain groups of the population was slightly restructured.

250929ksh01
Source: KSH

The share of people at risk of poverty or social exclusion is a composite indicator that measures the share of people affected by either relative income poverty or severe material and social deprivation or very low work intensity. 

Merely one of the components of the complex indicator, relative income poverty changed in effect. However, neither the main indicator nor the trend of the components altered,

the KSH said.

"The information coming from the EU-SILC data collection have already constituted a reliable basis for decision-making and researches. The updated data, however, further fine-tune earlier estimates, and allow more accurate analyses than earlier on. . Eurostat also validated the revised data and will soon publish them," it added.

The stats office stressed that it "continues to be committed to supporting the utilisation of data for scientific purposes and is open to co-operation and professional dialogue with users."

At a press conference on Monday morning, Tamás Tóth, the Deputy President of the Hungarian Central Statistical Office (KSH), said that the revision was due to the results of the census. He added that this was completely unrelated to reports in the press concerning the office's poverty data. He added that the office had informed Eurostat and researchers at various conferences that this revision would be carried out.

According to Tamás Tóth, the new data fell within the margin of sampling error compared to the old data. He emphasised that the proportion of young people at risk of poverty had increased, whereas it had decreased among older people.

This story began when two researchers, Annamária Tátrai (ELTE) and András Gábos (Tárki), raised serious professional concerns about Hungarian poverty statistics. According to the researchers, the Central Statistical Office (KSH) has been publishing income poverty data since 2017 that is highly questionable from a statistical point of view.

Put simply, Tátrai and Gábos claim that their histograms demonstrate that a significant proportion of people have experienced an increase in income that is only just above the poverty threshold. According to them, the probability of this occurring naturally is zero. Based on Eurostat data, they believe that the income distribution in Hungary since 2018 is distorted, a phenomenon not observed in other EU countries.

250929ksh02

At a press conference on Monday, Tamás Tóth emphasised that the outlier value located at the poverty threshold was a coincidence. This has been corrected by the new methodology, which means there are no such clusters around the poverty threshold.

According to Tátrai and Gábor, this distortion does not only occur in certain years, but regularly. The income brackets affected are consistently located in politically sensitive areas close to the poverty line. Furthermore, data from the Central Statistical Office shows that 14% of single-person households report an income that differs by no more than ten million points, which the researchers describe as statistically meaningless.

The researchers said that further suspicion was aroused by the fact that the tower-shaped curves, which had been confirmed by Eurostat, could not be taken out of the KSH research room, even though they could be generated from public EU databases. Despite initial indications as early as 2017, the KSH did not investigate or correct the problematic patterns, according to the researchers.

In response to the article, the KSH rejected the allegations in a statement issued earlier. "The Hungarian Central Statistical Office is devoted to inform users in an objective and transparent manner. The statistical data published by the Office are comparable in a transparent manner both internationally and nationally, so are suitable for being independent points of reference."

It stressed that the KSH is "professionally independent and trustworthy in its functioning, and acts according to international standards in processing its data.It is according to these national and international standards that it makes the EU-SILC survey, too, Eurostat validates the results of which and publishes them subsequently in its own database every year." 

The KSH added that it would implement, similarly to other EU member states, a revision – for 5 years – based on the 2022 census data.

"Statistical data are collected and processed according to strict professional and ethical rules. The KSH processes all its data series under the appropriate professional supervision, and communicates results in a transparent and accurate way in all cases. The KSH firmly refuses the charge of intentional juggling with figures. The Office can legally examine malicious interpretation, the influencing of public opinion and the damaging of the institution’s reputation," it concluded.

Following the response from the KSH, further research revealed discrepancies in the office's income statistics. Following earlier concerns, it emerged that the pre-tax income of many people is lower than their post-tax income. Furthermore, the problems date back to 2014. Judit Krekó, an economist at the Budapest Institute and the HUN-REN Centre for Economic and Regional Studies, examined the situation of disabled people using the database and also came across some unusual phenomena.

The main problem that arose was that

  • a suspiciously large number of people were found to have received the tax (or contribution) without paying for it.
  • Furthermore, the irregularities were found to have occurred over a much longer period than previously thought, stretching back as far as 2014.

Researchers discovered some intriguing findings among retirees. The sample included several hundred individuals with exactly the same net income, but what is even stranger is that

  1. their gross income, i.e., their income before deductions, differed significantly from one another, and
  2. their gross income was lower than their net income.

What happened was that when the missing data was supplemented, gross incomes were supplemented, mostly by just enough to bring the people in the sample above the poverty line. In fact, their net income was exactly the same: HUF 1.3 million per year.

In other words, this strictly regulated imputation was carried out in a highly specific manner. The researchers also identified other issues, such as the absurdly high volatility of the poverty gap between individual years, which is discussed in more detail in this study.

‘We work within a framework controlled by Eurostat. This does not allow for methodological errors,” Tamás Tóth said at Monday's briefing. "It is debatable whether the methodology was sufficiently sophisticated. We have complied with the methodological framework in the past, and we continue to do so now,” he emphasised.

He noted that the survey was conducted during the pandemic, when many respondents were reluctant to answer questions and did not allow officials into their homes.

Nevertheless, the KSH's research on poverty has consistently produced accurate data. Tamás Tóth added that, "although it was not our job, we attempted to provide our fellow researchers with a satisfactory response by incorporating their suggestions into the methodology."

Cover image (for illustration purposes only): Getty Images

 

More in Economy

benzin_3
February 27, 2026 13:45

Could the price of petrol really leap to HUF 1,000 a litre in Hungary?

The situation is more complex than it may seem at first glance

adó-munkaerőpiac-foglalkoztatás-szocho-adókedvezmény
February 27, 2026 09:46

The labour market situation is deteriorating in Hungary

Employment hits five-year low

D_MTI20260210007
February 27, 2026 09:18

Hungary's Orbán plans new steps with Fico to bring back Druzhba flow

Prime Minister speaks in regular interview

szijjártó péter
February 26, 2026 16:56

Ukraine summons Hungary's chargé d'affaires in Kyiv - MoFA

Conflict remains heated

Mol Dunai Finomító Dufi kőolajfinomító benzin naplemente
February 26, 2026 16:42

Hungary's Mol threatens Janaf, sets Friday deadline

The oil company may turn to the European Commission

LATEST NEWS
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts, spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas

Detailed search