Hungary found to have broken law on refugees

Portfolio
Hungary has failed to meet its EU obligations when it refused to take part in a mandatory refugee quota scheme, Eleanor Sharpston, Advocate General at the European Court of Justice, said on Thursday.
menekült kvóta

Hungary has not been the sole subject of the lawsuit, and Sharpston also reprimanded Poland and the Czech Republic for having refused compliance with the temporary and limited relocation of asylum-seekers.

Sharpston said the EU's highest court should rule that the three countries

have failed to fulfill their obligations under EU law.

"These Member States cannot invoke their responsibilities with regard to the maintenance of law and order and the safeguarding of internal security in order to disapply a valid EU measure with which they disagree," Sharpston said in a statement.

Sharpston said each EU country has to comply with its obligations under EU law and disregarding them because they are unwelcome or unpopular "is a dangerous first step towards the breakdown of the orderly and structured society governed by the rule of law.”

Sharpston's opinion is not legally binding, but such recommendations are usually followed by the European Court of Justice.

The temporary scheme, introduced in 2015, was meant to redistribute 160,000 refugees from Africa and the Middle East after their arrival in Italy and Greece. Eastern European countries refused to participate in the scheme, citing security risks and claiming that accepting refugees would be too much of a burden. At the time the case was taken to court in December 2017, the European Commission said Poland and Hungary hadn't taken in any refugees and the Czech Republic hadn't don't so for more than a year.

Cover photo: Omar Marques/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images

 

More in Economy

GettyImages Pension nyugdíj-idősek-nyár-nyaralás-nyugdíjas-pihenés-strand-szerelem-tengerpart-ünnep
August 04, 2025 16:05

Will there be a referendum on minimum pensions in Hungary? Pensioners have targeted a minimum of HUF 140,000 .

Almost half a million elderly people are receiving pensions that do not cover their basic living costs

suranyi gyorgy
August 04, 2025 10:01

Home Start's 3% mortgage loan fuel housing inflation - György Surányi

Former MNB governor says the state is taking on unsecured liabilities, which is a big risk

fed atlanta sas héja
August 04, 2025 08:48

All eyes on the US this week, major developments afoot

Recession or not, we will find out

DKCSZ20241218005
August 01, 2025 14:06

Budapest Mayor taken by police for questioning

Taking the mugshot was not easy, with Karácsony towering at 197 cm

fgsz földgáz gázszállítás gázvezeték gázár
August 01, 2025 13:05

Hungarian gas reserves haven't been this low in years

It's not a unique phenomenon, though

LATEST NEWS

Detailed search