(Adds details, charts) When Hungary’s OTP Bank releases its earnings report for the fourth quarter of 2012 we said that while the bank’s results were behind expectations there were positive developments “below the surface", as the deterioration of portfolio quality had greatly decelerated. At that time many were hoping that the accumulation of overdue loans will peak out, the time when the NPL ratio starts to drop is closer, OTP may reverse provisions and that could lead to a jump in its profits. But what happened in the first quarter seems to be everything but what we witnessed in Q4 2012. The bank beat the consensus estimates on virtually every row, but “below the surface" it looks like something is beginning to turn bad again. The NPL ratio rose considerably at every important operation and the pace of loan quality deterioration has also picked up. Investors who prefer focusing on portfolio quality instead of the current revenue and profit numbers will not be happy about these quarterly data.
Positive items in the flash report:
Profits above the market’s call on almost every row
Hungary Core and the key foreign subsidiaries (Bulgaria, Russia, Ukraine) all posted profits
Consumer lending in bloom in Russia and Ukraine which is positive for revenues
Net interest margin rose to nearly 19%, a never before seen level at the Russian unit
Lower-than-expected provisions at group level. Provisions have not been this low since mid-2011, whereas DPD90+ coverage rose further to 80.3%
Capital adequacy of the group remains outstanding
Negative items in the flash report:
The loan portfolio deterioration continued, the DPD90+ ratio grew to 19.9% from 19.1%; portfolio quality worsened at each of the key operations
Interest margin eroded on a group level, reaching its lowest of the past six years in Hungary, partly due to the contraction of the loan portfolio and partly due to the lower interest environment.
Stronger than expected quarter.
If we examine only the main results, OTP beat the expectations on almost every earnings row. This overperformance starts on the total income row, which shows that the consensus estimate was 1.5% smaller than the actual figure. And as operating expenses came in as expected operating profit turned out to be almost 3% larger than what the market envisaged.
OTP’s provisions for loan losses were the smallest in Q1 since mid-2011. It is partly thanks to this why pre-tax profit beat the median forecast by 10% and why after-tax profit exceeded the consensus by 14% despite a much higher-than-expected corporate tax payment.
The amount of after tax profit was significantly influenced by the meaningful increase in tax burden (consolidated effective tax rate in Q1 2013: 30% vs. 15% in Q1 2012). The main reason for this was the tax-shield effect of the revaluation of subsidiary investments (the amount of tax effect in HUF billion: 1Q 2012: 3.8 tax savings, 4Q 2012: 2.0 additional tax payment, 1Q 2013: 4.2 additional tax payment).
The accounting profit of the Group represented HUF 11.2 billion versus HUF 26.1 billion in the previous quarter and HUF 12.8 billion a year earlier. The single biggest adjustment item was the banking tax, which represents the same amount as in 2012 and similarly to last year the total annual amount was recognised in Q1.
As for after-tax profit OTP has - after faltering in Q4 2012 - once again beaten the market’s call, as its HUF 11.2 bn profit is 14% higher than the HUF 9.9 bn consensus.
Revenues turned out to be bigger in Q1 this year than in the base period and interest income, as well as net fee and commission income rose yr/yr. As provisioning decreased by nearly HUF 4 bn yr/yr, pre-tax profit went up 13%. The HUF 12.4% decline in after-tax profit is attributable to an increase in the effective tax burden due to a weaker HUF in Q1 and a negative tax shield stemming from the revaluation effect on investments in foreign subsidiaries. Also, as in 2012 OTP paid in full its bank tax obligation in the first quarter.
Charting is displayed using TradingView's technology, a platform, where you can build advanced charts,
spot upcoming trends in the stock screener, and find inspiration in multiple trading ideas